AirPods 5 Review: Is Open-Ear Noise Cancelling Enough?
Just 4 to 5 hours with ANC on. This AirPods 5 review weighs the fit, the noise cancelling and battery, and tells you which version to buy.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.
OASTHAR score
- Design and Comfort8.6
- Sound Quality8.3
- Noise Cancelling7.8
- Battery Life6.5
- Value9.0
The verdict
If you carry an iPhone and hate the plugged-up feel of silicone tips, I'd buy the AirPods 5, and I'd buy the Wireless Charging Case version. If you're on Android, fly a lot or need buds that stay locked in on a run, I'd skip them. The noise cancelling is the best Apple has put in an open-fit earbud, clearly ahead of the AirPods 4, and Transparency sounds natural.
The catch is the battery. Apple claims 4 hours with ANC on the base model and 5 on the wireless one, and the outlets that ran them down found them close to empty at four and a half to five hours. Without tips, the ANC also can't match sealed buds like the AirPods Pro 3. If your AirPods 4 with ANC still work, I'd keep them, because the gain is real but modest. And if AirPods 4 never stayed comfortable in your ears, skip these too, since the fit is the same.
Buy it ifiPhone owners who dislike ear tips and want noise cut on commutes and in the office.
Reasons to buy
- Noise cancelling clearly beats the AirPods 4, with no tips plugging your ears.
- Natural Transparency, so you hear people and traffic without pulling a bud out.
- Light at 4.3 g per bud and comfortable for hours for most ears that suit AirPods 4.
- IP57 buds handle sweat and rain better than the IP54 AirPods 4.
Skip it ifSkip them if you fly often or need a sealed fit; get the AirPods Pro 3. On a Galaxy, get the Galaxy Buds4 Pro.
Reasons to avoid
- Only 4 to 5 hours with ANC on, so a long flight needs a mid-trip stop in the case.
- On Android they're plain Bluetooth buds, with no Spatial Audio, Live Translation or Siri AI.
Prices and availability can change. Details
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
What are the AirPods 5, and who should buy them?
Tired of ear tips that leave your ears feeling plugged? That's the buyer these are built for. The AirPods 5 are Apple's open-fit earbuds, with no silicone tips, and now both models carry active noise cancelling. They went on sale on 18 September 2026.
Read those as one sentence: light buds, real noise reduction for an open design, and a short charge. That 59% is the average drop in perceived outside noise SoundGuys measured, the best it has recorded on open-ear buds. Here's who I'd point toward them, and who I'd send elsewhere.
- Buy the AirPods 5 if you carry an iPhone, dislike tips and want less noise at work.
- Pick the Wireless Charging Case version if you charge on a Qi pad or lose cases, since only it has a speaker.
- Keep your AirPods 4 with ANC if they still work, since the gain is modest.
- Get the AirPods Pro 3 if you fly often or ride loud trains, since sealed tips block far more.
- Skip them on Android, where they work as plain Bluetooth earbuds.
Say you sit at a desk all day and still want to hear a colleague call your name. That's where these shine. The reasons to buy the AirPods 5 sum up the case fast.
What changed from the AirPods 4?
Short answer: the noise cancelling, the water rating and, on one model, an extra hour. The shape stayed put. Gizmodo says the fit is the same as AirPods 4, so your ears know the answer.
| Feature | AirPods 4 with ANC | AirPods 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Noise cancelling | Open-fit ANC | Stronger open-fit ANC; Apple claims up to 1.5x |
| Water rating | IP54 | IP57 earbuds |
| ANC battery, buds | Up to 4 h | Up to 4 h base, 5 h wireless case model |
| Case charging | USB-C, Qi, Apple Watch charger | Base: USB-C only; wireless model: USB-C, Qi, Apple Watch charger |
| Case speaker | Yes | Wireless case model only |
| Swipe volume | No | Wireless case model only |
| Fit and weight | Open fit, no tips | Same as AirPods 4, per Gizmodo |
So the upgrade is mostly about noise. Apple's 1.5x figure is a claim, and Headphonesty's measurement, via iThinkDifferent, put the real gain at about 3 dB more attenuation. That's a step you'd notice on a bus, not a new class of quiet. Engadget, Gizmodo, T3 and Expert Reviews all heard a clear improvement, most of all on steady noise.
Now the part that bites. The base AirPods 5 lose the case speaker and wireless charging that the AirPods 4 with ANC had. Apple has stopped selling the AirPods 4 with ANC, so if you spot one at a clear discount, read my AirPods 5 vs AirPods 4 breakdown first. Coming from AirPods 3 or wired buds? Upgrade, easily.
Will the AirPods 5 fit, and are they comfortable?
Here's the question that decides everything else: did AirPods 4 sit well in your ears? If yes, you're in good shape. If they slipped or ached, these will too, because there are no tips to swap and only one size.
Each bud weighs 4.3 g. T3 says they almost disappear in the ear and prefers them to the bulkier AirPods Pro 3 shape. Gizmodo wore a pair through a flight of 4 hours 44 minutes with no discomfort, and Expert Reviews counts them among the most comfortable earbuds it has worn, after about a month.
But SoundGuys got a different result. The housing started to rub after about 30 minutes, and longer sessions turned uncomfortable. I'd believe whichever side matches your history with AirPods 4, since ear shape decides it.
Fit changes the sound, too. SoundGuys found the bass thins out quickly when the fit is loose. And Expert Reviews says they may not be secure enough for running. Picture a hard interval on a treadmill with one bud working loose. If that's your morning, the AirPods 5 vs Powerbeats Pro 2 question has an easy answer: the ear hooks win.
One design detail helps. T3 notes the stem is close to the Pro 3's length, so swipe volume on the wireless model works the same way. IP57 covers sweat and rain on the buds, but Apple doesn't state a rating for the case.
How good do the AirPods 5 sound?
Expecting Pro-level sound from an open fit? You'll get closer than you might think. Engadget found the bass stronger than expected for open buds, with texture and detail. T3 calls the sound full-bodied and spacious, and Expert Reviews says they're "not far off" the Pro 3.
The Pro 3 still leads, though. T3 gives it the edge on clarity, separation and detail, and Gizmodo hears deeper bass from its sealed tips. So think of the AirPods 5 as a richer-sounding AirPods 4, not a cheaper Pro. Gizmodo found vocals clearer than on AirPods 4, with a little more low-end thump.
Two quirks are worth knowing before you buy. SoundGuys found the tuning shifts with volume. Gizmodo heard some older low-bitrate tracks turn muddy, with distortion above 50% volume, and it says the new sound signature isn't always better than the AirPods 4's.
The codec is AAC only, with no lossless or high-res option. That doesn't matter on most streaming apps, but a lossless library gains nothing here. A custom three-band EQ arrives with iOS 27, stored on the earbuds, per T3. And Expert Reviews says Spatial Audio with head tracking works well on iPhone.
Say you play podcasts on a walk and a playlist at your desk. That's a great match. If your evenings are loud, detailed albums, I'd lean toward the AirPods Pro 3.
How well do noise cancelling, Transparency and calls work?
Want a quieter commute without the sealed-in feeling? That's exactly the job here, and the AirPods 5 do it better than any open-fit Apple bud before them. Just set your expectations by the kind of noise you face.
What to take from that row: steady mid and high noise drops a lot, deep rumble doesn't. Gizmodo heard traffic and footsteps cut and jet engines mostly blocked, but jackhammers and keyboard typing stayed audible. T3 still heard train announcements, Expert Reviews says the Pro 3 cut more noise on the London Underground's Central Line, and Engadget found voices reduced but still there. With no tips, there's almost no passive isolation to back the ANC up.
Transparency is the standout. Gizmodo, T3, SoundGuys and Expert Reviews all praise it as natural, close to wearing nothing at all.
Calls are good, with a catch. Gizmodo found the mic clear. But Expert Reviews heard Voice Isolation over-process in very loud places, leaving the voice compressed and choppy, and SoundGuys flags wind as a weakness. So for a call on a windy platform, I'd step inside first. For quiet on a plane, the AirPods Pro 3 are the better tool.
How long does the battery last, and how fast does it charge?
This is the catch. Plan on four to five hours of noise cancelling before the buds go back in the case. Fine for a commute, short for a long flight.
| Source | Model | Conditions | Figure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apple claim | Base | ANC on | Up to 4 h buds, 20 h with case |
| Apple claim | Wireless case | ANC on | Up to 5 h buds, 22 h with case |
| Apple claim | Both | Noise Control off | Up to 6 h base, 7 h wireless |
| Engadget | Wireless case | ANC on, Spatial Audio off | 5 to 7% left at 5 h |
| T3 | Wireless case | Continuous ANC listening | 12% left after about 4.5 h |
| Gizmodo | Wireless case | 4 h 44 min flight, settings unstated | Below 5% at landing |
| Apple claim | Both | 5 minutes in the case | About 1 h of listening |
| T3 | Wireless case | Charging in the case | 12% to 80% in about 30 min |
Apple claims, per Apple's spec sheet: preproduction units, iPhone 18 Pro, 256-kbps AAC, 50% volume, Spatial Audio and Conversation Awareness off.
So the measured runs land right on Apple's claim, with nothing spare. Every measured run used the wireless model, so the base model's four hours rests on Apple's word.
Five minutes in the case gave Gizmodo about an hour. Picture a cross-country flight: you'd drop the buds in the case once, somewhere over Kansas. For long trips, Gizmodo lists the AirPods Pro 3 at up to 8 hours with ANC.
What works on iPhone, and what works on Android?
Got an Android phone and a pair of AirPods on your wish list? Honestly, I'd stop and think. They pair and play over Bluetooth, but most of what makes them worth buying needs an iPhone.
| Feature | iPhone | Android or Windows |
|---|---|---|
| Pairing and music over AAC | Yes | Yes, as ordinary Bluetooth earbuds |
| Personalized Spatial Audio, head tracking | Yes; a profile needs an iPhone with a TrueDepth camera | No |
| Live Translation | Yes, with Apple Intelligence; beta, limited languages | No |
| Siri AI | Yes, beta with usage limits | No |
| Find My | Yes, on iOS 27 or later | Not stated |
| Custom three-band EQ | Yes, with iOS 27 | Not stated |
| Switching between devices | Automatic across Apple devices | Cumbersome, per SoundGuys |
The table says it plainly: on an iPhone you get the whole package, and anywhere else you get decent open-fit buds with the extras switched off. Apple itself says functionality may be limited on non-Apple devices. Expert Reviews doesn't recommend them for Android, and SoundGuys says many features won't work there. Whether you can change noise modes from an Android phone isn't spelled out by Apple, so I wouldn't count on it.
Say you carry an iPhone for work and a Galaxy for home. The AirPods 5 will feel like two different products. If your main phone is a Galaxy, the AirPods 5 vs Galaxy Buds4 Pro question tips to Samsung, since its buds unlock their full features on a recent Galaxy phone.
What problems are known, and has anything been fixed?
Worried you'll hit a flaw a month in? Fair question. I couldn't find an owner thread reporting connection or case faults on the AirPods 5, though they've only been on sale since September. So the issues below come from the hands-on reviews.
- Battery near empty at 4.5 to 5 hours with ANC on, which is hardware.
- Comfort fading after about 30 minutes for SoundGuys, which depends on your ears.
- Voice Isolation over-processing calls in very loud places, per Expert Reviews.
- Wind noise on the microphone, per SoundGuys.
- Live Translation still in beta; Expert Reviews says it struggled with simple conversation.
- Clumsy switching between non-Apple devices, per SoundGuys.
Take that callout as the honest status, not a warning sign. None of these is a defect report; they're the limits of an open, small design.
A bit of fine print, too. Find My needs iOS 27 or later, and Gizmodo notes there's no Ultra Wideband Precision Finding. Engadget points out there are no hearing health tools, and there's no heart rate either, both of which the Pro 3 has. Apple's spec sheet doesn't list a warranty, so check the terms where you buy.
Which version should you buy: base or Wireless Charging Case?
Is the dearer model worth it? For most people, yes, though not for its sound.
| Feature | Base (USB-C case) | Wireless Charging Case |
|---|---|---|
| Case charging | USB-C only | USB-C, Qi, Apple Watch charger |
| ANC battery, buds | Up to 4 h | Up to 5 h |
| Total with case, ANC on | Up to 20 h | Up to 22 h |
| Case speaker for Find My | No | Yes |
| Swipe volume on the stem | No | Yes |
| Case weight | 32.3 g | 34.7 g |
| Sound and ANC | Same | Same, per AppleInsider via iThinkDifferent |
| MagSafe | Not confirmed | Not confirmed; Apple names Qi and the Apple Watch charger |
What to take from it: you're paying for convenience and an hour of battery, not better audio. Engadget calls the base model a tough sell, and Gizmodo calls the wireless one a steal for the small difference. SoundGuys says swipe volume alone doesn't justify the gap, but it still recommends the wireless model if you can stretch.
Picture losing the case under a car seat. With the speaker, you play a sound and find it; with the base model, Find My only shows the location on your iPhone, per Expert Reviews. That alone sells me on the wireless case.
Apple shows white only, and engraving is free at Apple. A lanyard loop and a cable in the box aren't confirmed. For a row-by-row look, my comparison of the wireless charging case version against the base model goes deeper.
Final verdict: should you buy the AirPods 5?
So, is this the pair to put in your cart? On an iPhone, with ears that liked AirPods 4, I'd say yes, and I'd take the Wireless Charging Case model. It's the best open-fit noise cancelling Apple sells, the Transparency is natural, and the buds are light enough to forget.
That callout is the whole decision in three lines, so here's who should go another way. If you fly often or ride loud trains, sealed tips and longer ANC battery matter more than an open fit. My AirPods Pro 3 review covers that pick, and AirPods 5 vs AirPods Pro 3 weighs the trade side by side.
If you're on a Galaxy phone, start with the Galaxy Buds4 Pro. If you run hard, look at the Powerbeats Pro 2 and its ear hooks.
Still unsure which Apple pair fits your day? My guide on which AirPods to buy sorts the range by habit, and the best earbuds for iPhone list widens the field. For other brands, the AirPods 5 alternatives page names the rivals worth your money.
AirPods 5 specs
- Compatibility
- Best on iPhone; basic Bluetooth on Android and Windows
- Noise Cancelling
- Open-ear ANC, Transparency, Adaptive Audio, Conversation Awareness
- Battery
- ANC on: base 4h, wireless case model 5h; case 20h or 22h
- Case and Charging
- Base USB-C only; wireless model adds Qi, Watch charger, speaker
- Water Rating
- IP57 earbuds; case rating not stated
What the experts found
The Wireless Charging Case model is the better buy; there should be only one AirPods 5 model, and the base version is a tough sell.
Fit determines nearly everything: well-fitting ears get strong open-ear performance, poor-fitting ears should buy a sealed earbud; the wireless case model is worth it if affordable.
An easy recommendation; the Wireless Charging Case model is an absolute steal for a small step up, better than AirPods 4 in every way with virtually no downsides.
Also consider

Apple AirPods Pro 3
Silicone tips in five sizes seal out far more noise, Apple claims 8 hours with ANC, and it adds heart rate and a hearing aid mode. It costs more.

Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro
IP57 buds, strong ANC and a claimed 6 hours with ANC on, with full features on a recent Galaxy phone. On an iPhone it drops to plain ANC earbuds with no app.

Beats Powerbeats Pro 2
Ear hooks keep it in place, and Beats claims 8 hours with ANC on. The case is large and the buds are only IPX4.
AirPods 5: frequently asked questions
Are the AirPods 5 worth it over the AirPods 4 with ANC?
If you own the AirPods 4 with ANC and they work, I'd keep them. The AirPods 5 add stronger ANC, IP57 and, on the wireless model, an hour more battery. Coming from older AirPods or wired buds, the AirPods 5 are an easy upgrade.
Do the AirPods 5 work with Android phones?
Yes, as ordinary Bluetooth earbuds. Personalized Spatial Audio, Live Translation and Siri AI need an iPhone, and switching between non-Apple devices is clumsy. On a Galaxy phone, I'd look at the Galaxy Buds4 Pro instead, and my Galaxy Buds4 Pro review covers them on Android.
Do the AirPods 5 come with ear tips or different sizes?
No. They are open-fit earbuds with one size and no silicone tips. If AirPods 4 fit you well, these should too. If they fell out or hurt, a tipped earbud like the AirPods Pro 3 is the safer buy.
How long does the AirPods 5 battery last?
Apple claims up to 4 hours with ANC on the base model and 5 hours on the wireless model, and 20 or 22 hours with the case. Measured runs on the wireless model ended near empty at about 4.5 to 5 hours. Five minutes in the case gives about an hour.
Is the Wireless Charging Case model worth the extra money?
For most people, yes. It adds Qi and Apple Watch charger charging, a case speaker for finding it, swipe volume and an hour of ANC battery. Sound and ANC are the same on both models, so you pay for convenience.
Are the AirPods 5 good for running and the gym?
They are IP57 against sweat and water, but Expert Reviews says they may not be secure enough for running, and there are no tips to tighten the fit. For hard workouts, I'd pick ear hooks like the Powerbeats Pro 2.
Do the AirPods 5 block noise as well as the AirPods Pro 3?
No. SoundGuys found the ANC weak on deep rumble below about 500 Hz, and voices and train announcements still come through. The sealed AirPods Pro 3 block far more, so frequent flyers should pick those.
Does the AirPods 5 case support MagSafe?
Apple doesn't say so. The Wireless Charging Case charges by USB-C, any Qi-certified charger or an Apple Watch charger, and the base case charges by USB-C only. I'd treat MagSafe as unconfirmed.