Deals
All deals
ReviewsIs it worth buying? ComparisonsWhich of these two? AlternativesWhat else is like it? Best PicksWhat's the best one for me? DealsIs now the time to buy?
All categories

SmartwatchesBuying Guide

Smartwatch Buying Guide 2027: How to Pick the Right One

Wrong phone, dead battery by dinner, a fee you didn't expect? This smartwatch buying guide takes the choice in order, with published figures by source.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

Key takeaways

  • Pick by phone first. Apple Watches need an iPhone 11 or later, the Pixel Watch 5 and Galaxy Watch 9 need Android, and the Garmin Venu 4 and Withings ScanWatch 2 pair with both.
  • Most full smartwatches still need a charge every day. About two days means a rugged watch of 61.5 g or 63 g, and a week or more means a Garmin or a Withings.
  • For sleep, weight matters. The everyday watches here run from 26.3 g to 39.5 g, and both rugged ones come in a single large size.
  • ECG is the big health divider. The Series 12 has it, the SE 3 doesn't, and the Galaxy Watch 9 needs a Galaxy phone to run it.
  • Buy cellular only if you leave your phone behind or the watch is for a child, because it adds a carrier plan.
  • Check three traps before you pay: features still in beta, features that need a newer phone, and measured figures taken on the bigger size.

Which smartwatch works with your phone?

Start with what's in your pocket, because it rules out more watches than any spec does. Picture a store counter on a Saturday, with the box already in your hand. Nothing on the front says it won't pair.

Watch iPhone Galaxy phone Other Android
Apple Watch Series 12, SE 3, Ultra 4 Yes, iPhone 11 or later on iOS 27 No No
Pixel Watch 5 No Yes, health features included Yes, Android 12 or newer
Galaxy Watch 9 No Yes, everything Pairs on Android 13 or later, without ECG, irregular rhythm alerts or sleep apnea checks
Galaxy Watch Ultra 2 Listed as Android only Yes Pairs, without ECG or blood pressure
Garmin Venu 4 Yes, without quick text replies Yes Yes
Withings ScanWatch 2 Yes, iOS 15 or later Yes Yes, Android 9 or later

So read your column, not the rows. On an iPhone, it's an Apple Watch, or a Garmin or Withings if battery matters more to you than Apple's apps. On a Galaxy phone, Samsung's own watch unlocks the most. On any other Android, I'd take the Pixel.

Want names in order? The best smartwatches list ranks the field by phone, and the best Android smartwatches list covers that side alone. Changing phones soon? The Series 12 against the Galaxy Watch 9 is the read for that.

How often are you willing to charge it?

This one is about you. Think about a three-day work trip with one small bag. Do you want a charging puck in it?

Watch Maker's claim Published result Who, and how
Apple Watch SE 3 18 hours 46 hours; 22 to 25 hours PCMag, always-on display, size not stated; CNET, 40mm with sleep tracking and a run
Apple Watch Series 12 24 hours 51 and about 40 hours Macworld, size not stated
Pixel Watch 5, 41mm 30 hours, always-on 33 h 45 min Digit, settings not stated
Galaxy Watch 9, 44mm 30 hours display on, 40 off 30 to 35 hours Android Authority, display off
Apple Watch Ultra 4 50 hours About two days, not timed Four hands-on reports
Galaxy Watch Ultra 2 About 60 hours, always-on Two to three days Notebookcheck, always-on display on
Garmin Venu 4 12 days, 4 with always-on None found Listed figure only
Withings ScanWatch 2 35 days None found Listed figure only

Here's how I read that. Each daily watch beat its maker's claim in somebody's run. I'd still plan on a daily charge, because the settings are thin or unstated. About two days costs you weight, which comes next.

Bottom lineIf a daily top-up at your desk sounds fine, every watch here is open to you. If not, cross off the light ones now.

Will it be light enough to sleep in?

A watch can't track your night from the nightstand, so weight matters. Say you're a side sleeper with one hand tucked under the pillow. That's where a heavy case gets old fast.

Watch Weight Thickness
Apple Watch SE 3, 40mm 26.3 g 10.7 mm
Pixel Watch 5, 41mm 31.0 g, no band 12.3 mm
Galaxy Watch 9, 40mm / 44mm 31.5 g / 34 g 8.6 mm on the 44mm
Apple Watch Series 12, 42mm / 46mm aluminum 32.2 g / 39.5 g 9.7 mm on the 42mm
Galaxy Watch Ultra 2, 47mm 61.5 g, no band 10.7 mm
Apple Watch Ultra 4, 49mm 63 g 12 mm

What to take from it: the everyday watches sit between 26 and 40 g, and the two rugged ones weigh about double. Each of those comes in one size, so a small wrist has no fallback.

Now, does the bigger size buy battery? On the Pixel, yes. The 45mm carries about 40% more battery for under 6 g, and the Pixel Watch 5 sizes compared, 41mm against 45mm, goes through it. On the Series 12, Apple gives one battery claim for both sizes.

And if you're torn between light and long-lasting on an iPhone, the Series 12 against the Ultra 4 is that exact trade. My call: fit the wrist first.

Which health checks have real evidence behind them?

Every box lists a dozen features. What I'd ask is which ones somebody has checked, and which your phone will switch on. Heart rate has the best evidence.

  • Apple Watch Series 12: within 0.18% of a Polar H10 chest strap over seven runs, per Expert Reviews, on the 46mm.
  • Galaxy Watch Ultra 2: within 1 bpm of the same strap in Notebookcheck's comparison.
  • Galaxy Watch 9: an average gap of 4.3 bpm, about 1.5%, across three bike rides on the 44mm, per Notebookcheck.
  • Apple Watch SE 3: tracked that strap almost perfectly in The Quantified Scientist's data.
  • Pixel Watch 5: live heart rate essentially matched an Oura ring for Droid Life on the 45mm, with no numbers given.

Honestly, that's thin: one outlet per watch, and mostly the bigger case. What the SE 3 lacks is ECG, blood oxygen and hypertension alerts, and the Series 12 against the SE 3 comes down to those.

Phone lock-in is the other filter. The Galaxy Watch 9 runs ECG and sleep apnea checks only with a Galaxy phone, while the Pixel Watch 5 offers ECG free on any Android 12 or newer phone.

Say your doctor asked you to watch your rhythm. Then shop by ECG, and open the best smartwatches for health tracking next. My Apple Watch Series 12 review has the strap comparison in full.

Do you need dual-frequency GPS?

Sometimes, yes. Say your Sunday loop runs under trees and past a row of brick warehouses. That's where the published checks split these watches.

On single-band, the Apple Watch Series 12 came within 1.09% of a Stryd pod for distance in Expert Reviews' runs on the 46mm. The SE 3's track cuts corners and drifts by walls and trees, per The Quantified Scientist and Expert Reviews.

On dual-frequency, the Apple Watch Ultra 4 tracked visibly closer than the Series 12 on DC Rainmaker's trail run. And the Pixel Watch 5 held up on a London route known for signal blackouts, in TechRadar's check of the 45mm. The Galaxy Watch 9 has it too, but I couldn't find one accuracy number for it, so the label alone proves nothing.

  • Single-band is fine if a distance gap of about 1% wouldn't change your training.
  • Pay for dual-frequency if you run trails or tight streets and care about the line on the map.
  • Want routes on your wrist? The Galaxy Watch Ultra 2 adds offline GPX routes with turn-by-turn, and the Garmin Venu 4 lists up to 17 hours in multi-band mode.
  • Check it has GPS at all. The Withings ScanWatch 2 borrows your phone's GPS, so the phone comes on every run.

Bottom line: for pavement miles, I wouldn't let GPS type decide the purchase.

Who actually needs a cellular smartwatch?

Cellular earns its fee in two cases I can point to: you leave the phone behind on purpose, or the watch is for a child with no phone.

Picture a beach run with your phone locked in the car. A cellular Series 12 adds LTE and RedCap 5G for that, plus international roaming.

For a child, the Apple Watch SE 3 has to be the cellular model, because the GPS-only one can't be set up that way, and a plan is needed for most features. CNET's reviewer says Apple expects about 2 hours less battery in that kids mode.

Now the fine print. Every Apple Watch Ultra 4 has cellular built in, and it still needs a carrier plan before it does anything.

On the Galaxy Watch 9, LTE models need a plan too, and Notebookcheck warns that eSIM use drains the battery fast enough that the watch may barely last a day. The same outlet says running the Galaxy Watch Ultra 2 on its eSIM alone cuts battery life noticeably, with no number given. For the Pixel Watch 5, no published test says whether its unit was Wi-Fi or LTE, so the battery cost isn't known.

So who should skip it? If your phone is always within reach, buy the non-cellular model and skip the monthly line.

What does a smartwatch cost you after checkout, and how long is it supported?

The sticker isn't the last bill. Think about month 25, not day one.

Watch What you may keep paying for Update promise
Apple Watch Series 12, SE 3 A carrier plan on cellular models. Readiness and the sleep features need no subscription Apple publishes no end date
Apple Watch Ultra 4 A carrier plan. Satellite features are free for two years; no year-three price found No number published
Pixel Watch 5 Google Health Premium, a monthly fee, for the Health Coach and personal plans At least October 2029
Galaxy Watch 9 Nothing required. A carrier plan on LTE models Five Wear OS upgrades and five years of security patches, per Android Authority
Galaxy Watch Ultra 2 Not stated Until July 2031, per Notebookcheck

So the Pixel ties a fee to features, and its basics stay free: tracking, ECG, Daily Readiness and the health trends. Samsung's update run is the longest stated here, and the Pixel answers with a battery and display that can be replaced. The Withings ScanWatch 2 keeps its best insights behind Withings+.

And the box: the Apple Watches and the Pixel Watch 5 come with a cable or dock and no power adapter, so you'll need your own USB-C plug. Google's charging times assume a 30W one, according to the5krunner.

So add the plan, the subscription and the plug before you compare two watches.

What traps should you check before you pay?

We've all bought something for one feature and found out later it wasn't there yet. It happens three ways.

  • Features missing at launch. Live Rewind and Siri Recap on the Apple Watch Series 12 were absent in all three hands-on reviews, and Apple lists both as a beta. The Pixel Watch 5's workout builder was missing at launch too.
  • Features that need a newer phone. Those two Apple features need an Apple Intelligence-enabled iPhone 16 or later, not the 16e. Workout Buddy on the SE 3 needs an iPhone 15 Pro or later, and the Pixel's Proactive Assistance needs a Pixel 11.
  • Figures from the bigger size. The Series 12's strap-level heart rate came from the 46mm, and the Pixel Watch 5's measured two-day battery came from the 45mm.
Heads-upMacworld's three timed tests of the Series 12 reached 58%, 62% and 72% in 30 minutes, against Apple's claim of about 80%. Published full charges of the Galaxy Watch 9 run from about 1.5 hours to nearly 3 hours, against Samsung's 80 to 90 minutes.

So I'd read a maker's charging time as the best case.

Before you pay, confirm your must-have feature has shipped, works with your phone and was measured on your size. My Pixel Watch 5 review's issue list and my Galaxy Watch 9 review's issue list each say what's fixed and what isn't. And check the return window.

Where I'd go nextIf health data is why you're shopping, the watches I rank for health tracking evidence go by accuracy checks alone. And if an Apple Watch is already the front-runner, my honest case for the Apple Watch Series 12 includes the two reasons I'd hold back.

Products worth a look

Apple Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)
The iPhone route with every sensor

Apple Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)

If you carry an iPhone and want ECG, blood oxygen and a Readiness score with no subscription, this is the route I'd take. Expert Reviews measured heart rate within 0.18% of a chest strap, on the 46mm. It's still a daily-charge watch, and Live Rewind and Siri Recap were missing at review time.

$329.00$399.00Save 18%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

Early Black Friday Deal

View on Amazon
Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)
The non-Galaxy Android route

Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)

On a Pixel or another non-Galaxy Android phone, I'd start here, because no health feature is tied to one phone brand. Google claims about 50% in 15 minutes on the dock. The 41mm is a daily-charge watch, and the Health Coach needs Google Health Premium.

$299.99$399.99Save 25%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon
Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)
The Galaxy phone route

Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)

With a Galaxy phone, this watch unlocks ECG and sleep apnea checks in a 34 g, 8.6 mm case on the 44mm. The catch is the battery. Plan on a nightly top-up, since published full charges run from about 1.5 hours to nearly 3 hours.

$408.99

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon
Apple Apple Watch SE 3 (40mm / 44mm)
The first-watch route on iPhone

Apple Apple Watch SE 3 (40mm / 44mm)

For a first Apple Watch, I'd look here before spending more. You get an always-on display and heart rate that tracked a chest strap almost perfectly in The Quantified Scientist's data. You give up ECG, blood oxygen and hypertension alerts, and PCMag timed a full charge at 89 minutes.

$199.00$249.00Save 20%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon
Apple Apple Watch Ultra 4
The two-day route on iPhone

Apple Apple Watch Ultra 4

If nightly charging is the deal-breaker and you carry an iPhone, this is the worked example. Four hands-on reports put it at about two days per charge, with dual-frequency GPS and satellite SOS. It comes in one 49mm size at 63 g, and nobody timed a battery run.

$774.00

as of Nov 16, 2026, 23:30 UTC

View on Amazon
Prices and availability can change. Details

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Frequently asked questions

What should I look for first when buying a smartwatch?

Your phone. Apple Watches pair only with an iPhone 11 or later on iOS 27, and the Pixel Watch 5 and Galaxy Watch 9 pair only with Android. After that, I'd decide how often you'll charge, then check the weight if you plan to sleep in it. Health checks, GPS type and cellular come later, because they only matter once the watch fits your phone and your routine.

Can I use an Apple Watch with an Android phone?

No. The Series 12, SE 3 and Ultra 4 all need an iPhone 11 or later, or an iPhone SE of the 2nd generation or later, on iOS 27, and none of them pairs with Android at all. On a Galaxy phone I'd look at the Galaxy Watch 9, and on any other Android phone the Pixel Watch 5. The best Android smartwatches list covers the rest.

Which smartwatch has the longest battery life?

Of the watches in this guide, the Withings ScanWatch 2 lists the most, up to 35 days, in an analog body without built-in GPS. The Garmin Venu 4 lists up to 12 days, or 4 with the display always on. Among full app watches, the Galaxy Watch Ultra 2 ran two to three days for Notebookcheck with its always-on display on, and four hands-on reports put the Apple Watch Ultra 4 at about two days.

Do I need a cellular smartwatch?

Only if the watch has to work with no phone nearby. That's a run with the phone left at home, or a child's Apple Watch SE 3, which must be the cellular model. Cellular needs a carrier plan, and on the Galaxy Watch 9's LTE model Notebookcheck warns the battery may barely last a day with eSIM use. If your phone is always with you, I'd skip it.

Do smartwatches need a subscription?

Not for the basics on the Apple, Google and Samsung watches here. Apple's Readiness score on the Series 12 needs no subscription, and the Pixel Watch 5 keeps tracking, ECG and Daily Readiness free. The Pixel's Health Coach and personal plans need Google Health Premium, a monthly fee, and the Withings ScanWatch 2 keeps its best insights behind Withings+. Cellular models add a carrier plan on top.

Should I buy the bigger size of a smartwatch?

It depends on the brand. On the Pixel Watch 5, the 45mm carries about 40% more battery for under 6 g of extra weight, so I'd take it unless your wrist is small. On the Apple Watch Series 12, Apple gives one battery claim for both sizes and no reviewer measured the 42mm against the 46mm, so pick by wrist and screen. On the Galaxy Watch 9, the 44mm is my pick when battery margin matters most.

Keep reading