Fitbit Edge vs Garmin CIRQA: Screen or No Screen?
One band has a screen and GPS, the other has neither. See how Fitbit Edge vs Garmin CIRQA compares on battery, costs and phone-free use, and which to buy.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

Google Fitbit Edge
7.7/10Score

Garmin CIRQA Smart Band
7.8/10Score
Prices and availability can change. Details
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
The short answer
Do you want to look at your wrist, or forget it's there? That's the whole choice. The Fitbit Edge gives you a 1.3-inch screen, GPS in the band and an ECG app, and its week of battery held at every outlet that ran one down. The Garmin CIRQA has no screen and no GPS, but Garmin's training and recovery numbers come with no subscription. No outlet has worn the two side by side, so where I line them up, it's specs and separate tests. Coming from the Fitbit side, I'd buy the Edge. If you train by Garmin's numbers and want nothing lighting up on your arm, get the CIRQA.
Which to choose
Choose the Fitbit Edge if
You want the time, your stats and your texts on your wrist, GPS without your phone and an ECG app. Paying by wrist and exact GPS distance don't matter to you.
Choose the CIRQA Smart Band if
You want no screen at all, plus Training Readiness and Body Battery with no subscription. Your phone comes on every run, and a five to ten day battery swing is fine by you.
Where they differ
| Area | Fitbit Edge | CIRQA Smart Band |
|---|---|---|
| Screen This is the choice itself. The Edge wins if you want to see anything, the CIRQA if you don't. | 1.3-inch AMOLED touchscreen, always-on option | None; one button and a status LED |
| Size and weight Spec figures. The CIRQA pod is long, and the5krunner found it overhangs wrists under about 6.5 inches. | 39.2 x 25.6 x 11.6 mm; 32 g with band | 27 x 47 x 9 mm; about 21 g with band |
| GPS Android Authority's one run logged 6.25 miles on the Edge where Strava and another watch read 6.42. | Built-in GPS and Galileo | None; borrows your phone's GPS |
| Claimed battery Garmin's figure assumes about 30 minutes of exercise a day with Pulse Ox off, per DC Rainmaker. | Up to 7 days; up to 2 with the always-on display | Up to 10 days |
| Battery in published runs Separate runs with different habits, never side by side. The Edge was the steadier of the two. | 7 to over 8 days | About 5 to about 10 days |
| Full charge Nobody timed the Edge. Droid Life thinks it took about the claimed 90 minutes. | About 90 minutes claimed; 30W adapter not included | Up to 90 minutes claimed; just over 1 h 10 min at Tech Advisor |
| ECG and floors | ECG app in select countries; altimeter for floors | No ECG; no altimeter |
| Training and recovery numbers | Readiness free; coaching paid | Training Readiness, Training Status, Body Battery, HRV Status, all free |
| Subscription The Edge's three-month Premium trial renews at a monthly fee unless you cancel. | None required; Health Coach needs Google Health Premium | None required; Connect+ is optional |
| Phone notifications 9to5Google had Edge notifications fail for much of its time with the band. No fix confirmed. | On the screen, with media controls | A vibration only, since firmware 4.20 |
Screen or no screen: what's on your arm all day
Picture a Thursday budget meeting that has run long. With the Edge you glance down and see the time and who just texted. With the CIRQA you see a fabric strap, and that's the point of it.
| On the band | Fitbit Edge | Garmin CIRQA |
|---|---|---|
| The time and your stats | On a 1.3-inch AMOLED touchscreen | No screen; one button and a status LED |
| Phone notifications | Shown on the screen | A vibration only, since firmware 4.20 |
| Size and weight | 39.2 x 25.6 x 11.6 mm; 32 g with band | 27 x 47 x 9 mm; about 21 g with band |
| Where it's worn | Wrist | Wrist, or upper arm with a band sold separately |
Read that as two different jobs: a small dashboard against a sensor you forget about. It's a spec comparison, built from each maker's figures and the Gadgets & Wearables spec table, because nobody has worn both at once.
Two warnings before you pick. The CIRQA is lighter and thinner, but its pod is long, and the5krunner found it overhangs wrists under about 6.5 inches. You also choose S/M or L/XL at checkout, while the Edge puts both band sizes in the box. And the Edge's screen has a soft spot: 9to5Google had notifications fail for much of its time with the band, with no fix confirmed.
My call: if you'd check your wrist even once a day, get the Edge. Like Google's app but want no screen? The Edge against the Fitbit Air is the comparison to read, since that's Google's own screenless band.
Battery and charging: every published figure
Which one dies on you first? Honestly, the CIRQA is the harder one to predict. Google claims up to 7 days for the Edge, or up to 2 with the always-on display. Garmin claims up to 10. Here's what the published runs found.
| Band | Who and how | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Fitbit Edge | Android Authority: six tracked workouts, nightly sleep; always-on setting not stated | A little over 10% left after 7 days |
| Fitbit Edge | Droid Life: replacement unit, 4 one-hour treadmill runs; always-on setting not stated | Over 8 days, 14% left |
| Garmin CIRQA | Wareable: day and night, about two months | About 10 days |
| Garmin CIRQA | Tech Advisor: two workouts and one walk | About 5 days |
| Garmin CIRQA | DC Rainmaker: 1 to 3 hours of training a day | 10% to 30% a day |
The pattern matters more than any one row. The Edge landed at a week or a bit more in both run-downs, workouts included. The CIRQA's runs flatly disagree, and its drain follows how much you train. Say you're building toward a half marathon with an hour on the road most days: I'd plan on about five days and treat anything more as a bonus. One Edge caveat: Droid Life's first unit fell from 89% to 17% in 3 days before it was replaced for a band fault.
Charging is close. Google claims about 90 minutes for the Edge, with a 30W adapter that isn't in the box. Tech Advisor timed the CIRQA at just over 1 h 10 min from empty on its bundled cable. I couldn't find whether Garmin includes a power adapter. Bottom line: get the Edge if you want a battery you can predict.
Phone left behind: what each band still does
Say it's Saturday morning and your phone is locked in the car at the trailhead. That's where these two bands stop being similar.
| Situation | Fitbit Edge | Garmin CIRQA |
|---|---|---|
| Outdoor run, phone left behind | Distance and pace from built-in GPS | Workout and heart rate recorded; no outdoor distance, pace or map |
| Checking the time or your numbers | On the screen | Nothing until you open Garmin Connect on the phone |
| First setup | Needs a phone and a Google Account | Needs a phone and the Garmin Connect app |
| Phones supported | Android 11 or newer; iPhone on iOS 16.4 or newer | iPhone and Android; minimum versions not published |
The Edge wins that table by having GPS at all, and I wouldn't read more into it. On one Android Authority run it logged 6.25 miles where Strava and another watch read 6.42. The Quantified Scientist saw signal losses and rated its GPS average.
Neither band replaces a phone, though. The Edge shows Maps directions only when you start them on the phone, and it can't pay or take a call. If that's what you were hoping for, the fitness tracker or smartwatch guide is the place to start.
Here's where I land. For phone-free runs where rough distance is enough, get the Edge. If you'd carry the phone anyway, this round doesn't count against the CIRQA. Train by exact distance? I wouldn't pick either.
Heart rate and sleep: separate tests, no head-to-head
Can you trust the numbers? For steady effort, yes on both. But each band was checked against a different yardstick by a different person, so I can't rank them.
Those numbers show where each band is strong and where it slips. The Edge figures come from The Quantified Scientist, who also found it weak in weightlifting and saw cadence lock on some runs. The CIRQA stayed within about a beat of a chest strap in gym, yoga, cycling and steady run tests. It slipped in fast intervals on the wrist, then came within 0.3 bpm once the5krunner moved it to the upper arm. In open water it read about 20 to 30 bpm low.
Sleep is the same story. The Edge agreed with a ZMax EEG headband on 92% of deep sleep, 72% of light and 75% of REM. The CIRQA's published check is the5krunner's 14 nights against an Eight Sleep mattress sensor, where resting heart rate sat 0.4 bpm above it. A mattress sensor isn't an EEG, so that settles nothing.
Picture your Tuesday 6 p.m. spin class: either band is fine there. If most of your week is barbells, I'd lean CIRQA. If it's hard intervals, plan on Garmin's upper arm band, which is sold separately.
What each one costs to keep
Will either band keep billing you? No, and that surprises people on the Fitbit side. Both track sleep, heart rate and recovery for free. The difference is what sits behind each optional paid tier.
| What you get | Fitbit Edge | Garmin CIRQA |
|---|---|---|
| Sleep score, heart rate, HRV, skin temperature | Free | Free |
| Readiness and training numbers | Readiness free | Training Readiness, Training Status, Body Battery and VO2 max, all free |
| Coaching and personal plans | Google Health Premium, monthly | Garmin Coach plans, in the optional Connect+ plan |
| ECG app and heart rhythm alerts | Free, in select countries | Not on the band |
| Extras you may end up buying | A 30W power adapter | The upper arm band |
Garmin gives away the training numbers the CIRQA is bought for, and Tech Advisor never felt the need for Connect+. Google gives away the tracking and the ECG, and charges for the coach.
Now the long-run fine print. You can replace the Edge's battery yourself, though I couldn't find what a replacement costs. Security updates run to at least October 2028 for the Edge and at least 21 July 2028 for the CIRQA. My verdict on cost: if you'd never pay for coaching, neither band asks for anything more after the box.
Who should buy which: rules by habit
Still torn? Then stop comparing features and answer one question: when you raise your wrist, do you want something to be there?
- Get the Fitbit Edge if you want the time, your stats and your texts on your wrist, with about a week between charges.
- Get the Fitbit Edge if you want an ECG app or floors climbed. The CIRQA has neither.
- Get the Garmin CIRQA if you want Training Readiness and Body Battery with no subscription, and your training is gym work, yoga, cycling or steady runs.
- Skip the Edge if you pay with your wrist or train by GPS distance.
- Skip the CIRQA if you want GPS without your phone, or you swim in open water.
- Already wear a Garmin watch? Add the CIRQA only if you won't sleep or lift in the watch, because it repeats the same data.
Know both before you pay. My full Fitbit Edge review goes deeper on the band connector and the notification gaps, and my Garmin CIRQA review covers the lost workouts and the battery swings. Neither band feels right? The closest options are in Fitbit Edge alternatives, and the best fitness trackers list ranks the wider field.
If this were my money, I'd buy the Edge. But say you roll in from a long Sunday ride and all you want is Training Readiness waiting in the app on Monday. That's the CIRQA.
Specs side by side
| Spec | Fitbit Edge | CIRQA Smart Band |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | Android 11 or newer, or iPhone on iOS 16.4 or newer | iPhone and Android, through the Garmin Connect app |
| Display | 1.3-inch AMOLED touchscreen, always-on option, Gorilla Glass 3 | None (screenless); one button and a status LED |
| Battery | Up to 7 days; up to 2 days with the always-on display | Up to 10 days claimed; full charge in up to 90 minutes |
| GPS | Built-in GPS and Galileo; no phone needed outdoors | No built-in GPS; connected GPS through your phone |
| Water Rating | 5 ATM and IP68; shallow-water swimming | 5 ATM (swim); pool swim profile only |
What the experts found
Google Fitbit Edge
Comfortable, with a good screen and a true week of battery, but stuck in the middle: no NFC, a bare-bones OS, thin workout features and poor GPS make it overpriced for what it offers.
A light tracker that mostly stays out of the way, lasts a full week of heavy use and finally auto-tracks workouts properly; possibly the best of Google's three, despite a fussy band connector and slow charging.
A new, slightly better Fitbit that does not know what it wants to be: great battery and much better software than older trackers, but no payments, limited use beyond fitness and most features tied to a subscription.
Garmin CIRQA Smart Band
Well-built, accurate and comfortable with a dependable 10-day battery and no subscription, but the software lacks the depth of Whoop and Oura. Best as a second device for Garmin owners.
Recommended: excellent heart rate in the gym, yoga, cycling and on the biceps, with no compulsory subscription. Wrist readings failed in open water swimming and fast running intervals.
A great buy for distraction-free tracking: far more data than the Fitbit Air with no subscription. Battery ran shorter than claimed and the workout button needs more options.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Fitbit Edge or the Garmin CIRQA better?
It depends on whether you want a screen. The Edge has a 1.3-inch touchscreen, built-in GPS and an ECG app, and I'd buy it if you like seeing the time and your stats. The CIRQA is screenless, with Garmin's training and recovery numbers and no subscription. No outlet has worn the two side by side, so nobody can call a measured winner.
Do you need a subscription for the Fitbit Edge or the Garmin CIRQA?
No, for either one. Google lists activity, sleep score and stages, heart rate, HRV, SpO2 and skin temperature as free on the Edge, and only the Health Coach and personal plans need Google Health Premium. Garmin says no subscription is required for the CIRQA, and Training Readiness, Body Battery and HRV Status are all free.
Can you run without your phone with either band?
With the Edge, yes. It has built-in GPS, though the evidence so far says it's only average. The CIRQA has no GPS and borrows your phone's, so outdoor distance, pace and a map only work with the phone carried. You can still start a workout from its button and record heart rate.
Which lasts longer, the Fitbit Edge or the Garmin CIRQA?
On claims, the CIRQA, at up to 10 days against up to 7. In published runs it's less clear. Android Authority ended day seven with a little over 10% left on the Edge, and Droid Life's replacement unit ran over eight days. The CIRQA ranged from about 10 days at Wareable to about 5 at Tech Advisor.
Do the Fitbit Edge and Garmin CIRQA work with an iPhone?
Yes, both do. The Edge needs iOS 16.4 or newer, the Google Health app and a Google Account, though no outlet checked it on an iPhone. The CIRQA works with iPhone and Android through Garmin Connect, and I couldn't find a feature limited to either. Garmin hasn't published a minimum iOS version.