Fitbit Edge vs Fitbit Charge 6: Should You Upgrade?
You gain a bigger screen, floors and a replaceable battery, and you lose tap-to-pay. Fitbit Edge vs Charge 6: who should upgrade and who should stay.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

Google Fitbit Edge
7.7/10Score

Fitbit Charge 6
7.5/10Score
Prices and availability can change. Details
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
The short answer
Short answer: if your Charge 6 still works, I'd keep it, and I wouldn't think twice if you pay with your wrist. The Fitbit Edge has no NFC, so Google Wallet doesn't come with you.
I'd upgrade for three things only: the 1.3-inch screen, floors climbed, and a battery you can replace when it fades. The heart-rate evidence is stronger on the Edge too. Its GPS is better than the Charge 6's, but it isn't cured, so anyone who trains by distance shouldn't expect a fix.
Buying new while Google sells both? I'd take the Edge, unless tap-to-pay matters to you, or the Charge 6 costs clearly less when you shop and your phone rides along on runs. Check both on Amazon on the same day.
Which to choose
Choose the Fitbit Edge if
New buyers who want the bigger screen, floors, a replaceable battery and the later update date, and who never pay by wrist. That's who I'd send to the Edge.
Choose the Charge 6 if
Owners whose Charge 6 still works, anyone who taps to pay, and buyers who find it well below the Edge and carry a phone on runs. I'd stay or buy it.
Where they differ
| Area | Fitbit Edge | Charge 6 |
|---|---|---|
| Screen Google says the Edge's screen is 45% bigger and over 40% brighter. That's its claim, and I found no brightness measurement. | 1.3-inch AMOLED | 1.04-inch AMOLED |
| Tap-to-pay The one loss that should stop an upgrade on its own. | None, no NFC | Google Wallet, on Android and iPhone |
| Altimeter The Charge 6 can't count a flight of stairs. | Yes, floors and elevation | None |
| Battery life Always-on display off or not stated. With it on, the Charge 6 has the better published figure. | Up to 7 days claimed; 7 to 8 days in published runs | Up to 7 days claimed; about 5 to 7 days at Trusted Reviews |
| Full charge Google's Edge time assumes a 30W adapter, sold separately. | About 90 minutes, claimed | Two hours |
| Battery you can replace I couldn't find what a replacement cell costs. | Yes | No |
| Heart rate against a chest strap The Quantified Scientist, against a Polar H10, in separate tests. Weightlifting flips: 0.90 on the Charge 6, weak on the Edge. | 0.98 running, 0.98 indoor cycling, 0.96 outdoor cycling | 0.87 running, 0.94 indoor cycling, 0.93 outdoor cycling |
| Built-in GPS Better, not fixed. I wouldn't upgrade for GPS alone. | Average, with signal losses | Unreliable; phone GPS advised |
| Weight Google doesn't say whether the Charge 6 figure includes a band, so I won't call a winner. | 17.7 g bare, 32 g with band | 30 g, Google spec |
| Security updates, at least Security only, and Google may extend both dates while it still sells the bands. | October 2028 | February 2028 |
Should you upgrade from a Charge 6?
Two questions settle this before any spec does. Do you pay with your wrist, and is something about your Charge 6 bugging you? Picture the coffee stop after a Wednesday walk, phone left on the kitchen counter. Your Charge 6 pays for that latte. The Edge can't.
- Keep your Charge 6 if you tap to pay. The Edge has no NFC, so the upgrade takes Google Wallet away.
- Keep it if it still works and nothing below tempts you. Google guarantees its security updates until at least February 2028.
- Upgrade if you want floors and elevation. The Edge has an altimeter, and the Charge 6 doesn't.
- Upgrade if the 1.04-inch screen feels cramped. The Edge's is 1.3 inches.
- Upgrade if a fading battery worries you. You can replace the Edge's cell yourself. You can't on the Charge 6.
- Don't upgrade for GPS alone. The Edge's is only average, so a distance runner trades a big problem for a smaller one.
Your phone doesn't decide this one. Both bands need Android 11 or newer, or an iPhone on iOS 16.4 or newer, plus the Google Health app and a Google Account.
So here's my call: stay put unless a rule above names something you'd notice every day. And if you're leaning toward the switch, my full Fitbit Edge review covers the band connector, which is the part I'd read twice before paying.
What do you gain by moving to the Edge?
The list is short, and most of it is certain. I couldn't find an outlet that wore the two side by side, so the table is specs and Google's own claims.
| What changes | Charge 6 | Fitbit Edge | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Screen | 1.04-inch AMOLED | 1.3-inch AMOLED | More room for stats and messages |
| Altimeter | None | Yes | Floors and elevation get counted |
| Side button | Haptic, pressure-sensitive | Mechanical | A real click under your finger |
| Battery | Not replaceable | Replaceable by you | A faded cell doesn't end the band |
| Health trends | No blood pressure or insulin resistance trends | Monthly blood pressure and insulin resistance trends | Two more long-term signals, free |
| Security updates, at least | February 2028 | October 2028 | Eight more months of patches |
Now the fine print on that screen. Google says it's 45% bigger and over 40% brighter than the Charge 6's. That's a claim, because I found no brightness measurement for either band.
The altimeter is the gain you'd feel soonest. Say your office is on the fourth floor and you take the stairs every morning. The Charge 6 has never counted one of those flights. The Edge will.
Weight I'd hold loosely. Google lists the Edge at 17.7 g bare and 32 g with its band, and the Charge 6 at 30 g without saying whether a band is included.
What do you lose, and what is unconfirmed?
One loss is certain, and for some of you it ends the conversation. The Charge 6 pays through Google Wallet without your phone nearby, on Android and iPhone. The Edge has no NFC at all. Google told 9to5Google that hardly anyone paid with Wallet on the last generation. That explains the cut, and it doesn't help you one bit if you were one of the few.
Then there's the stress scan. The Charge 6 has an EDA scan, and Google doesn't list one for the Edge. Nobody has confirmed it's gone, so I'd treat it as missing until someone shows otherwise.
You also pick up a new worry. The Edge's band connector came loose or needed force at Android Authority, Droid Life and 9to5Google.
Who shouldn't move, then? Anyone who taps to pay most weeks, and anyone who leans on that stress scan. If that's you, my Fitbit Charge 6 review explains how the older band has aged and why I'd still keep one that works.
Are heart rate and GPS really better on the Edge?
Yes for heart rate, on the one set of numbers that exists. For GPS, better isn't the same as fixed.
The Quantified Scientist compared each band with a Polar H10 chest strap, the Edge this year and the Charge 6 in his long-term Charge 6 test. Those are separate tests on one person, not a head-to-head.
| Activity | Fitbit Edge | Charge 6 |
|---|---|---|
| Indoor cycling | 0.98 | 0.94, over 12 sessions |
| Running | 0.98, with some cadence lock | 0.87, with cadence lock on some runs |
| Outdoor cycling | 0.96 | 0.93, over 36 rides |
| Weightlifting | Weak | 0.90 |
| Built-in GPS, no phone | Rated average: a quick fix, then signal losses | Rated 1 out of 5: late fixes and dropouts |
Read the last two rows before you celebrate. If your week is kettlebells in the garage, the Charge 6 has the better number, so lifters gain nothing here. Sleep is a draw too. He found the Edge tracks sleep just as well as the Charge 6 he re-tested.
Now GPS. Google claims 40% better accuracy than the Charge 6 from internal tests, and that's a claim, not a result. Android Authority's run logged 6.25 miles where Strava and another watch read 6.42. That still beats a Charge 6 that Trusted Reviews watched give up after about 10 minutes each time. Its line: "Standalone GPS tracking is essentially unusable."
Honestly, if you train by GPS distance, neither band is your answer. The best fitness trackers list is where I'd look instead.
Does the Edge last longer between charges?
Google prints the same promise on both, up to 7 days, so the claim tells you nothing. The published runs do.
| Conditions | Fitbit Edge | Charge 6 |
|---|---|---|
| Google's claim, default settings | Up to 7 days | Up to 7 days |
| Always-on display off, or setting not stated | A little over 10% left after 7 days, Android Authority. Over 8 days with 14% left, Droid Life. One charge in about two weeks, 9to5Google | About 5 to 7 days with it off, Trusted Reviews |
| Always-on display on | Up to 2 days, Google's claim | About 4 days, Trusted Reviews. About 4 to 5 days with a longer night-time screen-off window, DC Rainmaker. 2 to 3.5 days through heavy GPS trials, Android Authority |
| Full charge | About 90 minutes, claimed, with a 30W adapter | Two hours, claimed. About two hours from around 5%, Trusted Reviews |
Say you leave Friday for a four-day trip and forget the cable. The Edge's runs say you come home with charge to spare. The Charge 6 should make it too, if the screen isn't always on.
Always-on is where I'd slow down. The Edge's only figure is Google's own, up to 2 days, while the Charge 6 managed about 4 at Trusted Reviews and in DC Rainmaker's run. I can't tell you the Edge wins with the screen lit all day.
What about an aging Charge 6? Owners on r/fitbit with units about two years old still report about a week between charges. So don't upgrade out of fear. When a battery does fade, though, only the Edge's 65 mAh cell can be swapped by you, and I couldn't find what a replacement costs.
Buying new: which one while Google sells both?
Starting from zero, with no Charge 6 on your wrist, I'd buy the Edge. But one habit flips that.
- Get the Fitbit Edge if you want a Fitbit with a screen for sleep, heart and all-day health tracking, and you never pay by wrist.
- Get the Charge 6 if tap-to-pay matters, your phone rides along on runs, and it costs clearly less than the Edge when you shop.
- Skip both if you run or ride without a phone and care about distance.
Before you pay, I'd run three checks.
- Compare both on Amazon on the same day. The Charge 6 only makes sense well below the Edge.
- Look in a drawer for a 30W power adapter. The Edge's box has a cable and no adapter, and Google's charge times assume one.
- Check readiness in the app. Google lists readiness as free on the Edge and puts the Charge 6's Daily Readiness Score behind Premium.
Want something smaller? The Edge against the Inspire 3 covers the least expensive Fitbit with a screen, and the Edge against the Fitbit Air shows what going screenless costs you. If neither fits, my Fitbit Edge alternatives line up the others I'd weigh.
Specs side by side
| Spec | Fitbit Edge | Charge 6 |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | Android 11 or newer, or iPhone on iOS 16.4 or newer | Android 11+ and iOS 16.4+; Google Health app and Google Account |
| Display | 1.3-inch AMOLED touchscreen, always-on option, Gorilla Glass 3 | 1.04-inch colour AMOLED touchscreen, Gorilla Glass 3 |
| Battery | Up to 7 days; up to 2 days with the always-on display | Up to 7 days claimed; about 4 days with always-on display |
| GPS | Built-in GPS and Galileo; no phone needed outdoors | Built-in GPS + GLONASS, unreliable; uses phone GPS by default |
| Water Rating | 5 ATM and IP68; shallow-water swimming | Water resistant to 50 m (5 ATM) |
What the experts found
Google Fitbit Edge
Comfortable, with a good screen and a true week of battery, but stuck in the middle: no NFC, a bare-bones OS, thin workout features and poor GPS make it overpriced for what it offers.
A light tracker that mostly stays out of the way, lasts a full week of heavy use and finally auto-tracks workouts properly; possibly the best of Google's three, despite a fussy band connector and slow charging.
A new, slightly better Fitbit that does not know what it wants to be: great battery and much better software than older trackers, but no payments, limited use beyond fitness and most features tied to a subscription.
Fitbit Charge 6
Still a great deal for the price: the button, more on-wrist sport modes, Google apps and better heart rate are real gains, but built-in GPS is still hit-or-miss, so use your phone's GPS.
Fitbit's best band-style tracker, with reliable heart rate, a useful button and Google apps, but GPS trouble makes it hard to recommend for serious distance training.
The go-to tracker for accurate daily tracking, rock-solid sleep monitoring and advanced health features at a fair price, but not reliable for GPS or workout heart rate, and some insights need Premium.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Fitbit Edge worth upgrading to from a Charge 6?
Yes, if you want the bigger screen, floors climbed and a replaceable battery, and you never pay with your wrist. No, if you tap to pay, because the Edge drops NFC and Google Wallet with it. If your Charge 6 still works and none of those three gains would change your day, I'd keep it. Google guarantees its security updates until at least February 2028.
Does the Fitbit Edge have Google Wallet like the Charge 6?
No. The Edge has no NFC, so it can't pay at a terminal. The Charge 6 keeps Google Wallet tap-to-pay, which works without your phone nearby, on Android and iPhone. If you pay by wrist even once a week, that's the reason I'd stay on the Charge 6, or buy one new.
Is the Fitbit Edge GPS better than the Charge 6?
Better, but not fixed. The Quantified Scientist rated the Edge's GPS average, with a quick fix and then signal losses, and Android Authority's run logged 6.25 miles where Strava and another watch read 6.42. The Charge 6 fails to lock or drops out when the band is worn snug, and no fix has been confirmed. Google's claim of 40% better accuracy comes from its own internal tests.
Does the Fitbit Edge battery last longer than the Charge 6?
A little, with the screen off. Google claims up to 7 days for both. The Edge's published runs reach 7 to 8 days with frequent workouts, against about 5 to 7 days for the Charge 6 at Trusted Reviews. With the always-on display on, Google says up to 2 days for the Edge, while the Charge 6 ran about 4 days. A full charge is about 90 minutes claimed on the Edge and two hours on the Charge 6.
Is the Charge 6 still worth buying now that the Fitbit Edge is out?
Yes, for one buyer: you want tap-to-pay, your phone comes along on runs, and you find it at a clear discount to the Edge. Google still sells it new. Everyone else buying fresh should take the Edge for the screen, the altimeter, the replaceable battery and security updates to at least October 2028.