Deals
All deals
ReviewsIs it worth buying? ComparisonsWhich of these two? AlternativesWhat else is like it? Best PicksWhat's the best one for me? DealsIs now the time to buy?
All categories

SmartwatchesAlternatives

The 6 Best Apple Watch Series 12 Alternatives in 2027

Tired of the nightly charger, or the bill? The best Apple Watch Series 12 alternatives each fix one complaint, and I show what every pick takes away.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

Apple Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)

The original

Apple Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)

Every pick below is measured against this one, and each says exactly how it differs. Read my full review of it first.

My picks at a glance

#1
Apple Apple Watch Ultra 4
Best for Two-Day Battery

Apple Apple Watch Ultra 4

Done charging every night but not done with Apple? The Ultra 4 ran about two days per charge in four hands-on reports, with the same heart sensor and Readiness score as the Series 12. You also get dual-frequency GPS, a 100-meter water rating and satellite SOS. The catch is bulk and cost: one 49mm case at 63 g, about twice the launch price, and no timed battery run.

9.9/10Score

$774.00

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon
#2
Garmin Venu 4 (45mm)
Best for a Week Per Charge

Garmin Venu 4 (45mm)

Want a week between charges without giving up your iPhone? The Venu 4 pairs with it, and Garmin lists up to 12 days in smartwatch mode, or 4 with the display always on. Multi-band GPS, ECG and an LED flashlight come along. The catch: a heavy metal case that can feel uncomfortable in bed, no quick text replies on an iPhone, and no Apple apps. That battery figure is Garmin's, not a timed run.

9.6/10Score

$449.99$549.99Save 18%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

Early Black Friday Deal

View on Amazon
#3
Apple Apple Watch SE 3 (40mm / 44mm)
Best for Spending Less

Apple Apple Watch SE 3 (40mm / 44mm)

Like the Series 12 but not the bill? The SE 3 keeps an always-on display, sleep apnea alerts and heart rate that tracked a chest strap almost perfectly in independent data. PCMag ran it for 46 hours, well past Apple's 18-hour claim. You give up ECG, blood oxygen, hypertension alerts and the Readiness score. The screen peaks at 1,000 nits, and a full charge took PCMag 89 minutes.

9.3/10Score

$199.00$249.00Save 20%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon
#4
Apple Apple Watch Series 11 (42mm / 46mm)
Best if It Costs Clearly Less

Apple Apple Watch Series 11 (42mm / 46mm)

Would last year's watch do if it costs clearly less? The Series 11 matches the Series 12 on thickness, 2,000-nit screen and 24-hour claim, and Android Authority measured just under 40 hours on the 46mm. Apple has discontinued it, though it's still found new. It never gets the Readiness score or 5-second heart rate checks, and owners report battery life collapsing after some updates.

9.2/10Score

Currently out of stock at Amazon.

Check price at Amazon
#5
Withings ScanWatch 2
Best Analog Hybrid

Withings ScanWatch 2

Want to stop thinking about chargers and screens altogether? The ScanWatch 2 has real hands on an analog dial with a small grayscale display inside, and Withings lists up to 35 days per charge. It works with an iPhone and has an FDA-cleared ECG with AFib detection. You lose built-in GPS, apps and dependable notifications, and the best insights need Withings+. I know it less well than the rest.

9.2/10Score

$369.95

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon
#6
Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)
Best for iPhone Leavers

Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)

Trading the iPhone for a Galaxy phone? The Series 12 won't pair with it, so the watch has to change too. The Galaxy Watch 9 is light at 34 g and 8.6 mm on the 44mm, with a 3,000-nit sapphire screen and ECG and sleep apnea checks on a Galaxy phone. The catch is charging: plan on a nightly top-up, with published full charges from about 1.5 hours to nearly 3 hours.

8.4/10Score

$408.99

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon
Prices and availability can change. Details

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

What I looked at in best Apple Watch Series 12 alternatives

You like the Series 12. So do I. But something keeps nagging at you: the charger every night, the bill, a case that feels too small and too delicate for the trail, or a new phone that isn't an iPhone. I went through the hands-on reviews and owner reports for all six watches here and sorted out where they agree. I rank them on Battery Life first, then Health Tracking, Value for Money, Design and Build, and Works With Your Phone. Each pick fixes one of those complaints and costs you something else, so I name both.

Battery Life

Apple's 24-hour claim for the Series 12 hasn't moved, and the nightly charger is the reason most people start looking.

Health Tracking

The Series 12's heart sensor and free Readiness score are why you liked it, so a replacement has to hold up here.

Value for Money

Two of these picks exist only because they cost less, and one costs about twice as much at launch.

Design and Build

Weight and thickness decide whether a watch stays on through the night, and toughness decides where you'll take it.

Works With Your Phone

Every Apple Watch pairs with an iPhone and nothing else, so a phone switch can settle this by itself.

How we review products

Best Apple Watch Series 12 alternatives compared

Swipe sideways to see every spec.

ProductScoreCompatibilityDisplayBatteryGPSWater Rating
9.9 iPhone 11 or later on iOS 27 or later (iPhone only)49mm Always-On LTPO3 OLED, sapphire, up to 3000 nitsUp to 50 hours; up to 84 hours in Low Power ModeBuilt-in dual-frequency GPS100m water resistant; scuba to 40m; IP6X dust
9.6 iPhone and Android (text replies from watch on Android only)1.4-inch AMOLED touchscreen, 454 x 454, optional always-onUp to 12 days smartwatch mode (4 days always-on)Built-in multi-band GPS, up to 17 hours in multi-band mode5 ATM, swim-proof
9.3 iPhone 11 or later on iOS 27 or later (iPhone only)40mm or 44mm Always-On LTPO OLED, up to 1000 nitsUp to 18 hours; up to 32 hours in Low Power ModeBuilt-in single-band L1 GPS50m water resistant (swim); no depth gauge
9.2 iPhone 11 or later; iOS 27 for watchOS 27 (iPhone only)42mm or 46mm always-on OLED, up to 2000 nitsUp to 24 hours; up to 38 hours in Low Power ModeBuilt-in single-frequency GPS50m water resistant; IP6X dust
9.2 iPhone (iOS 15+) and Android (9+)0.63-inch grayscale OLED inside a 38mm or 42mm analog dialUp to 35 daysConnected (uses your phone's GPS)5 ATM (50m)
8.4 Android 13+; sleep apnea, ECG need a Galaxy phone1.47in Super AMOLED, 480x480, 3,000 nits, sapphire (44mm)445mAh (44mm); Samsung claims up to 40 hrs, AOD offDual-frequency L1+L5 GPS5ATM + IP68, MIL-STD-810H

1. Apple Apple Watch Ultra 4: Best Series 12 Alternative Overall

Tested hands-on by
#1
Apple Apple Watch Ultra 4

9.9/10Score

$774.00

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon

Love everything about the Series 12 except the nightly charger? This move costs you the least of what you like. The Ultra 4 runs the same S11 chip, heart sensor and Readiness score, as my Apple Watch Ultra 4 review explains. What changes is stamina. Four hands-on reports landed on about two days per charge, and Expert Reviews charged on the morning of day three with the always-on display on and about three hours of workouts a day.

Say you leave on Friday after work for a ski weekend, and the charging cable is still on your nightstand. Going by those reports, you're home Sunday night with the watch still running. That kind of weekend is what this case is built for. Dual-frequency GPS tracked visibly closer than the Series 12 on DC Rainmaker's trail run. There's a 100-meter water rating, a depth gauge for scuba to 40 meters, and satellite SOS, free for two years. I couldn't find a price for year three.

Now the footnotes. Nobody put a stopwatch on a battery run or a charge, so every hour figure is Apple's claim, up to 50 hours, and the two days rest on what reviewers reported. Gizmodo, for one, charged every 2 to 3 days. It comes in one 49mm size at 63 g and 12mm thick, about double a 42mm Series 12, and it launched at about twice the price. Heart rate also dropped out for 5 to 20 seconds in DC Rainmaker's workouts. Small wrist? Stay where you are, and my Series 12 against the Ultra 4 comparison settles it. If two days isn't enough, the Garmin Venu 4 lists up to 12.

Versus the Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)It has the same heart sensor, Readiness score and S11 chip, with about two days per charge where the Series 12 needs a daily one. It's about double the weight and launched at about twice the price.

Buy it ifiPhone owners who want about two days per charge, or who run trails, dive or travel beyond cell coverage

Skip it ifTwo days still isn't enough for you. The Garmin Venu 4 pairs with an iPhone and lists up to 12 days.

Reasons to buy

  • About two days per charge in four hands-on reports, where the Series 12 needs a charger daily.
  • The same second-generation heart sensor and Readiness score as the Series 12.
  • Dual-frequency GPS that tracked visibly closer than the Series 12 on DC Rainmaker's trail run.
  • A 100-meter water rating, a 40-meter depth gauge and satellite SOS, free for two years.

Reasons to avoid

  • One 49mm size at 63 g and 12mm thick, about double a 42mm Series 12, so small wrists are out.
  • Nobody timed a battery run or a charge, and it launched at about twice the Series 12's price.

Expert reviews behind this pick

The best Apple Watch to date and an easy recommendation from an Ultra 2 or older; Ultra 3 owners get Readiness, sharper sensors and a modest battery bump, and the Series 12 has most of it for half the price.

A very strong upgrade from an older Ultra with a very accurate new heart sensor, but Apple's accuracy study flatters it and Readiness was buggy at launch; Ultra 3 owners can skip this year.

Gizmodo4 (scale not labeled on the page); Editor's Choice 2026

The best Apple smartwatch: it strengthens the health tracking basics without reinventing anything, but the review stays incomplete until Audio Intelligence and the new Health app ship. Ultra 3 owners need not upgrade.

2. Garmin Venu 4 (45mm): Best iPhone Watch for Days of Battery

Tested hands-on by
Android CentralDesFit
#2
Garmin Venu 4 (45mm)

9.6/10Score

$449.99$549.99Save 18%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

Early Black Friday Deal

View on Amazon

If two days isn't the fix you're after and a week is, this is where I'd look, and your iPhone can stay. The Venu 4 pairs with iPhone and Android, and Garmin lists up to 12 days in smartwatch mode, or 4 with the display always on. Set that beside Apple's 24-hour claim for the Series 12 and you can see why battery-first buyers end up here. It also brings multi-band GPS, good for up to 17 hours in that mode, where the Series 12 makes do with single-band, plus ECG.

Take a ten-day road trip in August, with two phones already fighting over the car's one USB port. On Garmin's figure, the watch never joins the queue. Calls and a voice assistant run through its speaker, the AMOLED screen is easy to read in sun, and there's an LED flashlight with a red light mode for finding the motel door at midnight. Android Central sums it up as an everyman fitness watch, and names the weak spot in the same breath: the heavy case is uncomfortable in bed.

But go in with your eyes open, because I know this watch less well than the Apple ones here. I have no timed battery run to quote, so treat the 12 days as Garmin's number. Wrist heart rate struggles in weights and on outdoor rides. There are only two buttons, no full onboard maps, and battery is shorter than the Venu 3 before it. On an iPhone you can't send quick text replies, and you leave Apple's apps behind. Rather stay inside Apple's world, with two days being plenty? The Apple Watch Ultra 4 is the safer buy.

Versus the Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)Garmin lists up to 12 days where Apple claims 24 hours, and it adds multi-band GPS. You lose Apple's apps, quick text replies on an iPhone and the Series 12's light case.

Buy it ifiPhone owners who want a week or more between charges more than they want Apple's apps

Skip it ifYou sleep in your watch or want Apple's apps and better-proven heart rate. The Apple Watch Ultra 4 keeps both.

Reasons to buy

  • Up to 12 days in smartwatch mode by Garmin's listing, against Apple's 24-hour claim.
  • Pairs with an iPhone, so the long battery doesn't cost you your phone.
  • Multi-band GPS, ECG and an LED flashlight with a red light mode on one watch.

Reasons to avoid

  • The heavy metal case can feel uncomfortable in bed, which works against sleep tracking.
  • No quick text replies on an iPhone, no full onboard maps, and no timed battery run to back the claim.

Expert reviews behind this pick

An everyman fitness watch: clean, bright, smooth and packed with health tools and a handy flashlight, but the heavy case is uncomfortable in bed and it costs more than the Venu 3 did.

A full sports watch hidden in a classic design, matching the Forerunner 570 and adding ECG and a flashlight; GPS, brightness and battery impress, but two buttons make some sports awkward.

3. Apple Apple Watch SE 3 (40mm / 44mm): Best Lower-Cost Apple Watch Alternative

#3
Apple Apple Watch SE 3 (40mm / 44mm)

9.3/10Score

$199.00$249.00Save 20%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon

Maybe the watch is right and the bill is wrong. Then start here, because the SE 3 keeps more of the Series 12 than its place in the lineup suggests, and my Apple Watch SE 3 review makes that case in full. You get an always-on display, a first for the SE, plus sleep apnea alerts, wrist temperature, fall detection and the same 64GB of storage. Heart rate tracked a Polar H10 chest strap almost perfectly in The Quantified Scientist's data.

Picture a Tuesday walk after dinner with the dog pulling ahead on the leash. A glance down shows the time without lifting your wrist, which no SE before this one could do. And the battery isn't the penalty you'd expect. PCMag ran it for 46 hours with the always-on display on and two GPS workouts, size not stated, against Apple's 18-hour claim. CNET's video reviewer got 22 to 25 hours on the 40mm with sleep tracking and a run. I'd treat that as the realistic figure, so plan on a daily charge.

Here's what the saving costs. There's no ECG, no blood oxygen app, no hypertension alerts and no Readiness score. So if a doctor has told you to keep an eye on your heart, this isn't your watch. The screen peaks at 1,000 nits against 2,000, behind Ion-X glass and thick bezels. Charging is slow as well: PCMag timed 89 minutes to full, and no power adapter comes in the box. My Series 12 or SE 3 comparison sets the published figures side by side. Want those heart checks and still hope to spend less? The Apple Watch Series 11 has them.

Versus the Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)It keeps the always-on display, sleep apnea alerts and accurate heart rate for less. You lose ECG, blood oxygen, hypertension alerts and the Readiness score, and the screen is half as bright.

Buy it ifiPhone owners buying a first Apple Watch, or a gift, who can live without ECG and blood oxygen

Skip it ifYou want ECG and hypertension alerts for less than a Series 12. Look for a new Apple Watch Series 11.

Reasons to buy

  • Heart rate tracked a Polar H10 chest strap almost perfectly in The Quantified Scientist's data.
  • An always-on display, a first for the SE, so the time shows without lifting your wrist.
  • PCMag ran it for 46 hours, well past Apple's 18-hour claim.
  • Sleep apnea alerts, wrist temperature and a sleep score, with no subscription needed.

Reasons to avoid

  • No ECG, blood oxygen, hypertension alerts or Readiness score, all of which the Series 12 has.
  • Slow to fill: PCMag timed 89 minutes to full, and no power adapter comes in the box.

Expert reviews behind this pick

PCMag4.0/5 (Excellent)

A worthy money-saving alternative to the Series 11: always-on display, gestures, sleep apnea alerts and accurate tracking, with a longer battery run than the Series 11 in PCMag's test; the Series 11 keeps the better screen and extra sensors.

Expert ReviewsBest Buy label; no numeric score seen in the page text

Fantastic value for iPhone owners with nearly every Series 11 feature at about half the price, but battery life remains poor and it ties you to the iPhone.

A great heart rate tracker and a fairly good GPS tracker for the money: heart rate on par with the Series 11 and Ultra 3 despite the older sensor, GPS noisier than the dual-band Ultra 3.

4. Apple Apple Watch Series 11 (42mm / 46mm): Best Series 12 Alternative From Last Year

#4
Apple Apple Watch Series 11 (42mm / 46mm)

9.2/10Score

Currently out of stock at Amazon.

Check price at Amazon

Here's the quiet option: buy the watch Apple just stopped selling. MacRumors lists the Series 11 as discontinued since the Series 12 launched, yet it's still found new at retailers, and my Apple Watch Series 11 review explains why it holds up. Both are 9.7 mm thick with a 2,000-nit screen, 64GB of storage and the same 24-hour battery claim, and the older 42mm is a touch lighter at 30.3 g. It runs watchOS 27.

Imagine you're standing in a store on a Sunday afternoon with both boxes on the shelf. What does the older one give up? The Readiness score, heart rate checks every 5 seconds, Recovery HRV and the tougher Ceramic Shield 2 glass, and per MacRumors the software ones never arrive here. Heart rate is still strong, within 0.91% of a chest strap over six runs on the 46mm per Expert Reviews, where the Series 12 managed 0.18%. And the battery is no worse. Android Authority measured just under 40 hours on the 46mm with the always-on display, sleep tracking and workouts on.

Two things would make me pause. First, owners on r/AppleWatch keep reporting battery life falling to 12 to 18 hours after some watchOS updates, with no fix confirmed, though a reset helped some. Second, Apple gives no end date for its support, and every timed result I found comes from the 46mm, not the 42mm. So buy it only if it costs clearly less than a Series 12. At about the same cost, the newer watch is better, as my Series 12 against the Series 11 comparison shows. For the lowest bill, the Apple Watch SE 3 is the cheaper route.

Versus the Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)It matches the Series 12 on thickness, screen brightness and battery claim, and keeps ECG and hypertension alerts. It never gets the Readiness score, 5-second heart rate checks or the tougher glass.

Buy it ifiPhone owners on a Series 8 or older who find it new for clearly less than a Series 12

Skip it ifIt costs about the same as a Series 12, or you only want the lowest bill. The Apple Watch SE 3 costs less.

Reasons to buy

  • Just under 40 hours on the 46mm, per Android Authority, past Apple's 24-hour claim.
  • Heart rate within 0.91% of a chest strap over six runs, per Expert Reviews on the 46mm.
  • Sleep stages, a sleep score and hypertension alerts, all with no subscription.
  • Still current on software: it runs watchOS 27.

Reasons to avoid

  • Apple has discontinued it, and it never gets the Readiness score or 5-second heart rate checks.
  • Owners report battery life falling to 12 to 18 hours after some updates, with no fix confirmed.

Expert reviews behind this pick

A truly excellent smartwatch with superb battery life and fast charging, but the SE 3 is almost as good for $150 less, so most buyers should get the SE 3; not enough change to upgrade from a Series 10.

Android AuthorityNo numeric score; Editor's Choice badge

Not a revelation, just another refinement: the first mainline Apple Watch to last well past a day, with faster charging and tougher glass; a worthwhile upgrade from a Series 8 or older, not from a Series 10.

Good heart rate tracking, good sleep stage tracking and 'pretty okay' GPS; any recent Apple Watch performs about the same, so the Series 11 is not needed for accuracy, and you must accept charging every day.

5. Withings ScanWatch 2: Best Hybrid Watch for Weeks Per Charge

Tested hands-on by
#5
Withings ScanWatch 2

9.2/10Score

$369.95

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon

Some Series 12 owners don't want a longer-lasting smartwatch. They want less smartwatch. If a wrist that lights up through every meeting has started to wear on you, the ScanWatch 2 goes the other way. It has real hands on an analog dial, in 38mm or 42mm, with a 0.63-inch grayscale screen tucked inside. Withings lists up to 35 days per charge. That's a charger about once a month where the Series 12 wants one daily. It works with an iPhone on iOS 15 or later, so nothing about your phone has to change.

Think of a week at your in-laws' over the holidays, with one suitcase and no room for another cable. On Withings' figure, you don't pack one. Under the dial sits an FDA-cleared ECG with AFib detection, and its sleep data came out close to an Oura Ring in published hands-on coverage. Digital Trends still recommends it for the hardware and that clearance.

Now for what it isn't, and the list is long. There's no built-in GPS, so a tracked run means carrying your phone. Notifications are basic and can be unreliable, and Digital Trends found the app clumsy. The best insights sit behind a Withings+ subscription, where the Series 12 gives its Readiness score away. My evidence is thinner here as well. The hands-on coverage dates from 2023 and 2024, and the 35 days is Withings' own figure, with no timed run I can quote. Android Authority's verdict names the buyer well: it suits heart watchers, not athletes. If you train with GPS and still want long battery, the Garmin Venu 4 is the better fit.

Versus the Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)Withings lists up to 35 days per charge in an analog case that works on iPhone or Android. There's no built-in GPS, no apps, and its best insights need a subscription the Series 12 doesn't ask for.

Buy it ifiPhone owners who want a classic analog watch with ECG and about a month between charges

Skip it ifYou want built-in GPS, apps or dependable notifications. The Garmin Venu 4 has GPS and still lasts days.

Reasons to buy

  • Up to 35 days per charge by Withings' listing, where the Series 12 wants a charger daily.
  • Looks and wears like a classic analog watch, in 38mm or 42mm.
  • FDA-cleared ECG with AFib detection, on iPhone or Android.

Reasons to avoid

  • No built-in GPS, and notifications are basic and can be unreliable.
  • The best insights sit behind a Withings+ subscription, and the battery figure is a maker claim.

Expert reviews behind this pick

A top health-first hybrid: discreet, comfortable and long-lasting with FDA-cleared ECG, though light on smarts and missing built-in GPS, so it suits heart watchers, not athletes.

Gorgeous, accurate health tech in a classy case, still recommended for the hardware and FDA approval, but shaky notifications, a clumsy app and a paywall dull the package.

6. Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth): Best Watch if You Switch to a Galaxy Phone

Tested hands-on by
#6
Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)

8.4/10Score

$408.99

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon

If you're moving to a Galaxy phone, your Apple Watch stops being useful the day you switch, because it pairs with an iPhone and nothing else. The Galaxy Watch 9 is what I'd put on your wrist next, and my Galaxy Watch 9 review covers it from every side. The 44mm weighs 34 g and measures 8.6 mm thick, so it sits close to the 32.2 g Series 12 and comes in thinner than its 9.7 mm. The sapphire screen is rated at 3,000 nits.

It's the afternoon your new Galaxy phone arrives, and the old iPhone is going into a trade-in envelope. Once the Watch 9 is paired, ECG, irregular rhythm alerts, sleep apnea checks and the Heart Health Score all run, and GPS is dual-frequency where the Series 12 is single-band. Notebookcheck compared the 44mm with a Polar H10 chest strap, and across three bike rides the average gap was 4.3 bpm, about 1.5%. That's good, though not the 0.18% the Series 12 posted on runs.

Don't expect the charging habit to improve, though. Samsung claims up to 30 hours with the display on, and published full charges run from about 1.5 hours to nearly 3 hours. So it's still a nightly top-up, and a slow one. The fine print cuts both ways as well. Those health checks need a Galaxy phone, not just any Android phone, and the watch doesn't pair with an iPhone at all. Still deciding on the phone? My Series 12 against the Galaxy Watch 9 comparison is written for exactly that. And if you're keeping the iPhone but want long battery, the Garmin Venu 4 pairs with it.

Versus the Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)It's thinner at 8.6 mm on the 44mm, with a sapphire screen and dual-frequency GPS. It doesn't pair with an iPhone, charges slowly, and its ECG and sleep apnea checks need a Galaxy phone.

Buy it ifSeries 12 owners moving to a Galaxy phone who want the full Samsung health suite in a light watch

Skip it ifYou're keeping your iPhone, since it won't pair. For long battery on an iPhone, take the Garmin Venu 4.

Reasons to buy

  • ECG, irregular rhythm alerts and sleep apnea checks on a Galaxy phone.
  • Light at 34 g and 8.6 mm on the 44mm, thinner than the 9.7 mm Series 12.
  • A sapphire screen rated at 3,000 nits that holds up in direct sun.
  • Five Wear OS upgrades and five years of security patches, per Android Authority.

Reasons to avoid

  • It doesn't pair with an iPhone, so it only makes sense if you're switching phones.
  • A nightly top-up, with published full charges from about 1.5 hours to nearly 3 hours.

Expert reviews behind this pick

A very good, comfortable watch with a bright screen, smooth speed and a big health suite, but battery life is the weak spot and it needs charging nightly, so the reviewer does not recommend it fully.

Strong everyday smartwatch with a premium look, many health features, fast performance and a very bright screen, but limited battery life and slow charging for such a small battery could become a daily annoyance.

An utterly fine smartwatch that changes little from last year; a solid pick for existing Galaxy owners, but battery life is still short and the reviewer suggests looking at alternatives or an older model.

Best Apple Watch Series 12 alternatives buying guide for 2027

Why would you look past the Apple Watch Series 12?

Not because it's a bad watch. It's the one I'd buy for most iPhone owners on a Series 9 or older, and my full Apple Watch Series 12 review explains why. Expert Reviews measured its heart rate within 0.18% of a chest strap across seven runs on the 46mm, and a Readiness score arrives each morning with no subscription. Still on the fence? My reasons to buy the Series 12 are worth five minutes before you leave.

So why leave? Four complaints come up, and only the first is a real fault.

  • The charger. Apple's claim hasn't moved from 24 hours. Macworld ran a unit of unstated size for 51 hours and about 40 hours, but its three timed charges reached only 58%, 62% and 72% at 30 minutes, against Apple's claim of about 80%.
  • The cost. The SE 3 and last year's Series 11 cover most of the same ground for less.
  • The size. Some buyers want a bigger case with a dive rating and a sapphire screen.
  • The phone. It pairs with an iPhone and nothing else.

We've all unpacked a bag in a hotel room and pictured the watch cable still plugged in at home. If that's your whole complaint, read the battery figures before anything else, because swapping watches fixes less than you'd hope.

Which alternatives really last longer on a charge?

Fewer than you'd think. Here's every figure, with who produced it.

Watch Who and how Result
Series 12 Macworld, size not stated, two runs 51 h and about 40 h; Apple claims up to 24 h
Ultra 4 Expert Reviews, reported, about 3 hours of workouts daily Charged on the morning of day three; Apple claims up to 50 h
Venu 4 (45mm) Garmin's listing, smartwatch mode Up to 12 days; 4 with always-on
SE 3 PCMag, size not stated, two GPS workouts 46 h; Apple claims up to 18 h
Series 11 Android Authority, 46mm, with workouts Just under 40 h
ScanWatch 2 Withings' listing Up to 35 days
Galaxy Watch 9 Android Authority, 44mm, display off 30 to 35 h

Look at the three regular Apple Watches. In their best single runs, the SE 3, the Series 11 and the Series 12 itself all landed between about 40 and 51 hours. So trading one for another doesn't buy a second night. Plan on a daily charge for all three.

Heads-upThe Venu 4 and ScanWatch 2 rows are the makers' own figures, with no timed run I can quote. The Ultra 4's two days rest on four reviewers' reports, not a stopwatch.

My call: to stay on an Apple Watch, the Ultra 4. For a week or more, the Garmin, on Garmin's word for now.

What if you're leaving the iPhone?

Then the phone decides before the watch does. Every Apple Watch here pairs with an iPhone and nothing else, so a move to Android takes three of these six off the table.

Watch iPhone Galaxy phone Other Android phone
SE 3, Series 11, Ultra 4 iPhone 11 or later No No
Garmin Venu 4 Yes; no quick text replies Yes Yes
Withings ScanWatch 2 Yes, iOS 15 or later Yes, Android 9 or later Yes, Android 9 or later
Galaxy Watch 9 No Full Samsung health suite Android 13 or later; no ECG or sleep apnea checks
Pixel Watch 5 (not ranked here) No Yes, Android 12 or newer Yes, Android 12 or newer

Two watches cross over. The Garmin and the Withings work on either side, so they're the safe buy if you haven't made up your mind about the phone yet.

Say the Galaxy phone is already ordered. Then the Galaxy Watch 9 is my pick, since its ECG and sleep apnea checks only run there. Heading to a Pixel or another Android phone? I'd point you to the Pixel Watch 5 instead. Its ECG is free on any phone running Android 12 or newer. Its 41mm needs a daily charge too.

Bottom lineSettle the phone first, then the watch. The other order is how a new watch ends up back in its box.

What do you give up by paying less?

Less than the lineup suggests. But the cuts land in different places, so check which one you'd feel.

Feature SE 3 Series 11 Series 12
ECG, blood oxygen, hypertension alerts No Yes Yes
Readiness score No No Yes, no subscription
Heart rate checks at rest Not stated Every few minutes Every 5 seconds
Peak brightness 1,000 nits 2,000 nits 2,000 nits
Front glass on aluminum Ion-X Ion-X with a ceramic coating Ceramic Shield 2
Apple's battery claim Up to 18 hours Up to 24 hours Up to 24 hours
Still sold by Apple Yes No, discontinued Yes

Read it this way. The SE 3 drops the heart checks, while the Series 11 keeps them and loses only what's new this year. So the real question isn't which one costs less. It's whether a doctor, or your own worry, has you watching your heart.

Say the watch is a gift for your dad, who wants step counts and fall detection and would never open an ECG app. That's an SE 3.

  • Take the SE 3 if this is a first Apple Watch and those heart checks wouldn't change your day.
  • Take the Series 11 if you want them and you find it new for clearly less than a Series 12.
  • Stay with the Series 12 if the gap is small. At about the same cost, it's the better watch.

Do you want a bigger, tougher watch than the Series 12?

Then this list has one answer, and it's a big one. Here's how the cases compare.

Watch Case Weight Thickness
Series 12 42mm aluminum, GPS 32.2 g 9.7 mm
Ultra 4 49mm titanium 63 g 12 mm
SE 3 40mm, GPS 26.3 g 10.7 mm
Series 11 42mm aluminum, GPS 30.3 g 9.7 mm
Galaxy Watch 9 44mm 34 g 8.6 mm
Venu 4 45mm, metal Not stated Not stated
ScanWatch 2 38mm or 42mm Not stated Not stated

The Ultra 4 is about double a 42mm Series 12 on the scale. For that you get a sapphire screen, a 100-meter water rating and a depth gauge for scuba to 40 meters. Apple rates it for wrists of 130 to 210 mm, but fitting and feeling right aren't the same thing, and there's no smaller Ultra to fall back on.

If you sleep in your watch for the Readiness score, picture 63 g on your wrist at 2 a.m. Not everyone keeps that on.

Heads-upI don't have a weight for the Venu 4 or the ScanWatch 2, so those cells are blank on purpose. What I do have for the Garmin is the complaint that its metal case can feel uncomfortable in bed.

My call: buy the Ultra 4 for the trail, the water and the second day, and check the return window before you commit.

Which Series 12 alternative should you buy?

Work down these lines and stop at the first one that sounds like you.

  • Keep the Series 12 if you carry an iPhone and a daily charge fits your routine.
  • Pick the Apple Watch Ultra 4 if you want about two days per charge without leaving Apple, and your wrist suits a 49mm case.
  • Pick the Garmin Venu 4 if you want a week or more on Garmin's figure and can live without Apple's apps.
  • Pick the Apple Watch SE 3 if cost comes first and you don't need ECG, blood oxygen or hypertension alerts.
  • Pick the Apple Watch Series 11 if you find it new for clearly less than a Series 12 and can skip the Readiness score.
  • Pick the Withings ScanWatch 2 if you'd rather wear a classic analog watch and don't need built-in GPS.
  • Pick the Galaxy Watch 9 if a Galaxy phone is replacing your iPhone.

One last check before you order: your wrist. If it measures under 140 mm, the 42mm Series 12 and the 40mm SE 3 are the sizes Apple rates to fit, and the Ultra 4 only comes in 49mm. Size is the easiest thing to get wrong online, so check sizes and bands on Amazon first.

Still not sure? The best smartwatches list ranks the wider field by phone.

Where I'd go nextNot sure what you need from a watch yet? What to settle before you buy any smartwatch takes it one question at a time. And if you're leaving the iPhone altogether, which Android smartwatch fits which phone is the next list to read.

Best Apple Watch Series 12 alternatives: frequently asked questions

What is the best Apple Watch Series 12 alternative?

It depends on why you're leaving. For most people that's the daily charge, so my first pick is the Apple Watch Ultra 4. It keeps the same heart sensor and Readiness score, and it ran about two days per charge in four hands-on reports. It's one big 49mm case, though. If cost is the reason, I'd take the Apple Watch SE 3. For a week or more of battery, look at the Garmin Venu 4.

Is the Apple Watch SE 3 a good alternative to the Series 12?

Yes, for a first Apple Watch. You keep the always-on display, sleep apnea alerts, fall detection and heart rate that tracked a chest strap almost perfectly in independent data. You give up ECG, blood oxygen, hypertension alerts and the Readiness score, and the screen peaks at 1,000 nits against 2,000. If those heart checks matter to you, stay with the Series 12.

Which Apple Watch Series 12 alternative has the longest battery life?

On paper, the Withings ScanWatch 2, which Withings lists at up to 35 days. The Garmin Venu 4 follows at up to 12 days in smartwatch mode. Both are the makers' figures, and I have no timed run to quote for either. Among Apple's own watches, the Ultra 4 lasts longest: about two days in four hands-on reports, with Apple claiming up to 50 hours.

Is the Apple Watch Series 11 still worth buying instead of the Series 12?

Only if you find it new for clearly less. Apple has discontinued it, but it runs watchOS 27, and Android Authority measured just under 40 hours on the 46mm. It never gets the Readiness score or heart rate checks every 5 seconds. Owners also report battery life falling to 12 to 18 hours after some updates, with no fix confirmed. If the two cost about the same, buy the Series 12.

Do any Apple Watch Series 12 alternatives work with Android?

Three do. The Garmin Venu 4 and the Withings ScanWatch 2 pair with iPhone or Android, so they survive a phone switch. The Galaxy Watch 9 needs Android 13 or later and doesn't pair with an iPhone, and its ECG and sleep apnea checks need a Galaxy phone. The Apple Watch SE 3, Series 11 and Ultra 4 are iPhone only. For a Pixel or another Android phone, I'd look at the Pixel Watch 5.

Keep reading