AirPods 5 vs Powerbeats Pro 2: Which for Workouts?
Buds slipping out mid-run? AirPods 5 vs Powerbeats Pro 2 weighs fit, heart rate, water ratings, battery and case size, and picks one for your workouts.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

Apple AirPods 5
8.3/10Score

Beats Powerbeats Pro 2
7.9/10Score
Prices and availability can change. Details
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
The short answer
For training, my pick is the Powerbeats Pro 2. Their ear hooks held through sweaty runs and gym sessions for 9to5Mac, SoundGuys and Engadget, and Beats claims 8 hours per bud with noise cancelling on, against 4 or 5 hours for the AirPods 5. The AirPods 5 still win two rounds a gym bag cares about: IP57 buds against the Powerbeats' IPX4, and a case small enough for a pocket. But Expert Reviews says they may not be secure enough for running, and there are no tips to tighten them. Don't buy the Powerbeats for the heart rate sensor, though. DC Rainmaker saw dropouts and poor accuracy against a chest strap. One honest caveat: no outlet has put these two side by side, so this call weighs each pair's own hands-on reviews.
Which to choose
Choose the AirPods 5 if
Pick the AirPods 5 if your workouts are walks, stretching or steady gym time on an iPhone, you dislike ear tips and you want a small case.
Choose the Powerbeats Pro 2 if
Pick the Powerbeats Pro 2 if you run, lift or ride hard and need buds that stay put, with long battery on an iPhone or on Android.
Where they differ
| Area | AirPods 5 | Powerbeats Pro 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Fit Expert Reviews says the AirPods 5 may not be secure enough for running. | Open fit, one size, no tips | Ear hooks, tips XS to XL |
| Weight per bud Half the weight, but nothing holds the AirPods 5 in place. | 4.3 g | 8.7 g, claimed |
| Heart rate DC Rainmaker and Lifehacker found it unreliable against a chest strap. | None | Sensor in each bud |
| Water rating Only the AirPods 5 are rated beyond sweat and splashes. | IP57 buds; case not stated | IPX4 buds; case not water resistant |
| Noise cancelling Same outlet, and the sealed fit blocks far more. | 59% perceived noise cut, SoundGuys | 83% average noise cut, SoundGuys |
| Battery, ANC on Engadget got over 8 hours on the Powerbeats with ANC on throughout. | Up to 4 h base, 5 h wireless case model | Up to 8 h, claimed |
| Total with case, ANC on | Up to 20 h or 22 h | Up to 36 h, claimed |
| Quick charge Both are maker claims. | About 1 h from 5 min | Up to 1.5 h from 5 min |
| Case size and weight SoundGuys likened the Powerbeats case to two AirPods 4 cases. | 46.2 x 50.1 x 21.2 mm; 32.3 g or 34.7 g | 75 x 66 x 34 mm, SoundGuys; 69 g |
| Android Neither offers multipoint outside Apple devices. | Plain Bluetooth earbuds | Beats app; heart rate to apps like Strava |
Ear hooks or an open fit: which stays put when you sweat?
Worried a bud will pop out mid-stride and bounce across the pavement? Then the hooks win, and it isn't close. The Powerbeats Pro 2 wrap a nickel titanium hook over each ear, and they held through running and gym sessions for 9to5Mac, SoundGuys and Engadget. 9to5Mac called them the most snug and secure earbuds its reviewer had worn.
The AirPods 5 go the other way: open fit, one size, no tips. At 4.3 g a bud they weigh about half as much as the Powerbeats, and Gizmodo found them comfortable through a flight of 4 hours 44 minutes. But Expert Reviews says they may not be secure enough for running, and SoundGuys found the bass thins out quickly once the fit loosens. Gizmodo says the fit matches the AirPods 4, so if you've owned those, your ears already know the answer.
Picture a two-hour Sunday long run in July heat. You wipe sweat off your face every mile, and an open bud with nothing to grip is the one that shifts. That's the job hooks exist for.
Hooks have a cost, though. SoundGuys found them pressing on the backs of its ears after a few hours, and I couldn't find a source that checked the Powerbeats on a bench press. They come with tips in five sizes, XS to XL, going by reviews, plus a fit test in the app. My call: for running and hard sessions, take the hooks.
Does the Powerbeats heart rate sensor change the decision?
Hoping your earbuds can stand in for a chest strap? Honestly, no. The AirPods 5 have no heart rate sensor at all, and the Powerbeats Pro 2 put one in each bud. Sounds like a win for Beats, until you see the outlets disagree.
| Outlet | Compared against | What it found on the Powerbeats Pro 2 |
|---|---|---|
| DC Rainmaker | Polar H10 chest strap, Apple Watch Ultra 2, Garmin Forerunner 965 | Close on an indoor ride, but long dropouts in sprints; slow lock, frequent dropouts and poor accuracy on hill intervals and a trail run |
| Lifehacker, after iOS 26 | Chest strap | Roughly tracked it but read high, above interval peaks; one bud alone was much worse |
| Engadget | Apple Watch | Matched once synced in the Runna app, no numbers |
| 9to5Mac, SoundGuys | Apple Watch | Comparable, no numbers |
Here's how I read that table. The only two outlets that compared it with a chest strap both found problems: DC Rainmaker saw slow lock, dropouts and poor accuracy on hill intervals, and Lifehacker found it read high even after iOS 26. The upbeat reports used an Apple Watch as the yardstick and published no numbers. One caveat cuts the other way: DC Rainmaker's runs came on launch firmware, before iOS 26.
Say you ride a spin class three mornings a week and want a rough heart rate line in Apple Fitness, which shows the reading since iOS 26. The sensor will do that. Train by zones, and it won't. If you want heart rate in the buds on an iPhone without hooks, the AirPods Pro 3 have it; my AirPods 5 and Pro 3 comparison weighs that step up.
Sweat and rain: which water rating holds up?
Sweat through your shirt by the second set, or train outside whatever the forecast says? This is the round the AirPods 5 take cleanly. Their buds carry IP57, which Engadget describes as full submersion to 1 m for up to 30 minutes. The Powerbeats Pro 2 buds are IPX4, rated for sweat and splashes.
What to take from that row: both shrug off a sweaty session, but only the AirPods 5 carry a rating for a real soaking. Imagine a trail run that ends in a downpour, with rain dripping off your cap into your ears for the last twenty minutes. That's the day the higher rating earns its keep.
Now the fine print on both. Apple says the AirPods 5's resistance can decrease with wear, and it states no rating for the case. Apple's Powerbeats page says that case isn't water resistant at all. Both makers also say not to charge wet buds, so dry them off before they go back in. If heavy rain is your normal, that's a real point for the AirPods 5, as long as the fit holds.
Long sessions: whose battery lasts?
Training for something long? Then battery may decide this before fit does. Beats claims 8 hours per bud with noise cancelling on, and Apple claims 4 hours on the base AirPods 5 and 5 on the Wireless Charging Case model.
| Source | Model | Conditions | Figure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apple claim | AirPods 5 base | ANC on | Up to 4 h buds, 20 h with case |
| Apple claim | AirPods 5 Wireless Charging Case | ANC on | Up to 5 h buds, 22 h with case |
| Engadget | AirPods 5 Wireless Charging Case | ANC on, Spatial Audio off | 5 to 7% left at 5 h |
| T3 | AirPods 5 Wireless Charging Case | Continuous ANC listening | 12% left after about 4.5 h |
| Beats claim | Powerbeats Pro 2 | ANC or transparency on | 8 h buds, 36 h with case |
| Engadget | Powerbeats Pro 2 | ANC on throughout | Over 8 h |
| Engadget | Powerbeats Pro 2 | ANC mostly off | Over 13 h |
Which means the gap holds up once outlets ran them down. T3 and Engadget found the AirPods 5 near empty right around Apple's figure, while Engadget's Powerbeats run beat Beats' own rating. Engadget also saw no faster drain from heart rate tracking across daily workouts of up to an hour.
So think about a marathon block: a three-hour long run with noise cancelling on, then the drive home with a podcast. The Powerbeats cover the whole morning with room left. The AirPods 5 would be close to empty by the time you park. For a 45-minute gym hour, either pair is fine. Going the AirPods route anyway? Take the wireless model for its extra hour; my guide to the two AirPods 5 cases explains the rest.
Where does the case go on a run or at the gym?
Ever tried to zip a bulky case into the tiny pocket on running shorts? This is where the Powerbeats bite. SoundGuys measured the Powerbeats case at 75 x 66 x 34 mm and likened it to two AirPods 4 cases, and Beats lists it at 69 g.
Read that row as pocket against bag. The AirPods 5 case weighs about half as much and is far thinner, so it slips into a jacket or a zip pocket. The Powerbeats case belongs in a gym bag or a locker.
Picture a work trip with a hotel gym in the basement. You ride the elevator down with a key card, a phone and a case, and small wins there. Charging differs too. The Powerbeats case charges over USB-C or a Qi pad, with no MagSafe. The base AirPods 5 case takes USB-C only, and the wireless model adds Qi and the Apple Watch charger. If the case stays in your bag while you train, this round barely matters.
Which works on your phone, and which should you buy?
Training with an Android phone in your armband? Then you're nearly done deciding, because the AirPods 5 work there as plain Bluetooth earbuds.
| For workouts | AirPods 5 | Powerbeats Pro 2 |
|---|---|---|
| On Android | Plain Bluetooth earbuds, extras off | Beats app: pairing, Locate My Beats, listening modes, heart rate toggle |
| Heart rate apps | No sensor | iPhone: listed apps such as Runna and Peloton, plus Apple Fitness. Android: any app that takes a heart rate sensor, such as Strava or Zwift |
| Finding lost buds | Find My, on iOS 27 or later | Find My on iPhone, Locate My Beats on Android |
The table's takeaway: on an iPhone both are easy, so your workout decides. On Android, the Powerbeats are the only real option of the two, and Android Central adds a catch: the Pixel Watch 3 and Galaxy Watch 7 don't accept third-party heart rate sensors, so your watch won't take the buds' reading.
- Get the Powerbeats Pro 2 if you run, lift or ride hard, train with an Android phone, or need more than five hours of noise cancelling.
- Get the AirPods 5 if your sessions are walks, stretching or steady gym time, you hate ear tips and you want a pocket case with IP57 buds.
Want a sealed fit without hooks? My AirPods Pro 3 review covers the sealed fit, and on a Galaxy, the AirPods 5 against the Buds4 Pro settles it. My Powerbeats Pro 2 review goes deeper on hooks and sensor, and my AirPods 5 review covers the open fit off the track. Still torn? My best earbuds for iPhone ranking and the AirPods 5 alternatives page widen the field, and which AirPods to buy sorts Apple's range.
Specs side by side
| Spec | AirPods 5 | Powerbeats Pro 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | Best on iPhone; basic Bluetooth on Android and Windows | iPhone iOS 18+ for full features; Android via Beats app |
| Noise Cancelling | Open-ear ANC, Transparency, Adaptive Audio, Conversation Awareness | ANC, transparency, adaptive EQ; H2 chip |
| Battery | ANC on: base 4h, wireless case model 5h; case 20h or 22h | Buds 10 h (8 h ANC on); 45 h with case (36 h ANC on) |
| Case and Charging | Base USB-C only; wireless model adds Qi, Watch charger, speaker | USB-C and Qi wireless; no MagSafe; 69 g case |
| Water Rating | IP57 earbuds; case rating not stated | Buds IPX4; case not rated |
What the experts found
Apple AirPods 5
The Wireless Charging Case model is the better buy; there should be only one AirPods 5 model, and the base version is a tough sell.
Fit determines nearly everything: well-fitting ears get strong open-ear performance, poor-fitting ears should buy a sealed earbud; the wireless case model is worth it if affordable.
An easy recommendation; the Wireless Charging Case model is an absolute steal for a small step up, better than AirPods 4 in every way with virtually no downsides.
Beats Powerbeats Pro 2
A substantial upgrade over the original with better comfort and a fuller feature set; ANC is only average and iOS heart-rate app support is narrow.
Very good workout earbuds with a secure fit, broad features and good noise cancelling; price is the main drawback.
The heart rate sensor is not good enough to be useful, even casually; iPhone pairing problems were the bigger issue.
Frequently asked questions
Are the AirPods 5 secure enough for running?
Not for everyone. Expert Reviews says they may not be secure enough for running, and there are no tips or sizes to tighten the fit. Gizmodo says the fit matches the AirPods 4, so if those stayed in on your runs, these likely will too. For hard runs, I'd take ear hooks.
Is the Powerbeats Pro 2 heart rate accurate enough for training?
Not for zone training. Against a Polar H10 chest strap, DC Rainmaker saw dropouts and poor accuracy on hard runs, and Lifehacker found it read high even after iOS 26. For a rough workout log it's fine, but keep a chest strap for intervals.
Which is better in the rain or with heavy sweat?
The AirPods 5. Their buds are rated IP57, while the Powerbeats Pro 2 buds are IPX4 for sweat and splashes. Neither case carries a rating, and the Powerbeats case isn't water resistant, so dry the buds before you charge them.
Do the AirPods 5 have a heart rate sensor?
No. The AirPods 5 have no heart rate sensor and no hearing health tools. If you want heart rate in the buds without hooks on an iPhone, the AirPods Pro 3 have it, and the Powerbeats Pro 2 put a sensor in each bud.
Which works better with an Android phone for workouts?
The Powerbeats Pro 2. On Android they get the Beats app, with Locate My Beats, listening modes and a heart rate toggle, and the reading pairs with apps like Strava and Zwift. The AirPods 5 work on Android only as plain Bluetooth earbuds.