Deals
All deals
ReviewsIs it worth buying? ComparisonsWhich of these two? AlternativesWhat else is like it? Best PicksWhat's the best one for me? DealsIs now the time to buy?
All categories

SmartwatchesBest List

The 5 Best Smartwatches for Health Tracking in 2027

I rank the best smartwatches for health tracking by accuracy evidence, the checks your phone switches on, fees and battery, with a pick for each phone.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

My picks at a glance

#1
Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)
Best Overall

Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)

On an Android phone that isn't a Galaxy? This is the health watch I'd buy. ECG, Daily Readiness and the blood pressure and sleep breathing trends are free, and none needs a Pixel phone. TechRadar's 45mm checks found heart rate close to a chest strap and GPS that held on a blackout route. The catch is the 41mm battery, so plan on a daily charge. Check both sizes on Amazon.

9.9/10Score

$299.99$399.99Save 25%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

View on Amazon
#2
Apple Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)
Best for iPhone

Apple Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)

Carry an iPhone and care about heart rate? I'd buy this one. Expert Reviews measured the 46mm within 0.18% of a chest strap across seven runs, the strongest accuracy figure on this list. A Readiness score out of 10 arrives each morning with no subscription. The catch: it's still a daily-charge watch, and GPS is single-band. It won't pair with Android. Compare the 42mm and 46mm on Amazon.

9.6/10Score

$329.00$399.00Save 18%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

Early Black Friday Deal

View on Amazon
#3
Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)
Best for Galaxy Phones

Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)

Galaxy phone in your pocket? This is the health watch I'd pick, because that phone unlocks ECG, irregular rhythm alerts, sleep apnea checks and blood pressure. Notebookcheck measured an average 4.3 bpm gap to a chest strap on three bike rides with the 44mm. The catch is a nightly top-up and slow charging, and on any other phone those checks vanish. Pick 40mm or 44mm on Amazon.

9.3/10Score

$408.99

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

View on Amazon
#4
Garmin Venu 4 (45mm)
Best for Long Battery

Garmin Venu 4 (45mm)

Tired of losing sleep data to a charger? I'd look here. Garmin rates the Venu 4 at up to 12 days in smartwatch mode, it works with iPhone and Android, and it adds ECG, multi-band GPS and near-Forerunner training tools. Two honest catches: the heavy metal case can bother you in bed, and I have no measured accuracy figure for it, only review impressions. Check band options on Amazon.

9.3/10Score

$449.99$549.99Save 18%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

Early Black Friday Deal

View on Amazon
#5
Withings ScanWatch 2
Best Hybrid

Withings ScanWatch 2

Want heart checks without a bright screen on your wrist? I'd consider this hybrid. It looks like an analog watch, lists up to 35 days per charge, carries an FDA-cleared ECG with AFib detection, and works with iPhone and Android. The catches are real: no built-in GPS, basic notifications, and the best insights sit behind a Withings+ subscription. Compare the 38mm and 42mm on Amazon.

9.0/10Score

$369.95

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

View on Amazon
Prices and availability can change. Details

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

What I looked at in best smartwatches for health tracking

A health watch only helps if you can believe its numbers and it's on your wrist when they matter, including at 3 a.m. And here's the part that trips people up: some checks only switch on with one brand of phone, and some insights cost a monthly fee. I read the hands-on tests and the owner complaints, then ranked five watches on five things, in this order: Heart Rate and GPS Accuracy, Health Checks and Insights, Battery and Sleep Wear, Phone Fit and Subscriptions, and Design and Build. Specs were last checked on 2026-11-15.

Heart Rate and GPS Accuracy

Zones, trends and alerts are only as good as the sensor readings underneath them.

Health Checks and Insights

ECG, sleep breathing, blood pressure trends and readiness scores are what separate a health watch from a step counter.

Battery and Sleep Wear

A watch on the charger at night tracks no sleep, so runtime decides how complete your data is.

Phone Fit and Subscriptions

Some checks only switch on with one phone brand, and some insights cost a monthly fee.

Design and Build

You have to keep it on in bed and in the pool, so weight, thickness and toughness matter.

How we review products

Best smartwatches for health tracking compared

Swipe sideways to see every spec.

ProductScoreCompatibilityDisplayBatteryGPSWater Rating
9.9 Most Android 12+ phones; needs the Pixel Watch app (no iPhone)41mm or 45mm domed AMOLED LTPO, up to 3000 nitsUp to 30h (41mm) or 40h (45mm) with always-on displayBuilt-in dual-frequency GPS5 ATM and IP68
9.6 iPhone 11 or later on iOS 27 or later (iPhone only)42mm or 46mm Always-On LTPO3 OLED, up to 2000 nitsUp to 24 hours; up to 38 hours in Low Power ModeBuilt-in single-band L1 GPS50m water resistant (swim, snorkel); IP6X dust
9.3 Android 13+; sleep apnea, ECG need a Galaxy phone1.47in Super AMOLED, 480x480, 3,000 nits, sapphire (44mm)445mAh (44mm); Samsung claims up to 40 hrs, AOD offDual-frequency L1+L5 GPS5ATM + IP68, MIL-STD-810H
9.3 iPhone and Android (text replies from watch on Android only)1.4-inch AMOLED touchscreen, 454 x 454, optional always-onUp to 12 days smartwatch mode (4 days always-on)Built-in multi-band GPS, up to 17 hours in multi-band mode5 ATM, swim-proof
9.0 iPhone (iOS 15+) and Android (9+)0.63-inch grayscale OLED inside a 38mm or 42mm analog dialUp to 35 daysConnected (uses your phone's GPS)5 ATM (50m)

1. Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi): Best Health Smartwatch Overall, for Android

Tested hands-on by
TechRadarEngadgetDigit
#1
Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)

9.9/10Score

$299.99$399.99Save 25%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

View on Amazon

If your phone runs Android and isn't a Galaxy, start here. What puts the Pixel Watch 5 first for me is how little it holds back. ECG, Loss of Pulse Detection and the Daily Readiness score are free. So are the blood pressure, insulin resistance and sleep breathing trends, on any phone with Android 12 or newer. The trends do ask for commitment: five straight days of wear in a week, or seven days of data in a month. An iPhone won't pair at all.

Now, can you believe the numbers? Picture a lunchtime run downtown, between glass towers. That's where watch GPS usually falls apart. TechRadar had the 45mm run a London route known for signal blackouts, and it held up. Heart rate stayed close to a Polar H10 chest strap on one run. But no figures were published, and nobody has run those checks on the 41mm. Droid Life also saw resting heart rate in sleep read about 5 bpm above an Oura ring most days, which it suspects was a looser fit.

The catch is the battery. Google claims up to 30 hours on the 41mm with the always-on display, and the one outlet that ran it down, Digit, got 33 hours 45 minutes without stating its settings. I'd plan on a charge about once a day, and I'd do it at breakfast, not overnight. Health Coach and personal plans also sit behind Google Health Premium, a monthly fee. My in-depth Pixel Watch 5 review goes through the 45mm option and the sudden drain owners reported in late October. On an iPhone? The Apple Watch Series 12 (#2) is your pick.

Buy it ifOwners of a Pixel or other non-Galaxy Android phone who want the most free health checks and can dock the watch daily.

Skip it ifiPhone in your pocket? It won't pair, so take the Apple Watch Series 12 (#2). Galaxy phone? The Galaxy Watch 9 (#3) unlocks more.

Reasons to buy

  • ECG, Daily Readiness and blood pressure trends are free on any Android 12 or newer phone.
  • Heart rate stayed close to a Polar H10 chest strap on one run, in TechRadar's check of the 45mm.
  • Dual-frequency GPS held up on a London route known for signal blackouts, again on the 45mm.
  • Google claims about 50% in 15 minutes, so a short dock still leaves the night for sleep tracking.

Reasons to avoid

  • The 41mm needs a charge about once a day, and its only battery run didn't state its settings.
  • Health Coach and personal plans need Google Health Premium, a monthly fee. It won't pair with an iPhone.

Expert reviews behind this pick

An iterative upgrade and the best Android watch yet for new buyers, accurate and well made, but battery is short, Gemini isn't truly agentic and Pixel Watch 3 or 4 owners can skip it.

Still a solid smartwatch that does just enough to justify its $50 price rise, with faster offline Gemini, but several features were missing at launch and Pixel Watch 4 owners should not upgrade.

A smart, distinctive watch whose value depends on how deeply you use Gemini and Google Health coaching; not worth buying as a basic smartwatch. Battery makes it easily a one-day watch.

2. Apple Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS): Best Health Tracking Watch for iPhone

Tested hands-on by
#2
Apple Apple Watch Series 12 (42mm, GPS)

9.6/10Score

$329.00$399.00Save 18%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

Early Black Friday Deal

View on Amazon

Heart rate is why this watch is on the list, and why it sits this high. Expert Reviews wore the 46mm aluminum model for about a month and ran it against a Polar H10 chest strap on seven runs, 61 km in all. Average heart rate came within 0.18% of the strap and peak heart rate within 0.56%. No single run averaged more than 1 bpm away. Among these five, nothing else has a published figure that strong.

What does that buy you? Say it's Tuesday evening at the track, six hard 800s with a jog between each. Your zones are only as good as the sensor, and here you can leave the strap at home. Keep the limits in view, though: one reviewer, running only, on the 46mm, and nobody has published the same check for the 42mm. GPS is the weaker half. It's single-band, and distance landed 1.09% away from a Stryd pod, which Expert Reviews says is not much better than the Series 11. Each morning you also get a Readiness score out of 10, free, once you've worn the watch for seven nights.

Here's the trade. Apple still claims 24 hours, and Macworld's three timed charges reached 58%, 62% and 72% at 30 minutes, short of Apple's 80%. Charge it every day, away from bedtime. I also couldn't confirm an ECG app, sleep apnea alerts or blood pressure alerts for this model from the reviews I read, so I've left them off the table further down. My Apple Watch Series 12 review covers the launch bugs and which iPhone you need. Android phone? Go back to the Pixel Watch 5 (#1).

Buy it ifiPhone owners, runners above all, who want heart rate close to a chest strap and a free daily Readiness score.

Skip it ifAndroid phone? It won't pair, so buy the Pixel Watch 5 (#1). On an iPhone but done with daily charging? The Garmin Venu 4 (#4).

Reasons to buy

  • Heart rate within 0.18% of a chest strap over seven runs, per Expert Reviews on the 46mm.
  • A Readiness score out of 10 each morning, with no subscription, after seven nights of wear.
  • Light at 32.2 g and 9.7 mm thin on the 42mm aluminum, by Apple's figures, so it's easy to sleep in.

Reasons to avoid

  • Still a daily-charge watch: Apple's 24-hour claim hasn't moved, and charging came in slower than promised.
  • iPhone only, and single-band GPS landed 1.09% from a Stryd pod, not much better than the Series 11.

Expert reviews behind this pick

A significant upgrade and the best all-round smartwatch if you accept daily charging: heart rate tracked a chest strap almost exactly, but battery life cost it full Best Buy status.

Not bad, but could do better: a useful Readiness app and good looks, let down by uneven battery and charging results, spontaneous resets, slow moments and a sharp screen edge.

Worth it from a Series 9 or older thanks to the new heart sensor and Readiness; Series 10 and 11 owners should treat it as a targeted upgrade, not an automatic one.

3. Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth): Best Health Smartwatch for Galaxy Phones

Tested hands-on by
#3
Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)

9.3/10Score

$408.99

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

View on Amazon

This one is decided by your phone, not your wrist. Pair the Galaxy Watch 9 with a Galaxy phone and you get ECG, irregular rhythm alerts, sleep apnea checks, the Heart Health Score and blood pressure. Pair it with a Pixel and all of those go dark, though basic Samsung Health, Vitals and Daily Cardio Load still run. It needs Android 13 or later, so an iPhone is out. That lock is why it lands third, even with the longest list of checks.

Say your partner mentions over breakfast that your breathing kept stopping last night. With a Galaxy phone, the sleep apnea check is right there, and at 34 g and 8.6 mm thin, the 44mm is easy to keep on until morning. On accuracy, Notebookcheck compared the 44mm with a Polar H10 chest strap. Resting readings matched, and across three bike rides the average gap was 4.3 bpm, about 1.5%. Its three blood pressure readings landed within about 1% of a Braun cuff, with cuff calibration every four weeks. I couldn't find a single GPS accuracy number, though, and blood pressure availability isn't settled in every market.

And then there's the part that undercuts a sleep watch. Android Authority got 30 to 35 hours with the display off, and published full charges run from about 1.5 hours to nearly 3. You need a daytime charging slot, or you lose the night. My Galaxy Watch 9 review lays out every battery run and the slow-charging complaints. No Galaxy phone? I'd take the Pixel Watch 5 (#1) instead.

Buy it ifGalaxy phone owners who want ECG, sleep apnea checks and blood pressure on a light watch, and will charge it most days.

Skip it ifPixel or another non-Galaxy Android phone? You'd lose the Galaxy-only checks, so buy the Pixel Watch 5 (#1). It doesn't pair with an iPhone.

Reasons to buy

  • On a Galaxy phone you get ECG, irregular rhythm alerts, sleep apnea checks and a Heart Health Score.
  • Resting heart rate matched a Polar H10, with a 4.3 bpm average gap on three rides, per Notebookcheck.
  • Light at 34 g and 8.6 mm on the 44mm, so wearing it all night is easy.

Reasons to avoid

  • Pixel and other non-Galaxy phones lose ECG, rhythm alerts, sleep apnea and blood pressure.
  • It needs a top-up most nights, and published full charges run from about 1.5 hours to nearly 3.

Expert reviews behind this pick

A very good, comfortable watch with a bright screen, smooth speed and a big health suite, but battery life is the weak spot and it needs charging nightly, so the reviewer does not recommend it fully.

Strong everyday smartwatch with a premium look, many health features, fast performance and a very bright screen, but limited battery life and slow charging for such a small battery could become a daily annoyance.

An utterly fine smartwatch that changes little from last year; a solid pick for existing Galaxy owners, but battery life is still short and the reviewer suggests looking at alternatives or an older model.

4. Garmin Venu 4 (45mm): Best Long-Battery Health Watch, Either Phone

Tested hands-on by
Android CentralDesFit
#4
Garmin Venu 4 (45mm)

9.3/10Score

$449.99$549.99Save 18%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

Early Black Friday Deal

View on Amazon

There's a different way to fix patchy health data: stop charging every night. Garmin rates the Venu 4 at up to 12 days in smartwatch mode and 4 days with the display always on, and it works with both iPhone and Android. That makes it the one full sports watch on this page that doesn't care which phone you carry. I couldn't find an independent battery run, so treat the 12 days as Garmin's claim.

Picture the first months with a newborn, when you sleep in three-hour pieces and a charger is the last thing on your mind. A watch that asks for power about once a week keeps logging through all of it. You also get ECG, multi-band GPS whose tracks hands-on reviews rate highly, and training tools close to a Forerunner's. What I can't give you is a number. There's no chest-strap comparison for it like the ones behind the top three, so its accuracy evidence is thinner.

The weak spots are specific. Wrist heart rate struggles during weights and outdoor rides, so pair a chest strap for those sessions. The metal case is heavy and can feel uncomfortable in bed, which matters on a list about sleep and recovery. On an iPhone you can't send quick text replies, and there are no full onboard maps. Whether it offers sleep apnea or blood pressure checks, or charges for any insight, isn't something I could confirm. If measured heart rate matters most and you carry an iPhone, the Apple Watch Series 12 (#2) is the safer buy.

Buy it ifiPhone or Android owners who want ECG, GPS and training tools with about a week or more between charges.

Skip it ifWant heart rate with a published accuracy figure? Take the Apple Watch Series 12 (#2) on iPhone or the Pixel Watch 5 (#1) on Android.

Reasons to buy

  • Rated up to 12 days in smartwatch mode, or 4 with the display always on, so nights stay tracked.
  • Works with iPhone and Android, so a phone switch doesn't strand your health history.
  • ECG, multi-band GPS and near-Forerunner training tools in one metal watch.

Reasons to avoid

  • Wrist heart rate struggles in weights and on outdoor rides, and no measured figure backs it here.
  • The heavy metal case can feel uncomfortable in bed, which is where sleep tracking happens.

Expert reviews behind this pick

An everyman fitness watch: clean, bright, smooth and packed with health tools and a handy flashlight, but the heavy case is uncomfortable in bed and it costs more than the Venu 3 did.

A full sports watch hidden in a classic design, matching the Forerunner 570 and adding ECG and a flashlight; GPS, brightness and battery impress, but two buttons make some sports awkward.

5. Withings ScanWatch 2: Best Hybrid Health Watch, iPhone or Android

Tested hands-on by
#5
Withings ScanWatch 2

9.0/10Score

$369.95

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

View on Amazon

This isn't a smartwatch in the way the other four are, and that's the appeal. The ScanWatch 2 is an analog watch with a small grayscale screen set into the dial, in 38mm or 42mm, and Withings lists up to 35 days per charge. It carries an FDA-cleared ECG with AFib detection. It pairs with an iPhone on iOS 15 or later and with Android 9 or later, so your phone doesn't narrow anything.

Think of a dinner where you're in a jacket and nobody at the table clocks that you're wearing a health tracker. That's who this suits: someone who wants heart rhythm checks and sleep data in the background, and would never dock a watch daily. A month between charges means almost no missed nights. Its sleep data also landed close to an Oura Ring in review testing, though I have no figure to quote. Android Authority's verdict is that it suits heart watchers, not athletes, and I agree.

Now weigh it against the rest of this page. With no built-in GPS, a run without your phone records no route. Notifications are basic and can be unreliable, and Digital Trends called the app clumsy. The best insights sit behind a Withings+ subscription, so read what's free before you buy. I also have no chest-strap heart rate comparison for it, and the hands-on reviews behind this entry date from 2023 and 2024. Which means its accuracy evidence is the thinnest of the five. Want GPS and long battery together? The Garmin Venu 4 (#4) covers both.

Buy it ifiPhone or Android owners who want ECG and sleep data in a classic analog watch that runs for weeks.

Skip it ifNeed built-in GPS or proper notifications? The Garmin Venu 4 (#4) also works with both phones and lasts days, not hours.

Reasons to buy

  • Up to 35 days per charge, so it's on your wrist nearly every night of the month.
  • FDA-cleared ECG with AFib detection, in a case that looks like a classic analog watch.
  • Works with iPhone on iOS 15 or later and Android 9 or later, in 38mm or 42mm.

Reasons to avoid

  • No built-in GPS, so route tracking needs your phone along. It isn't a runner's watch.
  • The best insights sit behind a Withings+ subscription, and notifications can be unreliable.

Expert reviews behind this pick

A top health-first hybrid: discreet, comfortable and long-lasting with FDA-cleared ECG, though light on smarts and missing built-in GPS, so it suits heart watchers, not athletes.

Gorgeous, accurate health tech in a classy case, still recommended for the hardware and FDA approval, but shaky notifications, a clumsy app and a paywall dull the package.

Best smartwatches for health tracking buying guide for 2027

Which health checks need a particular phone or a subscription?

This is where most regret starts, so check it before anything else. A watch can list a feature on the box and still refuse to switch it on with your phone. Samsung is the clearest case: ECG, irregular rhythm alerts, sleep apnea checks, the Heart Health Score and blood pressure all need a Galaxy phone. Google goes the other way. It ties no health check to a Pixel phone, but it puts coaching behind a monthly fee.

Watch Phone it needs Health checks included Needs a specific phone or a fee
Pixel Watch 5 Android 12 or newer, no iPhone ECG, Loss of Pulse Detection, Daily Readiness; blood pressure, insulin resistance and sleep breathing trends Health Coach and personal plans: Google Health Premium
Apple Watch Series 12 iPhone 11 or later on iOS 27, no Android Readiness score out of 10; heart rate checked every 5 seconds Live Rewind and Siri Recap: iPhone 16 or later, not the 16e
Galaxy Watch 9 Android 13 or later, no iPhone Basic Samsung Health, Vitals, Daily Cardio Load ECG, rhythm alerts, sleep apnea, Heart Health Score, blood pressure: Galaxy phone
Garmin Venu 4 iPhone or Android ECG, training tools Text replies: Android only. Fees: not confirmed
Withings ScanWatch 2 iPhone (iOS 15+) or Android (9+) ECG with AFib detection, sleep tracking Best insights: Withings+

Read the last column against the phone you own today, not the one you might buy. A few gaps are honest ones. I couldn't confirm an ECG app, sleep apnea alerts or blood pressure alerts on the Series 12, or any sleep apnea or blood pressure check on the Garmin and the Withings, so they aren't in the table. That doesn't prove they're missing, only that I won't promise them. And if you're on Android and want a wider field than these five, my best Android smartwatches list ranks eight watches by phone.

How accurate are these watches for heart rate and GPS?

Fair question, and the honest answer is that the evidence is uneven. Only one watch here has a full set of published numbers, and even those come from a different size than the one many people buy.

Watch Who checked, and how Heart rate GPS
Apple Watch Series 12 Expert Reviews, 46mm, seven runs against a Polar H10 Average within 0.18%, peak within 0.56% Distance 1.09% from a Stryd pod; single-band
Pixel Watch 5 TechRadar, 45mm, one run against a Polar H10 Close to the strap, no figures Held up on a London blackout route, no figures
Galaxy Watch 9 Notebookcheck, 44mm, three bike rides against a Polar H10 Resting matched; 4.3 bpm average gap, about 1.5% No published number
Garmin Venu 4 No strap comparison to cite Struggles in weights and outdoor rides Multi-band, rated highly in hands-on reviews
Withings ScanWatch 2 No strap comparison to cite Not known None built in; uses your phone
Heads-upEvery measured figure above comes from the larger case: the 46mm Apple, the 45mm Pixel and the 44mm Galaxy. Nobody has published the same checks for the 42mm Apple or the 41mm Pixel, so I can't promise the small watches match.

So how would I read that table? If you train by heart rate zones, the Series 12 has the strongest case, with the caveat that it was running only. If you run between tall buildings, the Pixel's dual-frequency GPS is the one with a blackout-route result, even without figures. The Galaxy's numbers come from bike rides, and it has no GPS figure at all. And with the Garmin and the Withings, you're buying on hands-on impressions, not on measurements.

Why does battery life count as a health feature?

Because a watch on the charger at night tracks no sleep. We've all meant to put one back on after a top-up and woken with it still on the nightstand. Sleep stages, overnight heart rate and readiness scores all need hours on your wrist, and the Pixel's free trends need five straight days of wear in a week.

35 daysScanWatch 2, Withings' claim
12 daysVenu 4, Garmin's claim, smartwatch mode
30 hPixel Watch 5 41mm, Google's claim, always-on
24 hSeries 12, Apple's claim

All four numbers are maker claims, and I couldn't find an independent battery run for the Venu 4. The three daily-charge watches need a routine instead. Google claims about 50% in 15 minutes for the Pixel, though the5krunner says that assumes a 30W adapter that isn't in the box. Apple claims about 80% in about 30 minutes, and Macworld's timed runs reached 58% to 72%. The Galaxy Watch 9 is the slow one, with published full charges from about 1.5 hours to nearly 3, so it needs a longer daytime slot.

My call: if you know you won't build a charging habit, pick the Venu 4 or the ScanWatch 2 and accept thinner accuracy evidence. If you will, a top-up over breakfast keeps the top three on your wrist at night.

Can you trust a smartwatch's ECG, blood pressure or sleep apnea reading?

Treat each one as a prompt to see a doctor, not as a diagnosis. Start with blood pressure, because the two watches that offer it work differently. The Pixel Watch 5 shows trends with no cuff and no calibration, after five straight days of wear in a week. The Galaxy Watch 9 asks you to calibrate against a cuff every four weeks. Notebookcheck's three readings landed within about 1% of a Braun cuff, but outlets split on how well it works, and I'd take that split as a warning. Availability isn't settled in every market either.

On ECG, the ScanWatch 2 is the one sold as FDA-cleared, with AFib detection. The Pixel, the Galaxy on a Galaxy phone and the Venu 4 list ECG too. For sleep, the Galaxy runs sleep apnea checks with a Galaxy phone, and the Pixel gives sleep breathing trends for free. Sleep tracking has its own quirks. Expert Reviews saw the Series 12 log sofa time as sleep, and the Pixel has recorded wake-up times wrongly, with no fix confirmed for either.

Bottom lineA watch is good at noticing a change over weeks. If it flags something, book the appointment and bring the data. Don't change a medication on a wrist reading.

Which size should you buy for health tracking?

Go for the larger case if your wrist allows, for two reasons. The first is battery. The 45mm Pixel Watch 5 holds 465 mAh against 332 mAh in the 41mm and weighs under 6 g more, and the measured two-day results come from it. The 44mm Galaxy Watch 9 has 445 mAh against 390 mAh in the 40mm. The second reason gets less attention: the accuracy checks were run on the big cases. With the larger watch, you're buying the one that was measured.

Apple is the exception on battery. It gives one 24-hour claim for both sizes, and no reviewer measured the 42mm against the 46mm, so choose by wrist. The 42mm fits wrists of 130 to 200 mm at 32.2 g in aluminum, and the 46mm fits 140 to 245 mm at 39.5 g.

  • Take the bigger case if it fits your wrist and you want the longest gap between charges. On the Pixel, that means a wrist of about 150 mm or more.
  • Take the smaller case if you sleep in it and weight bothers you. A watch you take off at night tracks nothing.
  • Check the fit first if you're eyeing the Venu 4. It comes in 45mm, with a metal case that can feel heavy in bed. The ScanWatch 2 comes in 38mm or 42mm.

Which health tracking smartwatch should you pick if you're still stuck?

Go back to the phone, then to the one thing you won't compromise on. Most people who get stuck are comparing two watches that can't both pair with their phone.

  • Android phone that isn't a Galaxy: the Pixel Watch 5. Every free health check works, and none is held back for a Pixel phone.
  • iPhone: the Apple Watch Series 12 for measured heart rate, or the Venu 4 if a daily charge is a dealbreaker.
  • Galaxy phone: the Galaxy Watch 9, as long as you'll give it a daytime charging slot.
  • You won't charge often, whatever the phone: the Venu 4 for workouts and GPS, or the ScanWatch 2 for heart checks in a classic watch.

Still between two? If you're choosing a phone as much as a watch, I've put the Pixel Watch 5 against the Apple Watch Series 12 in its own comparison. Galaxy owners tempted by Google's free checks should read how the Pixel Watch 5 compares with the Galaxy Watch 9 first, because the Samsung-only checks are what you'd give up. And if the Pixel's daily charge is the thing stopping you, my Pixel Watch 5 alternatives page lists what I'd consider in its place.

One last piece of fine print: wear it through the first week while the return window is open, and confirm the features you paid for switched on with your phone.

Where I'd go nextOn Android and torn between Google and Samsung? Pixel Watch 5 vs Galaxy Watch 9 for non-Galaxy phones settles it by the phone in your pocket. And if the Pixel is your pick, which Pixel Watch 5 size to get matters more for sleep tracking than any score here.

Best smartwatches for health tracking: frequently asked questions

What is the best smartwatch for health tracking?

It depends on your phone, so here are three answers. On an Android phone that isn't a Galaxy, I'd buy the Google Pixel Watch 5, since ECG, Daily Readiness and its blood pressure trends are free. On an iPhone, the Apple Watch Series 12 has the best measured heart rate here. On a Galaxy phone, the Galaxy Watch 9 unlocks the most checks. Hate charging? The Garmin Venu 4 works with either phone.

Which smartwatch has the most accurate heart rate?

On published numbers, the Apple Watch Series 12. Expert Reviews measured the 46mm within 0.18% of a Polar H10 chest strap across seven runs. The Pixel Watch 5 stayed close to the same strap in TechRadar's check of the 45mm, with no figures given, and the Galaxy Watch 9 averaged 4.3 bpm off on three bike rides for Notebookcheck. I have no strap comparison for the Venu 4 or the ScanWatch 2.

Do health tracking smartwatches need a subscription?

It varies, and the fees hide in different places. The Pixel Watch 5 keeps ECG, Daily Readiness and its health trends free, but Health Coach and personal plans need Google Health Premium. The Apple Watch Series 12's Readiness score needs no subscription. The Withings ScanWatch 2 puts its best insights behind Withings+. I couldn't confirm a fee either way for the Garmin Venu 4, so check before you buy.

Can a smartwatch detect sleep apnea?

Some can check for signs of it, with conditions. The Galaxy Watch 9 runs sleep apnea checks, but only when paired with a Galaxy phone on Android 12 or later. The Pixel Watch 5 offers free sleep breathing trends on any Android 12 or newer phone, after enough days of wear. I couldn't confirm a sleep apnea feature on the other three picks. Either way, treat a flag as a reason to see a doctor.

Which health smartwatch works with both iPhone and Android?

Two on this list: the Garmin Venu 4 and the Withings ScanWatch 2. The Venu 4 is a full sports watch with ECG and multi-band GPS, though quick text replies only work on Android. The ScanWatch 2 is an analog hybrid with an FDA-cleared ECG and no built-in GPS. The Pixel Watch 5 and Galaxy Watch 9 need Android, and the Apple Watch Series 12 needs an iPhone.

Keep reading