Fitness TrackersReasons to Buy
5 Reasons to Buy the Fitbit Edge
Wondering if a week of battery is real? Five reasons to buy the Fitbit Edge, three honest reasons not to, and the tracker I'd pick in its place.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.
The short answer
Short answer: if you want a Fitbit with a screen for sleep, heart and all-day health tracking, the Fitbit Edge is the one I'd buy, on Android or iPhone. If you run by GPS distance or pay with your wrist, I'd skip it. The week of battery held up at every outlet that ran one down, and that's the reason I'd lead with. My full Fitbit Edge review has the whole picture. Every measurement here belongs to the outlet that took it.
- Buy it if you want background health tracking, a readable screen and about a week between charges.
- Keep what you have if your Charge 6 still works and you tap to pay with it. The Edge has no NFC.
- Skip it if you train by GPS distance or want sets and reps logged. On Android, the Pixel Watch 5 is my pick for training.
I've put the limit next to every reason below, so nothing surprises you after the box is open.
Buy it ifAndroid or iPhone owners who want background health tracking, a readable screen and a week between charges
Reasons to buy
- A true week of battery with frequent workouts, in both Android Authority's and Droid Life's run-downs
- Light at 32 g with its band, so wearing it to bed is easy, and the 1.3-inch screen is easy to read
- Heart rate tracked a Polar H10 chest strap closely in cycling and running, in one reviewer's test
- Works with Android phones and iPhones, and the battery can be replaced when it fades
Skip it ifSkip it if you pay by wrist or run by GPS distance. Take the Charge 6 for Google Wallet or the Pixel Watch 5 for training.
Reasons to avoid
- No NFC, so no Google Wallet. The older Charge 6 keeps tap-to-pay if you rely on it
- GPS is only average, with signal losses in one test, and the band connector needs a firm click
Prices and availability can change. Details
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
1. It lasts a real week, even with workouts most days
Charging anxiety is the thing a tracker is supposed to end, and plenty of them don't. Say you fly out for a Friday-to-Friday work trip and the cable is still on your dresser. With this band, that's a shrug. Google claims up to 7 days, and for once the published run-downs back the claim up.
| Source | Conditions | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Google claim | Default settings, pre-production units | Up to 7 days |
| Android Authority | Six tracked workouts, nightly sleep; always-on setting not stated | A little over 10% left after 7 days |
| Droid Life | Replacement unit; 4 one-hour treadmill runs, 7 hours of pickleball; always-on setting not stated | Over 8 days, 14% left |
| 9to5Google | Always-on off; no percentages given | One charge in about two weeks |
| Google claim | Always-on display on | Up to 2 days |
Read the middle rows first. Android Authority, Droid Life and 9to5Google each got a week or more, workouts included.
Now the catch, and it's in the last row. Turn the always-on display on and Google itself says up to 2 days. You get a week, or a screen that never sleeps. Not both.
One oddity: Droid Life's first unit, later replaced for a band fault, fell from 89% to 17% in 3 days, cause unknown. If yours drains like that in week one, return it while you can.
My call: this is the main reason to buy.
2. It's light enough to sleep in, and the screen is easy to read
A tracker only knows your sleep if it stays on at night, and bulky ones end up on the nightstand. Picture 2 a.m., on your side, one hand tucked under the pillow. A thick watch digs in there. This band weighs 32 g with its strap, so wearing it to bed is easy.
The case is recycled aluminum, 39.2 x 25.6 x 11.6 mm, in one size. You don't pick a strap length at checkout either, because a small band (130 to 170 mm wrists) and a large one (170 to 210 mm) both come in the box.
Then there's the screen, which is the whole point of choosing this over a screenless band. It's 45% bigger and over 40% brighter than the Charge 6's, per Google, and Android Authority found it readable on sunny outdoor walks and runs. I couldn't find a brightness measurement, so that's a claim plus one report.
Is 32 g the lightest you can get? No. The Fitbit Air is about 12 g with its band, and my Edge against Fitbit Air comparison shows what the screen buys you for the extra weight.
3. Heart rate stayed close to a chest strap in the one test that used one
Can you trust the number on a band this small? Fair question, and for steady cardio the answer looks like yes. Say it's a 9 a.m. Saturday spin class and you're riding to a heart rate zone. That's where this band did its best work.
The evidence comes from The Quantified Scientist, who compared it with a Polar H10 chest strap.
| Activity | Correlation with the Polar H10 |
|---|---|
| Indoor cycling | 0.98 |
| Running | 0.98, with some cadence lock |
| Outdoor cycling | 0.96 |
| Weightlifting | Weak |
A perfect match would read 1.00, so the top three rows are close. Sleep went well too. Against a ZMax EEG headband, he found agreement of 92% for deep sleep, 72% for light and 75% for REM.
Here's the fine print. That's one reviewer, not a consensus. Cadence lock means the band followed his stride rate on some runs, and no fix is confirmed. Lifters get the weakest readings, and the band doesn't log sets and reps anyway.
Want training numbers with no paid tier at all? The Garmin CIRQA landed within about a beat of a chest strap in most published tests, and the Edge against the Garmin CIRQA weighs that screenless band against this one.
My take: trust it for rides, steady runs and sleep. Don't buy it to track a lifting program.
4. It works with an iPhone or an Android phone, and tracking is free
A gift tracker is a gamble when you don't know the phone. Say it's your dad's birthday and you can't remember whether he carries an iPhone or a Samsung. Here it doesn't matter. Google lists phones on Android 11 or newer and iPhones on iOS 16.4 or newer, both through the Google Health app with a Google Account.
| Feature | Android | iPhone | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Activity, sleep score and stages, heart rate, HRV, SpO2, skin temperature, readiness | Yes | Yes | Free |
| ECG app and heart rhythm alerts | Yes, in select countries | Yes, in select countries | Free |
| Blood pressure and insulin resistance trends | Yes | Yes | Free |
| Notifications, media controls, Maps directions started on the phone | Yes | Listed by Google; no outlet checked an iPhone | Free |
| Quick replies to messages | Yes | Unconfirmed | Free |
| Health Coach, personal plans, on-wrist coaching cues, detailed sleep insights | Yes | Yes | Google Health Premium, monthly |
The free rows hold everything a health tracker needs. Only coaching costs extra.
Two catches. Three months of coaching are included, and the trial renews at a monthly fee unless you cancel it. And no outlet paired the band with an iPhone, so that column is Google's word.
A Pixel Watch 5 won't pair with an iPhone at all. On Android, the Edge against the Pixel Watch 5 answers the tracker or smartwatch question.
My read: it's the safe pick for a mixed-phone household.
5. You can replace the battery yourself when it fades
Every rechargeable cell wears down, and on most bands that's when the shopping starts again. Picture an airport gate in 2029, and the band that once ran a week is flat by day three. On a sealed tracker, that's the end. Here, the 65 mAh cell is user-replaceable, which the Charge 6 never offered.
Why does that matter on a band that already lasts a week? Because a week is the reason you bought it. A fresh cell brings that back without buying a new tracker.
Honestly, there's plenty I can't tell you. I couldn't find what a replacement costs. And the band is only weeks old, so I don't have owner reports of a swap to weigh.
Software is the other half of keeping a gadget for years. Google's security update list guarantees the Edge updates until at least October 2028, and it may extend that date while it still sells the band. The promise covers security only, not new features. So I wouldn't count on missing workout tools arriving later.
Three honest reasons not to buy it
Three things could send this band back.
First, there's no NFC, so no Google Wallet. Say your morning walk ends at a coffee counter and your phone is on the kitchen table. This band can't pay.
Second, the GPS is only average. Android Authority's run logged 6.25 miles where Strava and another watch read 6.42, and The Quantified Scientist saw signal losses. No fix is confirmed. Fine for a casual jog, not for a half marathon plan.
Third, the band connector. It came loose or needed force at Android Authority, Droid Life and 9to5Google, and Google's setup page says to push the band in until you hear a clear click, or the tracker may fall off. No fix is confirmed there either.
- Pay by wrist? The Charge 6 keeps Google Wallet. Its built-in GPS is unreliable, so carry your phone on runs.
- Run by GPS distance? On Android, I'd take the Pixel Watch 5 for training.
- Never glance at your wrist? The Fitbit Air is screenless and about 12 g, with no GPS in the band.
- Still unsure? My Fitbit Edge alternatives line up what I'd buy in its place, and the best fitness trackers list sets it beside the wider field.
For the smaller known issues, such as notifications that failed for much of 9to5Google's time with the band, my full Fitbit Edge review tracks where each one stands.
Fitbit Edge specs
- Compatibility
- Android 11 or newer, or iPhone on iOS 16.4 or newer
- Display
- 1.3-inch AMOLED touchscreen, always-on option, Gorilla Glass 3
- Battery
- Up to 7 days; up to 2 days with the always-on display
- GPS
- Built-in GPS and Galileo; no phone needed outdoors
- Water Rating
- 5 ATM and IP68; shallow-water swimming
What the experts found
Comfortable, with a good screen and a true week of battery, but stuck in the middle: no NFC, a bare-bones OS, thin workout features and poor GPS make it overpriced for what it offers.
A light tracker that mostly stays out of the way, lasts a full week of heavy use and finally auto-tracks workouts properly; possibly the best of Google's three, despite a fussy band connector and slow charging.
A new, slightly better Fitbit that does not know what it wants to be: great battery and much better software than older trackers, but no payments, limited use beyond fitness and most features tied to a subscription.
Also consider

Fitbit Charge 6
It keeps Google Wallet tap-to-pay, and Google still sells it new with security updates to at least February 2028. Its built-in GPS is unreliable, so I'd carry a phone on runs, and a full charge takes about two hours.

Google Fitbit Air
A screenless band of about 12 g that tracks sleep, heart rate and steps with no subscription, and lasts close to a week. There's no GPS in the band and nothing to check mid-workout, so I'd skip it for runs.

Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)
Wallet, Maps and on-device Gemini on a polished Wear OS watch for phones on Android 12 or newer. The 41mm is a daily-charge watch, it won't pair with an iPhone, and the Health Coach needs Google Health Premium.
Fitbit Edge: frequently asked questions
Is the Fitbit Edge worth buying?
Yes, if you want a Fitbit with a screen for sleep, heart and all-day health tracking, on Android or iPhone. It's light, the screen is easy to read and the week of battery held up in published run-downs. I'd skip it if you pay with your wrist or run by GPS distance. My full Fitbit Edge review covers every section in depth.
How long does the Fitbit Edge battery last?
About a week with the always-on display off. Android Authority ended day seven with a little over 10% left, and Droid Life's replacement unit ran over eight days. Turn the always-on display on and Google itself says up to 2 days, so decide which you'd rather have before you set it up.
Do you need a subscription for the Fitbit Edge?
No. Google lists activity, sleep score and stages, heart rate, HRV, SpO2, skin temperature and health alerts as free. The Health Coach, personal plans and detailed sleep insights need Google Health Premium. Three months are included, and the trial renews at a monthly fee unless you cancel it.
Does the Fitbit Edge work with an iPhone?
Yes. Google lists iPhones on iOS 16.4 or newer and phones on Android 11 or newer, both through the Google Health app with a Google Account. No outlet checked the band on an iPhone, though, and whether quick replies to messages work there is unconfirmed.
Does the Fitbit Edge have Google Wallet or tap-to-pay?
No. The Edge has no NFC, so it can't pay at a terminal. If you tap to pay with a Charge 6 today, I'd keep it, because that older band has Google Wallet and Google still sells it new. Upgrading would take the feature away.