Deals
All deals
ReviewsIs it worth buying? ComparisonsWhich of these two? AlternativesWhat else is like it? Best PicksWhat's the best one for me? DealsIs now the time to buy?
All categories

Fitness TrackersAlternatives

The 5 Best Fitbit Edge Alternatives in 2027

No tap-to-pay, a screen you never look at, or a coaching fee? These are the best Fitbit Edge alternatives, each matched to the one thing it gives up.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

Google Fitbit Edge

The original

Google Fitbit Edge

Every pick below is measured against this one, and each says exactly how it differs. Read my full review of it first.

My picks at a glance

#1
Google Fitbit Air
Best With No Screen

Google Fitbit Air

Never glance at your wrist? Then the Edge's screen is weight you don't need. The Fitbit Air is about 12 g with its band, ran 199 hours in Which?'s lab and tracks heart rate, sleep and readiness with no subscription, on Android or iPhone. The catch is everything a screen and a GPS chip would give you: no time, no notifications, and distance well out in two published checks.

#2
Garmin CIRQA Smart Band
Best Free Training Scores

Garmin CIRQA Smart Band

Does a coaching fee bother you on principle? Garmin's screenless band includes Sleep Score, HRV Status, Body Battery and Training Readiness with no subscription required, and Tech Advisor measured its heart rate 1 bpm off a chest strap on average. You lose the Edge's screen, built-in GPS and ECG. Battery swings from about five to ten days, and lost workouts have no fix confirmed.

7.8/10Score

$199.99

as of Nov 18, 2026, 18:15 UTC

View on Amazon
#3
Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)
Best Full Smartwatch

Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)

Wanted a smartwatch all along? On an Android 12 or newer phone, the Pixel Watch 5 adds Google Wallet, apps and on-device Gemini to the health tracking, with ECG and Daily Readiness free and dual-frequency GPS. The trade is the battery. The 41mm is a daily-charge watch where the Edge runs a week, it won't pair with an iPhone, and the Health Coach still needs Google Health Premium.

8.4/10Score

$299.99$399.99Save 25%

as of Nov 18, 2026, 18:15 UTC

View on Amazon
#4
Fitbit Charge 6
Best for Paying by Wrist

Fitbit Charge 6

Pay with your wrist? The Edge can't, and its older sibling still can. The Charge 6 keeps Google Wallet tap-to-pay on Android and iPhone, adds an ECG app, and runs about four days with the screen always on. What you give up is the bigger screen, floors climbed and a GPS you can count on: its built-in GPS drops out, with no fix confirmed. A full charge takes about two hours.

7.5/10Score

$134.67$159.95Save 16%

as of Nov 18, 2026, 18:15 UTC

View on Amazon
#5
Fitbit Inspire 3
Best for the Basics

Fitbit Inspire 3

Like the Edge but not the bill? The Inspire 3 is the least expensive Fitbit with a screen: a 17.69 g band that tracks steps, sleep stages and all-day heart rate, with up to 10 days claimed when the always-on display is off. It has no GPS of its own, no ECG and no floors. It's a 2022 band, and owners report battery drain after the 2025 and 2026 updates, with no fix confirmed.

7.1/10Score

$85.00$99.95Save 15%

as of Nov 18, 2026, 18:15 UTC

View on Amazon
Prices and availability can change. Details

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

What I looked at in best Fitbit Edge alternatives

The Fitbit Edge gets a lot right, so most people who look past it have one specific reason. The screen is more than they want, a coaching fee nags at them, they pay by wrist, the bill is too high, or they wanted a real smartwatch all along. I read the hands-on coverage and the owner complaints for each pick, then weighed where they agree. I rank them on Health and Fitness Tracking first, then Battery Life, Cost to Own, Design and Build, and Smart Features. Each entry answers one reason to leave. Find yours, then check what the pick takes away.

Health and Fitness Tracking

Heart rate, sleep and workouts are why you buy a tracker, so a replacement that tracks worse than the Edge isn't one.

Battery Life

A week between charges is the Edge's main strength, and every pick either keeps it or trades it for something.

Cost to Own

What you keep paying matters as much as the tag: paid tiers, extra bands and how long the updates last.

Design and Build

Weight and size decide whether a band stays on through the night, and the night is where the best data comes from.

Smart Features

Payments, apps and an assistant are what the Edge leaves out, so they're why some buyers move on.

How we review products

Best Fitbit Edge alternatives compared

Swipe sideways to see every spec.

ProductScoreCompatibilityDisplayBatteryGPSWater Rating
8.1Android 11+ and iOS 16.4+; Google Health app and Google AccountNone (screenless); one status LED and a vibration motorUp to 7 days; 5 minutes of charging for about a dayNone built in; relies on the paired phone5 ATM (50m); showers and swimming, not diving
7.8iPhone and Android, through the Garmin Connect appNone (screenless); one button and a status LEDUp to 10 days claimed; full charge in up to 90 minutesNo built-in GPS; connected GPS through your phone5 ATM (swim); pool swim profile only
8.4Most Android 12+ phones; needs the Pixel Watch app (no iPhone)41mm or 45mm domed AMOLED LTPO, up to 3000 nitsUp to 30h (41mm) or 40h (45mm) with always-on displayBuilt-in dual-frequency GPS5 ATM and IP68
7.5Android 11+ and iOS 16.4+; Google Health app and Google Account1.04-inch colour AMOLED touchscreen, Gorilla Glass 3Up to 7 days claimed; about 4 days with always-on displayBuilt-in GPS + GLONASS, unreliable; uses phone GPS by defaultWater resistant to 50 m (5 ATM)
7.1iPhone (iOS 16.4+) and Android 11+; Google Health app and accountSmall colour AMOLED touchscreen, Gorilla Glass 3, always-on optionUp to 10 days claimed; about 3 days with always-on displayNo built-in GPS; uses your phone's GPS (connected GPS)5 ATM, water resistant to 50 m

1. Google Fitbit Air: Best Fitbit Edge Alternative Overall

Hands-on reviews from
#1
Google Fitbit Air

If the Edge's screen is the part you'd never look at, I'd send you here first. The Air does the background job at well under half the weight: about 12 g with its band, against 32 g for the Edge. Heart rate, HRV, sleep, steps and readiness all track without paying, on Android or iPhone, through the same Google Health app. And the week of battery survives the diet. Which? ran it for 199 hours in its lab and got six to seven days in daily wear.

Say you wake at 3 a.m. and roll over to check the time out of habit. Nothing lights up, because there's nothing to light. The band has a status light and a vibration motor that buzzes only for alarms. That's the appeal, and it's also the limit. The all-day numbers hold up, with a 1.34% heart rate error overall in that lab. Exercise is shakier: Expert Reviews saw it read 20 to 30 bpm high late in one long workout.

What you give up is a long list. No time, no notifications, no timer and no way to start a workout on the band. There's no GPS in it either, and daily distance was 10.8% out in the Which? lab. Phantom steps and sleep logged while awake have been reported, with no fix confirmed. I also couldn't find a warranty length, and Google lists its security updates to at least May 2028, where the Edge has them until at least October 2028. My Fitbit Air review covers the accuracy split in full. If you want a workout button and tighter heart rate in the gym with no screen, the Garmin CIRQA fits better.

Versus the Fitbit EdgeIt drops the screen, GPS, ECG and notifications, and weighs about 12 g with its band against 32 g. Battery is the same week, and tracking stays free.

Buy it ifAndroid or iPhone owners who want sleep, heart rate and recovery tracked on a band they forget they're wearing

Skip it ifYou want a workout button and tighter heart rate in the gym. The Garmin CIRQA has both, with no screen.

Reasons to buy

  • About 12 g with its band against 32 g for the Edge, so it's easy to sleep in.
  • Heart rate, sleep, steps and readiness track with no subscription.
  • Which? ran it for 199 hours on one charge in its lab, a week like the Edge.
  • Works with Android phones and iPhones through the Google Health app.

Reasons to avoid

  • No screen, no GPS and no workout start on the band; daily distance was 10.8% out in Which?'s lab.
  • Exercise heart rate read 20 to 30 bpm high for Expert Reviews in one long workout.

Expert reviews behind this pick

Worth considering for passive health tracking without a screen: accurate heart rate and steps and a long battery for the money, but poor for runs, cycling and anything you want to check mid-workout.

Comfortable, petite and fine for casual tracking, but not an automatic recommendation: run distance and exercise heart rate were weak against a Garmin, and the AI feedback will irritate some.

Strong hardware for the money and a good first tracker for people who avoid smartwatches; the AI Health Coach makes too many mistakes to be worth the subscription yet.

2. Garmin CIRQA Smart Band: Best Alternative With No Subscription

Hands-on reviews from
#2
Garmin CIRQA Smart Band

7.8/10Score

$199.99

as of Nov 18, 2026, 18:15 UTC

View on Amazon

Maybe the fee itself is what bugs you. The Edge tracks for free, but its Health Coach, personal plans and detailed sleep insights sit behind Google Health Premium. Garmin goes the other way. Sleep Score, HRV Status, Body Battery, Training Readiness, Training Status and VO2 max all come with the band, and Garmin says no subscription is required. It works with iPhone and Android through Garmin Connect, and I couldn't find one feature limited to either.

Picture a Thursday evening Peloton ride in the garage. Hold the button for three seconds and the band broadcasts your heart rate to the bike. That number is one I'd trust. Tech Advisor measured it 1 bpm off a Garmin HRM 600 chest strap on average, and the5krunner got +0.8 bpm in flow yoga and +1.1 bpm in outdoor cycling. Fast running intervals are the exception. On the wrist it ran about 9 to 10 bpm off there, and the cure is an upper arm band sold separately.

Then comes the part I'd read twice before paying. Lost and missed workouts were still being reported in the autumn, with no fix confirmed. Battery runs from about five days to ten depending on how you train, so Garmin's claim isn't a promise. There's no screen, no ECG and no GPS in the band, which means your phone comes on every run. Swimmers get a pool profile only. My Garmin CIRQA review has the full issue list and the workaround for ending workouts. If sleep and steps are all you'd look at, the Fitbit Air does that on a lighter band for less.

Versus the Fitbit EdgeIt's screenless with no built-in GPS and no ECG, but its training and recovery scores need no paid tier. Battery ranges from about five to ten days against the Edge's steady week.

Buy it ifGym, bike and steady-run people on iPhone or Android who want recovery and training scores with no paid tier

Skip it ifSleep and steps are all you'd look at. The Fitbit Air does that on a lighter band for less.

Reasons to buy

  • Training Readiness, Body Battery and HRV Status included, with no subscription required.
  • Heart rate 1 bpm off a chest strap on average, measured by Tech Advisor.
  • A real button starts workouts, and it broadcasts heart rate to bike computers and gym apps.
  • About 21 g with its band, and it can move from the wrist to the upper arm.

Reasons to avoid

  • Lost and missed workouts were still reported in the autumn, with no fix confirmed.
  • No screen, ECG or GPS in the band, and battery swings from about five to ten days.

Expert reviews behind this pick

Well-built, accurate and comfortable with a dependable 10-day battery and no subscription, but the software lacks the depth of Whoop and Oura. Best as a second device for Garmin owners.

Recommended: excellent heart rate in the gym, yoga, cycling and on the biceps, with no compulsory subscription. Wrist readings failed in open water swimming and fast running intervals.

Tech AdvisorEditors' Choice badge; numeric rating not shown in the text read

A great buy for distraction-free tracking: far more data than the Fitbit Air with no subscription. Battery ran shorter than claimed and the workout button needs more options.

3. Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi): Best Full Smartwatch Alternative for Android

Hands-on reviews from
TechRadarEngadgetDigit
#3
Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)

8.4/10Score

$299.99$399.99Save 25%

as of Nov 18, 2026, 18:15 UTC

View on Amazon

Some people buy a tracker and then keep wishing it did more. If that's you, and your phone runs Android 12 or newer, this is a real step up and not a sidestep. The Pixel Watch 5 puts payments, apps and a voice assistant on your wrist, and the Edge has none of the three. Health doesn't shrink to pay for it. ECG, Loss of Pulse Detection, Daily Readiness and the blood pressure, insulin resistance and sleep breathing trends are all free. The 41mm weighs 31.0 g without its band.

Think of a self-checkout with a toddler on one hip and your phone buried in the diaper bag. You tap the watch and walk out. GPS is dual-frequency, and it held up on a London route known for signal blackouts in TechRadar's check of the 45mm. That's a size up from this watch, so I'd call it encouraging and not proven for the 41mm.

But you pay for all of it at the charger. Google claims up to 30 hours with the always-on display, and Digit, the one outlet that ran the 41mm down, got 33 hours 45 minutes without stating its settings. Plan on a dock about once a day, against a week on the Edge. Google's claimed 15 minutes to half full softens that. From late October 2026, some owners also saw sudden battery drain. Google says a fix is rolling out, and owners haven't confirmed it. My Pixel Watch 5 review explains why I'd look at the 45mm, which carries about 40% more battery. On an iPhone, or if a daily dock is a dealbreaker, the Fitbit Charge 6 still pays from the wrist.

Versus the Fitbit EdgeIt adds Google Wallet, apps, on-device Gemini and dual-frequency GPS. The 41mm needs a charge about once a day where the Edge lasts a week, and it won't pair with an iPhone.

Buy it ifOwners of an Android 12 or newer phone who want payments, apps and an assistant with their health tracking, and will dock daily

Skip it ifYou carry an iPhone or won't charge every day. The Fitbit Charge 6 keeps tap-to-pay on a band that lasts days.

Reasons to buy

  • Google Wallet, apps and on-device Gemini on your wrist, none of which the Edge has.
  • ECG, Daily Readiness and the blood pressure and sleep breathing trends are free.
  • Dual-frequency GPS that held up on a tough London route in TechRadar's 45mm check.
  • Updates guaranteed until at least October 2029, and the battery can be replaced.

Reasons to avoid

  • The 41mm is a daily-charge watch, where the Edge runs about a week.
  • Android 12 or newer only, so no iPhone, and the Health Coach needs Google Health Premium.

Expert reviews behind this pick

An iterative upgrade and the best Android watch yet for new buyers, accurate and well made, but battery is short, Gemini isn't truly agentic and Pixel Watch 3 or 4 owners can skip it.

Still a solid smartwatch that does just enough to justify its price rise, with faster offline Gemini, but several features were missing at launch and Pixel Watch 4 owners should not upgrade.

A smart, distinctive watch whose value depends on how deeply you use Gemini and Google Health coaching; not worth buying as a basic smartwatch. Battery makes it easily a one-day watch.

4. Fitbit Charge 6: Best Fitbit Alternative for Tap-to-Pay

Hands-on reviews from
#4
Fitbit Charge 6

7.5/10Score

$134.67$159.95Save 16%

as of Nov 18, 2026, 18:15 UTC

View on Amazon

This one's simple. If you tap to pay, the Edge takes that away, and the band it followed keeps it. Google Wallet on the Charge 6 works on Android and iPhone, without your phone nearby. Google still sells the band new and guarantees security updates until at least February 2028. You keep an ECG app too, and heart rate held 0.93 to 0.94 correlations against a chest strap on bikes and in the gym.

Picture the front desk at your community pool after laps. Your phone and wallet are in a locker down the hall, and you buy a smoothie with your wrist. That's the whole case for this band, and for some people it's enough. Battery isn't far behind the Edge either. Trusted Reviews got about four days with the always-on display and five to seven without it.

Runners should hear the catch first. The built-in GPS fails to lock or drops out when the band is worn snug, with no fix confirmed, so your phone comes on every run. The screen is 1.04 inches against the Edge's 1.3, there's no altimeter for floors, and a full charge takes about two hours. The Daily Readiness Score needs Google Health Premium, where the Edge gives readiness away. And that February 2028 date lands before the Edge's October 2028. I'd buy one new only at a clear discount to the Edge, and my Fitbit Charge 6 review shows how the band has aged. On Android and want payments with a GPS you can trust? That's the Pixel Watch 5.

Versus the Fitbit EdgeIt keeps Google Wallet tap-to-pay, which the Edge lacks. You give up the 1.3-inch screen, the altimeter and the replaceable battery, and its built-in GPS is unreliable.

Buy it ifPeople who pay with their wrist, on Android or iPhone, and carry a phone on runs anyway

Skip it ifYou run without a phone and carry Android. The Pixel Watch 5 has Wallet and dual-frequency GPS.

Reasons to buy

  • Google Wallet tap-to-pay on Android and iPhone, without your phone nearby.
  • Heart rate held 0.93 to 0.94 correlations against a chest strap on bikes and in the gym.
  • About four days per charge with the screen always on, per Trusted Reviews.
  • Still sold new by Google, with security updates until at least February 2028.

Reasons to avoid

  • The built-in GPS drops out or never locks, with no fix confirmed, so runs need your phone.
  • A full charge takes about two hours, and Daily Readiness needs Google Health Premium.

Expert reviews behind this pick

Still a great deal for the price: the button, more on-wrist sport modes, Google apps and better heart rate are real gains, but built-in GPS is still hit-or-miss, so use your phone's GPS.

Android AuthorityAA Recommended badge; no number read

Fitbit's best band-style tracker, with reliable heart rate, a useful button and Google apps, but GPS trouble makes it hard to recommend for serious distance training.

Trusted ReviewsNot captured in the text read

The go-to tracker for accurate daily tracking, rock-solid sleep monitoring and advanced health features at a fair price, but not reliable for GPS or workout heart rate, and some insights need Premium.

5. Fitbit Inspire 3: Best Lower-Cost Fitbit Edge Alternative

Hands-on reviews from
#5
Fitbit Inspire 3

7.1/10Score

$85.00$99.95Save 15%

as of Nov 18, 2026, 18:15 UTC

View on Amazon

Perhaps the Edge does more than you need and costs more than you'd like. Then the least expensive Fitbit with a screen is the honest answer. The Inspire 3 covers steps, sleep stages and all-day heart rate on a 17.69 g band. It works with iPhone and Android, Google still sells it new, and security updates run to at least February 2028. Sleep is its strong suit. Over seven nights against an EEG headband, The Quantified Scientist found about 97% agreement on deep sleep.

Think of a parent who wants a step count for the walk round the block after dinner, and nothing else to learn. This is that band. Google claims up to 10 days with the always-on display off, and DC Rainmaker matched that on a new unit in 2022. Turn the display on and you're at about three days.

Be clear about what's missing, though, because no update can add it later. There's no GPS chip, so a mapped walk needs the phone along. No ECG app, no altimeter, no payments. Heart rate slips when your effort changes fast, so I wouldn't train by zones with it. Age is the bigger risk. Owners report battery drain after the 2025 and 2026 updates, with no fix confirmed, and you can't replace this battery yourself the way you can on the Edge. My Fitbit Inspire 3 review follows those reports. Don't need a screen at all? The Fitbit Air is lighter and tracks sleep and steps with no subscription.

Versus the Fitbit EdgeIt's a smaller, older band at 17.69 g with up to 10 days claimed. It has no GPS of its own, no ECG, no altimeter and a battery you can't replace.

Buy it ifFirst-time buyers who want steps, sleep and resting heart rate on a small band and carry a phone anyway

Skip it ifYou don't need a screen. The Fitbit Air is lighter and tracks sleep and steps with no subscription.

Reasons to buy

  • The least expensive Fitbit with a screen, and Google still sells it new.
  • About ten days per charge when new with the always-on display off.
  • Sleep stages landed close to an EEG headband over seven nights.
  • Light at 17.69 g, with small and large bands both in the box.

Reasons to avoid

  • No GPS in the band, no ECG and no floors, and no update can add them.
  • Owners report battery drain after the 2025 and 2026 updates, with no fix confirmed.

Expert reviews behind this pick

Called it hands-down the best deal in activity trackers at the time: used without Premium it works great for most people, though heart rate is not good enough for precise zones and the paywall balance is off.

The Quantified Scientist (YouTube)Heart rate 2.5/5, sleep stages 4/5, step counting 3/5

The Fitbit he would most likely recommend because it performs like the dearer Versa 4 and Sense 2 for a fraction of the price: good sleep stage tracking, mediocre heart rate, no built-in GPS.

Detailed health tracking at a decent price that helped the reviewer build habits; the small screen, the lack of built-in GPS and its limits around water are the main weaknesses.

Best Fitbit Edge alternatives buying guide for 2027

Why would you look past the Fitbit Edge?

Usually for one of five reasons, and only two of them are faults. Start with what the band does well, because it's a lot: a 1.3-inch screen, built-in GPS, an ECG app and a week of battery that held up at every outlet that ran one down. If that's all you wanted, stop here. My full Fitbit Edge review is the better read, and the reasons to buy the Fitbit Edge are laid out one by one.

Now the gaps. There's no NFC, so it can't pay. Picture a pharmacy counter, a full basket and your wallet out in the car. GPS is only average: Android Authority's run logged 6.25 miles where Strava and another watch read 6.42. The band connector also came loose or needed force at three outlets, with no fix confirmed.

The other three reasons are taste and money.

  • You never look at your wrist. A screenless band is lighter, and two of my picks are screenless.
  • A monthly fee bothers you. Tracking on the Edge is free, but its Health Coach sits in Google Health Premium.
  • You want to spend less. An older Fitbit with a screen covers the basics.

Which one is yours? Each of my five picks answers exactly one.

Do any of these Fitbit Edge alternatives need a subscription?

None of them needs one to work, and neither does the Edge. Here's the part nobody puts on the box, though: what counts as free changes from one band to the next.

DeviceFreePaid tier
Fitbit EdgeTracking, readiness, ECG app, blood pressure trendsHealth Coach, personal plans, detailed sleep insights
Fitbit AirHeart rate, HRV, sleep, steps, readinessAI Health Coach, adaptive plans
Garmin CIRQASleep Score, HRV Status, Body Battery, Training Readiness, VO2 maxOptional; core metrics free
Fitbit Charge 6Heart rate, sleep stages, HRV, ECG app, Google WalletDaily Readiness Score, Gemini coaching
Fitbit Inspire 3Steps, heart rate, sleep stages, HRVWellness report, Gemini coaching
Pixel Watch 5Tracking, ECG, Daily Readiness, health trendsHealth Coach, run coaching

Read the Charge 6 row twice. Its Daily Readiness Score needs Google Health Premium, while the Edge, the Air and the Pixel Watch give readiness away. On the Inspire 3, whether that score is free isn't settled.

Bottom lineNever want to see a renewal email? The Garmin CIRQA is the cleanest answer, because its recovery and training scores come with the band. The Fitbit Air is close: only its coach is paid.

One fine-print note. The Edge includes a three-month coaching trial that renews at a monthly fee unless you cancel, so I'd set a phone reminder the day you unbox it.

How long does each alternative last between charges?

Days for the four bands, and about one day for the watch. I've put the maker's number beside a published run for each, because the two don't always agree.

DeviceMaker claimPublished runConditions
Fitbit EdgeUp to 7 daysOver 8 days, 14% left, Droid LifeReplacement unit; always-on setting not stated
Fitbit AirUp to a week199 hours, Which?Lab, single charge
Garmin CIRQAUp to 10 daysAbout 10 days, Wareable; about 5 days, Tech AdvisorAbout two months of wear; two workouts and one walk
Fitbit Charge 6Up to 7 daysAbout 4 days, Trusted ReviewsAlways-on display on
Fitbit Inspire 3Up to 10 daysAbout 10 days, DC RainmakerNew unit in 2022, raise-to-wake
Pixel Watch 5, 41mmUp to 30 hours, always-on33 h 45 min, DigitSettings not stated

The Air and the Edge both deliver their week. The CIRQA's ten days depends on how hard you train, so don't plan a nine-day road trip around it. And the Inspire 3 carries an age warning: owners report drain after the 2025 and 2026 updates, with no fix confirmed.

Heads-upLeaving the Edge for the Pixel Watch 5 means trading a week for about a day.

My call: if battery is what you liked about the Edge, the Air is the only pick that fully keeps it.

Can you leave your phone at home on a run with any of them?

Honestly, only with the watch. This is the one place where swapping the Edge for another band makes things worse.

Say you run a lunchtime loop from the office and want the distance on your wrist when you're back at your desk.

DeviceGPS in the deviceWhat the evidence says
Fitbit EdgeBuilt inRated average, with signal losses, by The Quantified Scientist
Fitbit AirNoneDaily distance 10.8% out in Which?'s lab
Garmin CIRQANone; borrows the phone'sNo outdoor distance, pace or map with the phone left at home
Fitbit Charge 6Built inFails to lock or drops out when worn snug; no fix confirmed
Fitbit Inspire 3None; borrows the phone'sEvery mapped run needs the phone along
Pixel Watch 5Built in, dual-frequencyHeld up on a London route known for signal blackouts, per TechRadar

The Charge 6 has a GPS chip on paper, and the Edge still beats it. Trusted Reviews watched the older band give up after about 10 minutes each time and concluded, "Standalone GPS tracking is essentially unusable." TechRadar's check was on the 45mm, and nobody has published one for the 41mm.

If phone-free runs matter to you, none of the four bands is a step up from the Edge. Take the Pixel Watch 5 on Android, or start from my best fitness trackers list.

Which alternative works with your phone, and which can pay?

Check the phone first, because it removes one pick outright.

DeviceiPhoneAndroidTap-to-payApp
Fitbit EdgeiOS 16.4 or newerAndroid 11 or newerNoGoogle Health
Fitbit AiriOS 16.4 or higherAndroid 11 or higherNoGoogle Health
Garmin CIRQAYes; minimum version not publishedYes; minimum version not publishedNone listedGarmin Connect
Fitbit Charge 6iOS 16.4 or newerAndroid 11 or newerGoogle WalletGoogle Health
Fitbit Inspire 3iOS 16.4 or higherAndroid 11 or higherNoGoogle Health
Pixel Watch 5NoAndroid 12 or newerGoogle WalletPixel Watch app

An iPhone rules out the Pixel Watch 5 completely, and it's the only pick with that limit. Buying a pair as a gift for a couple with one iPhone and one Android phone? Any of the four bands works on both.

Payments are rarer than you'd expect. Only the Charge 6 and the Pixel Watch have Google Wallet, and on the Charge 6 it works on Android and iPhone alike.

There's an account question as well. Every Fitbit here, the Edge included, needs a Google Account and won't set up without one. The Pixel Watch needs one too. If you'd rather not tie your health data to Google, the Garmin runs through Garmin Connect instead.

Which one should you pick?

Work down the list and stop at the first line that sounds like you.

One more check before you order: fit. The Air's fabric loop is one size, listed for 130 to 210 mm wrists. The CIRQA's pod is the same size on both bands and overhangs wrists under about 6.5 inches. Both older Fitbits include a small and a large band.

The Edge and the Pixel Watch also ship with no power adapter, so check sizes and bands on Amazon first.

Where I'd go nextNot sure a band is right at all? How to choose between a band and a smartwatch settles that before the model. Leaning to a watch? Smartwatch picks ranked for iPhone and Android covers the full watches.

Best Fitbit Edge alternatives: frequently asked questions

What is the best Fitbit Edge alternative?

It depends on why you're leaving. For most people it's a screen they never look at, so my first pick is the Fitbit Air: about 12 g with its band, a week of battery and tracking with no subscription. Pay by wrist? Take the Fitbit Charge 6. Want a full smartwatch on Android? That's the Pixel Watch 5. If nothing about the Edge bothers you, keep it.

Which Fitbit Edge alternative has tap-to-pay?

Two of the five. The Fitbit Charge 6 keeps Google Wallet tap-to-pay on Android and iPhone, without your phone nearby. The Pixel Watch 5 has Wallet too, but it only pairs with phones on Android 12 or newer. The Fitbit Air and the Inspire 3 can't pay, and neither can the Edge. I couldn't find payments listed for the Garmin CIRQA.

Is there a Fitbit Edge alternative with no subscription?

None of the five needs one to track. The Garmin CIRQA goes furthest: Garmin says no subscription is required, and Training Readiness, Body Battery and HRV Status are included. The Fitbit Air tracks heart rate, sleep, steps and readiness for free and keeps only its coach in the paid tier. On the Charge 6, the Daily Readiness Score needs Google Health Premium.

Which Fitbit Edge alternatives work with an iPhone?

Four of the five. Google lists iOS 16.4 or newer for the Fitbit Air, the Charge 6 and the Inspire 3, and the Garmin CIRQA works with iPhone through Garmin Connect, though Garmin hasn't published a minimum iOS version. The Pixel Watch 5 won't pair with an iPhone at all. On an iPhone I'd take the Air for no screen, or the Charge 6 to pay.

Is the Fitbit Air or the Garmin CIRQA the better screenless band?

The Air for sleep and steps, the CIRQA for training. The Air is lighter, about 12 g with its band against 20.7 g, and its week of battery is steadier. The CIRQA adds a workout button and included training scores, and Tech Advisor measured its heart rate 1 bpm off a chest strap on average. Neither has GPS in the band, so runs need your phone.

Keep reading