Deals
All deals
ReviewsIs it worth buying? ComparisonsWhich of these two? AlternativesWhat else is like it? Best PicksWhat's the best one for me? DealsIs now the time to buy?
All categories

EarbudsReasons to Buy

5 Reasons to Buy the AirPods 5 (and Who Should Skip Them)

Hate the plugged feel of ear tips? Five reasons to buy the AirPods 5, four honest reasons to skip them, and the pair I'd get in their place.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

The short answer

Short answer: if you carry an iPhone and can't stand the plugged-up feel of silicone tips, I'd buy the AirPods 5, and I'd take the Wireless Charging Case version. They're light, their noise cancelling is the best Apple has put in an open-fit bud, and Transparency sounds natural. The catch is a battery that runs four to five hours with noise cancelling on, and an open fit that can't seal out noise like tipped buds. My AirPods 5 review has the whole picture, and every measurement here belongs to the outlet that took it.

  • Buy them if you use an iPhone, dislike ear tips and want less noise on a commute or at work.
  • Keep what you have if your AirPods 4 with ANC still work, since the gain is real but modest.
  • Skip them if you fly long hauls, run hard or carry an Android phone. The AirPods Pro 3, the Powerbeats Pro 2 and the Galaxy Buds4 Pro fit those buyers better.

I picked the five reasons below because each one holds up across the evidence, and the last section is the honest case against.

Buy it ifiPhone owners who dislike ear tips and want noise cut on commutes and in the office

Reasons to buy

  • No tips to plug your ears, and at 4.3 g a bud they're comfortable for hours if AirPods 4 suited you
  • Noise cancelling that clearly beats the AirPods 4, with a 59% average cut measured by SoundGuys
  • Transparency so natural you hear people and traffic without pulling a bud out
  • IP57 buds handle sweat and rain better than the IP54 AirPods 4

Skip it ifSkip them if you fly often or need a sealed fit; get the AirPods Pro 3. On a Galaxy phone, get the Galaxy Buds4 Pro, and for hard runs the Powerbeats Pro 2.

Reasons to avoid

  • Only 4 to 5 hours with ANC on, so a long flight needs a stop in the case
  • On Android they're plain Bluetooth buds, with no Spatial Audio, Live Translation or Siri AI

$129.00

as of Nov 17, 2026, 22:15 UTC

View on Amazon
Prices and availability can change. Details

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

1. They're light, open and easy to forget in your ears

Some ears simply hate silicone tips, and that suction feeling is the reason plenty of people give up on earbuds. If that's you, start here. The AirPods 5 rest in the outer ear with no tips at all, in one size, and each bud weighs 4.3 g.

4.3 gper earbud, Apple
4 h 44 minflight worn with no discomfort, Gizmodo

Most of the evidence backs the comfort up. Gizmodo wore a pair through a flight of 4 hours 44 minutes with no discomfort. T3 says they almost disappear in the ear, and Expert Reviews counts them among the most comfortable earbuds it has worn, after about a month.

Picture a slow Saturday at home: laundry, dishes and a podcast queue that runs past lunch. Tipped buds would have you twisting one out by noon. These are the kind you forget until the episode ends.

But one outlet disagrees, and I won't hide it. SoundGuys found the housing started to rub after about 30 minutes. Gizmodo says the fit is the same as AirPods 4, so your ears already know the answer. If AirPods 4 sat well, count this reason in. If they slipped or ached, these will too.

2. The noise cancelling is the best Apple has put in an open-fit bud

Open earbuds have always meant hearing most of the room, and this is the pair that finally narrows that gap. SoundGuys measured a 59% average drop in perceived outside noise, the best it has recorded on open-ear buds.

59%average perceived noise cut, SoundGuys
1 to 9 kHzwhere the ANC works best
Under 500 Hzwhere it is weak

Read that row as a map of your day: steady mid and high noise drops a lot, deep rumble doesn't. Take a busy cafe on a Saturday morning, laptop open. The clatter of cups and the hum of the room fall back, though Engadget found voices reduced but still there.

And the step over AirPods 4 is real. Apple claims up to 1.5x, and Headphonesty's measurement, via iThinkDifferent, put the gain at about 3 dB more attenuation. Engadget, Gizmodo, T3 and Expert Reviews all heard a clear improvement, most of all on steady noise.

Here's the limit. With no tips, there's almost no passive isolation behind the ANC, so this isn't a new class of quiet. If your noise is a cafe, an office or a street, I'd call this a strong reason. If it's a rumbling subway, my AirPods 5 against Pro 3 comparison weighs that trade.

3. Transparency sounds natural, so you stay part of the room

Blocking noise is only half the job. The other half is letting the world back in without pulling a bud out, and that's where these stand out most. Gizmodo, T3, SoundGuys and Expert Reviews all praise Transparency here as natural, close to wearing nothing at all. Four outlets on one side is about as solid as agreement gets.

Picture walking the dog at dusk on a road with no sidewalk. You want your audiobook, and you also want to hear the car coming up behind you. Transparency covers that, and the open shape helps, since nothing seals your ear in the first place.

Apple also lists Adaptive Audio and Conversation Awareness among the noise features. I couldn't find an outlet that measured how well they switch, so I'd treat them as extras, not reasons.

Calls fit in this picture, with a catch. Gizmodo found the mic clear. But Expert Reviews heard Voice Isolation over-process in very loud places, leaving the voice compressed and choppy, and SoundGuys flags wind as a weakness. So for a call in a gusty parking lot, I'd step into the lobby first.

My take: if your day swings between your audio and the people around you, this reason carries real weight. If you want to vanish into silence, it's the wrong tool.

4. IP57 buds shrug off sweat and a summer storm

Earbuds that quit after one sweaty summer are an expensive lesson. The AirPods 5 earbuds carry an IP57 rating, up from IP54 on the AirPods 4, so sweat and rain worry them less.

Say you're mowing the lawn on a sticky August afternoon and a storm rolls in before you finish the back yard. That's the kind of day the rating is for. You finish the job, wipe the buds on your shirt and carry on.

Now the fine print, because two things bite later. First, Apple doesn't state a water rating for the case, so keep it in a dry pocket, not on a wet bench. Second, water resistance isn't grip. Expert Reviews says they may not be secure enough for running, and with one size there are no tips to tighten the fit. SoundGuys adds that the bass thins out quickly when the fit is loose, so a bud that shifts also sounds worse.

So read this reason as weather and everyday sweat: a brisk walk, yard work, a rainy commute. For sprints and long runs, ear hooks win, and AirPods 5 vs Powerbeats Pro 2 shows the trade. My Powerbeats Pro 2 review covers the hooks in detail.

5. On an iPhone you get every feature, and the wireless case is worth it

On an iPhone, you get the whole package, and that's a big part of why these are worth it. Expert Reviews says Spatial Audio with head tracking works well on iPhone, and a personalized profile needs an iPhone with a TrueDepth camera. Switching is automatic across Apple devices. Find My works on iOS 27 or later, and a custom three-band EQ arrives with iOS 27, stored on the earbuds, per T3.

Now think of an evening: you finish a podcast on your iPhone at the kitchen counter, then sit down at your Mac to work. The buds follow you across, with no trip to Bluetooth settings.

Live Translation and Siri AI are on the list too, but both are in beta, and Expert Reviews says Live Translation struggled with simple conversation. I'd count them as previews.

Then there's the case, and this is where I'd spend a little more. The Wireless Charging Case version charges by USB-C, any Qi-certified charger or an Apple Watch charger. It adds a speaker so Find My can play a sound, swipe volume on the stem and an extra hour of noise cancelling, with the same sound and ANC. Gizmodo calls it a steal for the small difference. The base and wireless case comparison goes row by row.

Who should skip the AirPods 5, and what to get instead

Four kinds of buyer should walk away, and one should simply wait. Here they are, with the pair I'd pick instead.

  • Long flights: Apple claims 4 hours with ANC on the base model and 5 on the wireless one, and Engadget, T3 and Gizmodo found the wireless model near empty at about 4.5 to 5 hours.
  • Real quiet: without tips, the ANC can't match sealed buds, and deep rumble gets through.
  • Android: they work as ordinary Bluetooth earbuds, with no Spatial Audio, Live Translation or Siri AI.
  • Hard workouts: one size and no hooks, so they may not stay put on a run.

Imagine you've booked a nine-hour flight to London. You'd have the buds back in the case well before landing, and five minutes there buys only about an hour, per Apple's spec sheet. The AirPods Pro 3 claim 8 hours with ANC and seal out far more, so long hauls and loud trains point there. My AirPods Pro 3 review covers the long-haul pick.

On a Galaxy phone, my Galaxy Buds4 Pro review is where I'd start, and AirPods 5 vs Galaxy Buds4 Pro lays out the swap. For a trail half marathon, take the Powerbeats Pro 2.

And if your AirPods 4 with ANC still work, keep them. My AirPods 4 to AirPods 5 upgrade check shows why the gain is modest, and my AirPods 4 review explains what you'd keep.

Where I'd go nextWant the AirPods 5 ranked against other pairs? The four earbuds I'd buy for an iPhone sorts them by habit. Not sold after all? My alternatives to the AirPods 5 start from the reason you'd switch. Still weighing Apple's range? How to choose between every current AirPods walks through each model.

AirPods 5 specs

Compatibility
Best on iPhone; basic Bluetooth on Android and Windows
Noise Cancelling
Open-ear ANC, Transparency, Adaptive Audio, Conversation Awareness
Battery
ANC on: base 4h, wireless case model 5h; case 20h or 22h
Case and Charging
Base USB-C only; wireless model adds Qi, Watch charger, speaker
Water Rating
IP57 earbuds; case rating not stated

What the experts found

Engadget8.8/10

The Wireless Charging Case model is the better buy; there should be only one AirPods 5 model, and the base version is a tough sell.

SoundGuys6.4/10

Fit determines nearly everything: well-fitting ears get strong open-ear performance, poor-fitting ears should buy a sealed earbud; the wireless case model is worth it if affordable.

Gizmodo4.5 (Editor's Choice 2026)

An easy recommendation; the Wireless Charging Case model is an absolute steal for a small step up, better than AirPods 4 in every way with virtually no downsides.

Also consider

Apple AirPods Pro 3
Best for flights and loud commutes

Apple AirPods Pro 3

Silicone tips in five sizes seal out far more noise, Apple claims 8 hours with ANC, and it adds heart rate and a hearing aid mode. It costs more, and I'd only pay that if quiet or battery comes first.

$179.00$249.00Save 28%

as of Nov 17, 2026, 22:15 UTC

View on Amazon
Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro
Best for Galaxy phone owners

Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro

IP57 buds, strong noise cancelling and a claimed 6 hours with ANC on, with full features on a recent Galaxy phone. On an iPhone it drops to plain ANC earbuds with no app, so I'd keep it for Galaxy owners.

$226.88$249.99Save 9%

as of Nov 17, 2026, 22:15 UTC

View on Amazon
Beats Powerbeats Pro 2
Best for runners and the gym

Beats Powerbeats Pro 2

Ear hooks keep it in place, and Beats claims 8 hours with ANC on. The case is large and the buds are only IPX4, so I'd pick it for training rather than an everyday pocket pair.

$249.00

as of Nov 17, 2026, 22:15 UTC

View on Amazon

AirPods 5: frequently asked questions

Are the AirPods 5 worth buying?

Yes, if you carry an iPhone and dislike ear tips. They're light, the noise cancelling is the best Apple has put in an open-fit bud and Transparency sounds natural. I'd skip them if you fly long hauls, run hard or use Android, and I'd take the Wireless Charging Case model. My AirPods 5 review covers every section in depth.

Are the AirPods 5 worth it over the AirPods 4 with ANC?

If you own the AirPods 4 with ANC and they work, I'd keep them. The AirPods 5 add stronger noise cancelling, IP57 buds and, on the wireless model, an hour more battery with ANC on. That's a real gain but a modest one. Apple has stopped selling the AirPods 4 with ANC, so new buyers should start with the AirPods 5.

How long does the AirPods 5 battery last?

Apple claims up to 4 hours with ANC on the base model and 5 hours on the wireless model, and 20 or 22 hours with the case. Measured runs on the wireless model ended near empty at about 4.5 to 5 hours. Five minutes in the case gives about an hour, so plan a stop on long trips.

Are the AirPods 5 good for running and the gym?

They're IP57 against sweat and water, but Expert Reviews says they may not be secure enough for running, and there are no tips to tighten the fit. For walks and light gym work they're fine if AirPods 4 stayed in your ears. For hard workouts, I'd pick ear hooks like the Powerbeats Pro 2.

Do the AirPods 5 block noise as well as the AirPods Pro 3?

No. SoundGuys found the ANC weak on deep rumble below about 500 Hz, and voices and train announcements still come through. The open fit gives almost no passive isolation. If silence on planes and trains is the goal, the AirPods Pro 3 with sealed tips are the better pick, and they claim 8 hours with ANC.

Keep reading

Apple AirPods 5View on Amazon