AirPods 5 vs AirPods 4: Is the Upgrade Worth It?
Own AirPods 4 or eyeing a marked-down pair? AirPods 5 vs AirPods 4 on noise cancelling, battery, cases and fit, with a clear keep, upgrade or skip call.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

Apple AirPods 5
8.3/10Score

Apple AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation
7.4/10Score
Prices and availability can change. Details
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
The short answer
Short answer: if your AirPods 4 with ANC still fit and hold a charge, I'd keep them. The AirPods 5 keep the same H2 chip, shape and 4.3 g weight, and add stronger noise cancelling, IP57 buds and, on the Wireless Charging Case model only, an extra hour with ANC on and swipe volume. It's a real step, just not one most ANC owners will notice.
The plain AirPods 4 are a different story. They have no noise cancelling at all, so moving up buys ANC, Transparency and Live Translation, and I'd upgrade.
Buying new? I'd take the AirPods 5 with the Wireless Charging Case over a discounted AirPods 4. Apple stopped selling the AirPods 4 in September 2026, and when I checked in November, Amazon showed only used offers, which means an unknown battery and a warranty question.
Which to choose
Choose the AirPods 5 if
New buyers, plain AirPods 4 owners who want noise cancelling, and anyone whose old pair is fading. I'd take the wireless case model.
Choose the AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation if
AirPods 4 with ANC owners whose pair still fits and lasts the day, or an iPhone buyer who finds a sealed new pair at a clear discount.
Where they differ
| Area | AirPods 5 | AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation |
|---|---|---|
| Noise cancelling SoundGuys measured the AirPods 5 ahead of its AirPods 4 result. Headphonesty put the gain near 3 dB. | Stronger open-fit ANC; Apple claims up to 1.5x | Open-fit hybrid ANC |
| Water rating Better against sweat and rain. Apple states no rating for the AirPods 5 case. | IP57 earbuds | IP54 |
| ANC battery, buds Apple claims. The extra hour comes only with the Wireless Charging Case. | Up to 4 h base, 5 h wireless case model | Up to 4 h |
| Total with case, ANC on Apple claims. | Up to 20 h base, 22 h wireless case model | Up to 20 h |
| Case charging The base AirPods 5 case is a step back here. | Base USB-C only; wireless model adds Qi and Apple Watch charger | USB-C, Qi, Apple Watch charger |
| Case speaker Only the wireless AirPods 5 case can play a sound to be found. | Wireless case model only | Yes |
| Swipe volume Handy when your phone is buried in a bag. | Wireless case model only | No |
| Fit, chip and weight Same shape, so your ears already know the answer. | Open fit, H2, 4.3 g per bud | Open fit, H2, 4.3 g per bud |
| Sound BGR calls the improvement slight. | Clearer vocals, a little more bass, per Gizmodo | Balanced; Notebookcheck measured near neutral |
| Availability Buy an AirPods 4 only new, sealed and clearly discounted. | On sale since 18 September 2026 | Discontinued September 2026; Amazon showed used offers only in November 2026 |
Should you upgrade from the AirPods 4?
Worried you bought the AirPods 4 a year too early? Honestly, you probably didn't, if yours is the ANC model. The AirPods 5 refine the same earbud, so what you already own decides more than what's new.
- Keep your AirPods 4 with ANC if they stay in, the battery covers your day and you mostly listen indoors. Digital Trends says indoor listeners may not feel the improvements enough to replace a good pair.
- Upgrade from the plain AirPods 4 if you want noise cancelling. That model has none, so the jump is far bigger.
- Upgrade from the AirPods 4 with ANC if you commute or travel in steady noise, get caught in rain or adjust volume often. That's where stronger ANC, IP57 and swipe volume earn their keep.
- Pick the Wireless Charging Case model if you're moving up from the ANC pair. The base AirPods 5 drop the wireless charging and case speaker you already have.
- Skip both if open-fit AirPods have never stayed in your ears. The shape didn't change.
MacRumors sums it up for ANC owners as "not a strong case to upgrade", and it sees a stronger case for owners of the standard AirPods 4. That matches my read of the evidence.
Picture an evening at the laundromat, dryers droning while you fold. Your AirPods 4 with ANC already turn that down, and the AirPods 5 turn it down a bit more. Would you pay again for a bit more? For most ANC owners, I wouldn't.
What do you gain over the AirPods 4 with ANC?
Three things change, and two of them depend on which case you pick. Here's the full list side by side, with what each line means once the buds are in.
| Feature | AirPods 4 with ANC | AirPods 5 | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Noise cancelling | Open-fit hybrid ANC | Stronger; Apple claims up to 1.5x | Steady hum drops further |
| Water rating | IP54 | IP57 earbuds | Sweat and rain matter less |
| ANC battery, buds | Up to 4 h | 4 h base, 5 h wireless case model | The extra hour comes only with the wireless case |
| Swipe volume | No | Wireless case model only | Volume without reaching for your phone |
| Case charging | USB-C, Qi, Apple Watch charger | Base: USB-C only; wireless model: the same three | The base case is a step back |
| Case speaker | Yes | Wireless case model only | Same story as charging |
| Chip, Bluetooth, weight | H2, 5.3, 4.3 g | Same | Nothing new inside the bud |
So the noise cut is the gain you'd actually hear. SoundGuys measured a 59% average cut in perceived noise on the AirPods 5 and says that beats its AirPods 4 result. But Apple's 1.5x is a claim, and Headphonesty's measurement, via iThinkDifferent, put the real gain at about 3 dB more attenuation. Engadget heard the difference most on constant noise like air conditioning, with voices still coming through.
That callout is the fine print spec sheets skip. Say your AirPods 4 case sleeps on a Qi pad by the front door: the base AirPods 5 would send you back to a cable every few days. My breakdown of the two AirPods 5 cases weighs that choice in full.
Coming from the plain AirPods 4, is the jump bigger?
Yes, much bigger, and this is the owner I'd push to upgrade. The plain AirPods 4 share the open fit, the H2 chip, Spatial Audio and head gestures, but they have no noise cancelling and none of the modes built on it.
| Feature | AirPods 4 (no ANC) | AirPods 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Noise cancelling | None | Open-fit ANC on both models |
| Transparency, Adaptive Audio, Conversation Awareness | No | Yes |
| Live Translation | No | Yes, with Apple Intelligence; beta |
| Water rating | IP54 | IP57 earbuds |
| Battery, buds, noise control off | Up to 5 h | Up to 6 h base, 7 h wireless case model |
| Case | USB-C only, no speaker | Base the same; wireless model adds Qi, Apple Watch charger and a speaker |
| Fit, H2 chip, Spatial Audio, head gestures | Yes | Same |
Read that table as a list of gains with nothing taken away, even on the base model. Its case works just like the one you have now, USB-C and no speaker. That's the one situation where I'd call the base AirPods 5 a fine buy, though I'd still lean toward the wireless case for the speaker and the extra hour. And the base AirPods 5 bring ANC at the launch price the plain AirPods 4 had.
Here's where it pays off. Say you study in a library where the air handling hums all afternoon. The plain AirPods 4 can only play over it. The AirPods 5 cancel steady noise like that best, and Transparency still lets you hear the desk staff when they call your row.
If you own the plain pair and your ears like the shape, I'd upgrade without much hesitation.
Do the AirPods 5 last longer on a charge?
Only a little, and only on one model. That's the honest answer if you hoped the new pair would fix the short charge. With ANC on, the base AirPods 5 claim the same 4 hours as the AirPods 4 with ANC.
The claims barely move, so the measured runs matter more. Here's every timed run on file for the two pairs, with the conditions each outlet used.
| Source | Model | Conditions | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engadget | AirPods 5, wireless case | ANC on, Spatial Audio off | 5 to 7% left at 5 h |
| T3 | AirPods 5, wireless case | Continuous ANC listening | 12% left after about 4.5 h |
| SoundGuys | AirPods 4 with ANC | ANC and Transparency off | 6 h 21 min |
| Notebookcheck | AirPods 4 with ANC | 65 dB(A), ANC off | Nearly 7 h |
What to take from it: nobody published a timed ANC run for the AirPods 4, and every AirPods 5 run used the wireless model. So the 4 hours on the base AirPods 5 and on the AirPods 4 both rest on Apple's word. Apple claims 5 minutes in the case gives about an hour on either pair.
Picture a six-hour drive in the passenger seat, ANC on from breakfast onward. Either pair needs a case stop before you arrive. If that bothers you, one more hour won't solve it, and my AirPods Pro 3 review covers the pair Apple claims runs 8 hours with ANC.
Is a discounted AirPods 4 still a smart buy?
Spotted an AirPods 4 with ANC marked down beside the new box? Here's the part nobody prints on the shelf tag. Apple stopped selling both AirPods 4 models in September 2026. MacRumors reports retailers still carry them, but when I checked in November 2026, Amazon's listing showed only used offers.
So I'd buy one only new, sealed, at a clear discount, for an iPhone, and only if open-fit AirPods already stay in your ears. Even then, you're paying for weaker ANC, IP54 and 4 hours with noise cancelling, while the AirPods 5 launched for less than the AirPods 4 with ANC did.
That warning weighs more on a discontinued pair. Three owners in one MacRumors thread describe one bud losing volume or crackling, and the first poster got a warranty replacement with the same fault. That's a few posters, not a failure rate. But Notebookcheck notes the buds aren't repairable, so a worn battery stays worn.
Say a local seller lists a pair as barely used. You can't check the battery wear, the warranty status or whether a bud rings. That's why I'd pass. If the price gap is what pulls you, check today's price on the card for both, and my AirPods 4 review covers the rest of that call.
What stays the same, and who should look elsewhere?
Fit is the big one, and it cuts both ways. Gizmodo says the AirPods 5 fit the same as the AirPods 4, and BGR found the same shape and the same 4.3 g per bud. So if your AirPods 4 sit well, the new pair will too. If they slipped out or ached, the AirPods 5 won't fix that, with still no tips and one size.
Sound moves less than you might hope. BGR calls the improvement slight. Gizmodo heard clearer vocals and a little more low-end thump, yet says the new tuning isn't always better than the AirPods 4's. SoundGuys leans the other way, saying the AirPods 4 treble would sound tinny beside the newer pair. Either way, sound alone isn't a reason to upgrade.
Your phone matters the same on both. On an iPhone you get Spatial Audio, Live Translation and Find My, which needs iOS 27 or later on the AirPods 5. On Android, both work as ordinary Bluetooth earbuds.
- Get the AirPods Pro 3 if you fly often or ride loud trains. Sealed tips block far more, and AirPods 5 vs AirPods Pro 3 weighs that step.
- Get the Galaxy Buds4 Pro if your phone is a Galaxy, as my Galaxy Buds4 Pro review for Galaxy owners explains.
- Get the Powerbeats Pro 2 if you need buds that stay locked in on a hard run.
Still weighing the whole range? My guide on which AirPods to buy sorts every model, the best earbuds for iPhone list widens the field, and my AirPods 5 review has the full picture.
Specs side by side
| Spec | AirPods 5 | AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | Best on iPhone; basic Bluetooth on Android and Windows | iPhone best (iOS features); basic Bluetooth on Android and Windows |
| Noise Cancelling | Open-ear ANC, Transparency, Adaptive Audio, Conversation Awareness | Yes, hybrid ANC in open-fit buds; Transparency and Adaptive Audio |
| Battery | ANC on: base 4h, wireless case model 5h; case 20h or 22h | Claimed 4 h ANC on, 5 h off; case to 20 h ANC on, 30 h off |
| Case and Charging | Base USB-C only; wireless model adds Qi, Watch charger, speaker | USB-C, Qi and Apple Watch wireless charging, Find My speaker |
| Water Rating | IP57 earbuds; case rating not stated | IP54 (dust, sweat, splashes) |
What the experts found
Apple AirPods 5
The Wireless Charging Case model is the better buy; there should be only one AirPods 5 model, and the base version is a tough sell.
Fit determines nearly everything: well-fitting ears get strong open-ear performance, poor-fitting ears should buy a sealed earbud; the wireless case model is worth it if affordable.
An easy recommendation; the Wireless Charging Case model is an absolute steal for a small step up, better than AirPods 4 in every way with virtually no downsides.
Apple AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation
A great effort to bring ANC to unsealed AirPods, suited mainly to casual listeners and iPhone or Mac users; weak isolation and AAC only.
Impressive semi-in-ear earbuds: very effective ANC for the type, outstanding balanced sound and useful head gestures, but not secure for sport, average battery and full features only inside Apple's ecosystem.
The best ANC on the market for people who hate ear tips, with punchy sound and a long list of Apple features that earn its price; weaker than AirPods Pro, and poor value off Apple devices.
Frequently asked questions
Is it worth upgrading from the AirPods 4 to the AirPods 5?
It depends on which AirPods 4 you own. From the AirPods 4 with ANC, I'd usually keep them: the AirPods 5 add stronger ANC, IP57 and, on the wireless case model, an hour more with ANC on, but the fit, chip and weight are the same. From the plain AirPods 4, which have no noise cancelling, I'd upgrade.
Do the AirPods 5 cancel more noise than the AirPods 4 with ANC?
Yes, but not dramatically. Apple claims up to 1.5x, and SoundGuys measured a 59% average cut in perceived noise on the AirPods 5, better than its AirPods 4 result. Headphonesty put the real gain at about 3 dB, per iThinkDifferent. Steady hum drops most, while voices and deep rumble still come through on both open-fit pairs.
Do the AirPods 5 last longer than the AirPods 4?
Only the Wireless Charging Case model does, on paper. Apple claims 5 hours with ANC on for it, against 4 hours for both the base AirPods 5 and the AirPods 4 with ANC. Measured runs on the wireless model ended near empty at about 4.5 to 5 hours, and no timed ANC run exists for the AirPods 4.
Should I buy a discounted AirPods 4 instead of the AirPods 5?
Only if it's new, sealed and clearly cheaper, you use an iPhone and open-fit AirPods already stay in your ears. Apple stopped selling the AirPods 4 in September 2026, and in November Amazon showed only used offers. A used pair brings an unknown battery, and the buds aren't repairable, so I'd buy the AirPods 5.
Which AirPods 5 should an AirPods 4 with ANC owner buy?
The Wireless Charging Case model. It keeps the Qi and Apple Watch charger charging and the case speaker your AirPods 4 case already has, and adds swipe volume and an hour with ANC on. The base AirPods 5 case charges by USB-C only and has no speaker, so it would be a step back there.