Deals
All deals
ReviewsIs it worth buying? ComparisonsWhich of these two? AlternativesWhat else is like it? Best PicksWhat's the best one for me? DealsIs now the time to buy?
All categories

SmartwatchesReview

Google Pixel Watch 4 Review: Still the Smarter Buy After the Pixel Watch 5?

This Pixel Watch 4 review shows what the Watch 5 adds, when updates stop, and who should buy, keep or skip last year's watch.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, OASTHAR earns from qualifying purchases.

8.1/10Design and Comfort 8.6Speed and Software 8.2Health and Fitness 8.6Value 8.0Battery Life 6.8

OASTHAR score

  • Design and Comfort8.6
  • Speed and Software8.2
  • Health and Fitness8.6
  • Value8.0
  • Battery Life6.8

The verdict

If you're buying a first Pixel Watch and your phone runs Android, the Pixel Watch 4 is the smarter buy only when it costs clearly less than the Pixel Watch 5 on the day you order. If you already own a Watch 4, keep it, and I'd say that without hedging.

Here's why. On the wrist it's the same watch: same case, same domed screen, same dock, same battery claims. Heart rate and sleep tracking rank among the best on Android in independent checks, and Wear OS 7 and the free health trends have already arrived.

The catch is time. Guaranteed updates end in October 2028, a year before the Watch 5's, and offline Gemini and the cloud GPS correction stay on the newer watch. The 41mm also needs a charge about once a day.

Skip it if you carry an iPhone, want days between charges or need clean GPS tracks. A 45mm Pixel Watch 3 owner can wait too.

Buy it ifAndroid owners who want Pixel Watch health tracking for less than a Watch 5 and accept updates ending in October 2028.

Reasons to buy

  • Heart rate stayed close to a chest strap in three independent checks, so workout data holds up.
  • Quick top-ups: 9to5Google timed the 45mm from 29% to 95% in about 23 minutes.
  • The battery and display can be replaced through two screws, so a worn cell needn't end the watch.
  • Already runs Wear OS 7, with the blood pressure, insulin resistance and sleep breathing trends free.

Skip it ifSkip it if the saving over the Pixel Watch 5 is small, since the newer watch gets a year more of updates. For days of battery, the Garmin Venu 4 fits better, and Galaxy phone owners get more from the Galaxy Watch 9.

Reasons to avoid

  • Guaranteed updates end in October 2028, a year before the Pixel Watch 5, and offline Gemini isn't coming.
  • GPS tracks run noisier than a Garmin's, and the 41mm needs a charge about once a day.
Prices and availability can change. Details

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

What is the Pixel Watch 4 now, and who does it still suit?

Buying last year's model always comes with one nagging doubt: are you saving money, or buying something that's about to be left behind? Fair question. Here, it's mostly the first.

The Pixel Watch 4 is Google's 2025 smartwatch, and Google still sells it new beside the Pixel Watch 5. It comes in 41mm and 45mm, each in Wi-Fi and LTE, with a domed AMOLED screen that Google rates at up to 3,000 nits. Inside are a Snapdragon W5 Gen 2 chip, 2 GB of memory and 32 GB of storage. It pairs with most phones on Android 11 or newer, and it won't pair with an iPhone.

31.0 g41mm weight, no band
12.3 mmheight, both sizes
23 min29% to 95%, 9to5Google, 45mm
Oct 2028guaranteed updates end

Those four numbers are the watch in short: light, a little tall, quick to refill, and on a clock.

So who does it suit? Say your phone is a Pixel or another Android, you want heart rate and sleep data you can trust, and you'd rather keep some money back than own the newest chip. That's the buyer I'd point here.

The newer model is the other half of this decision. My review of the newer Pixel Watch 5 makes its case, and you'll notice how much the two watches share.

Who should buy the Pixel Watch 4, and who should skip it?

Two things settle this: what's on your wrist right now, and how wide the gap to the newer watch is on the day you order. Find your line below.

  • Buy the Pixel Watch 4 if it costs clearly less than the Watch 5 and you can live without offline Gemini.
  • Buy the Pixel Watch 5 instead if the gap is small. You get a year more of updates and offline Gemini for little extra.
  • Keep your Pixel Watch 4 if you own one. The Watch 5 has the same case, screen, heart rate sensor and dock.
  • Upgrade from a Pixel Watch 2 or older if slow charging or a tired battery bothers you.
  • Wait if you own a 45mm Pixel Watch 3. 9to5Google told that owner not to upgrade.
  • Get the Galaxy Watch 9 if your phone is a Galaxy, since its ECG and sleep apnea checks need a Samsung phone. My take on Samsung's Galaxy Watch 9 covers it.
  • Skip it if you carry an iPhone or want several days between charges. Garmin lists up to 12 days for the Venu 4.

Habits matter too. Picture the watch on its dock while you shower and make coffee. On the 45mm, that short stop covers most of a day. Never remember to dock anything? The 41mm will catch you out by the second afternoon.

Not sure about a Pixel at all? The best Android smartwatches are ranked by the phone you carry, and I'd look there first.

What changed from the Pixel Watch 3, and what does the Pixel Watch 5 add?

Short answer: the Watch 4 was the big redesign, and the Watch 5 is that same watch with a few things added. Honestly, that's good news if you're eyeing the older one.

Feature Pixel Watch 3 Pixel Watch 4 Pixel Watch 5
Chip Snapdragon W5 Gen 1 Snapdragon W5 Gen 2 Snapdragon W5 Gen 2 Accelerated
Storage 32 GB 32 GB 64 GB
Battery, 41mm / 45mm 307 / 420 mAh 325 / 455 mAh 332 / 465 mAh
Claimed life, always-on 24 h, both sizes 30 h (41mm), 40 h (45mm) Unchanged
Charging Pin cable, about 60 to 80 min to full Side dock, about 45 to 60 min to full Same dock and claims
Battery and display Not repairable Replaceable Replaceable
GPS Built-in GPS Dual-frequency GPS Dual-frequency, plus cloud correction
Offline Gemini No No Yes
Daily Readiness Score Not compared here Paid tier only Free
Phone needed Android 10 or newer Android 11 or newer Android 12 or newer
Software Wear OS 7 since June 2026 Wear OS 7 since June 2026 Wear OS 7
Guaranteed updates until October 2027 October 2028 October 2029

Source: Google's spec pages and Google's update schedule. The Watch 5 only features are as listed by the5krunner.

Read the table left to right. Coming from a Watch 3, the Watch 4 brought a domed screen with 10% more active area, a far quicker dock, dual-frequency GPS and a battery that can be replaced. The heart rate hardware carried over and performs the same.

Going the other way, the Watch 5 keeps four things to itself, per the5krunner: offline Gemini, cloud GPS correction, strength rep tracking and Smart Wake. What did reach the Watch 4 by software is Wear OS 7 in June 2026, the free blood pressure, insulin resistance and sleep breathing trends in September, and the Watch 5's faces in October.

Bottom lineBuy today and you get a little under two years of guaranteed updates, to October 2028. The Watch 5 runs to October 2029. If you keep a watch for four years, that year matters. If you swap every two, it doesn't.

Want it row by row? The Pixel Watch 5 vs Pixel Watch 4 comparison does that. And for readers looking further back, my review of the older Pixel Watch 3 covers the model before this one.

How do the design, comfort and bands hold up a year on?

Afraid a domed glass watch won't survive a year of door frames? I'd have the same fear, and the long-term evidence is kinder than you'd expect. 9to5Google's long-term video reports glass free of scrapes after about three months of near-daily wear with no case, and no pitting on the aluminum. That's one wearer, so read it as encouraging, not as a promise. The glass is Gorilla Glass 5 with no sapphire option. Want sapphire? The Galaxy Watch 9 has it.

The 41mm weighs 31.0 g without a band and the 45mm weighs 36.7 g, and both stand 12.3 mm high. So it's light, but tall. The 44mm Galaxy Watch 9 measures 8.6 mm, which means the Pixel is the one you'll feel under a snug shirt cuff.

Now the small annoyances, because they're real. 9to5Google's 41mm review found the side charging contacts stick out enough to feel when you press the crown, and that the bands overshoot the case on a small wrist and leave a gap. And the speaker is too quiet for a call in traffic or a supermarket, according to the long-term video.

Here's the part nobody puts on the box. Chargers from older Pixel Watches don't fit, the dock's cable is fixed to it, and no power adapter is included. Replacing a Watch 3? Your old cable goes in a drawer.

My call on design: easy to live with, if the height doesn't bother you.

How long does the battery last, and how fast does it charge?

That depends on which size you pick, and nobody selling it says so up front. The 45mm is a two-day watch. The 41mm is a one-day watch with a little spare.

Source Size Conditions Figure
Google claim 41mm Always-on display / Battery Saver Up to 30 h / 48 h
Google claim 45mm Always-on display / Battery Saver Up to 40 h / 72 h
9to5Google 45mm Always-on display on, Raise to Talk on Nearly two full days before Battery Saver
DC Rainmaker 45mm Always-on setting not stated About two full days
DC Rainmaker 45mm GPS on, worked out from burn rate Roughly 14 to 15 h
9to5Google, 41mm review 41mm Always-on setting not stated About 36 h to the 15% Battery Saver
Android Authority Not stated Always-on display and notifications on A day and a half, sometimes two
Android Authority Not stated Eight hours of sleep tracking Under 5% used
9to5Google, long-term video Not stated No workout or sleep tracking Around 2 days
Google claim 41mm Dock with a 30W adapter, from empty About 15 min to 50%, 45 min to full
Google claim 45mm Dock with a 30W adapter, from empty About 15 min to 50%, 60 min to full
9to5Google 45mm Quick Charge Dock, adapter not stated 29% to 95% in about 23 min
9to5Google, long-term video Not stated Desk top-ups 5 to 10 min adds 30 to 50%

Check the size column before the figures. Every two-day result with a size attached comes from the 45mm. The only 41mm run reached about 36 hours with its always-on setting not stated, and that reviewer charged every night anyway. I'd plan on the same.

Charging is where this watch earns its keep. 9to5Google timed the 45mm from 29% to 95% in about 23 minutes. Say you dock it while you pack lunch and hunt for your keys: that's most of a day back. Google's own times assume a 30W adapter that isn't in the box, so check the plug you'd pair it with. Nobody has timed a 41mm charge.

My readShort daytime top-ups beat overnight charging here, and that leaves the watch on your wrist for sleep tracking. Android Authority reported eight hours of sleep tracking taking under 5% of the battery.

One gap to know about: Google publishes no GPS battery figure. DC Rainmaker's burn rate on the 45mm works out to roughly 14 to 15 hours with GPS on, which is plenty for a long day out and not enough for a multi-day trek.

How accurate is the health tracking, and what works on which phone?

If you're buying a watch for the numbers, this is where the decision gets made. Heart rate and sleep are strong. GPS is the weak spot.

The Quantified Scientist wore both sizes against a Polar H10 chest strap. Correlation came out at 0.97 to 0.99 for cycling, and 0.99 for running on the 41mm. The 45mm scored 0.81 for running because one run locked near 158 bpm, which he calls a possible fit fluke. Weightlifting was weaker at 0.86 on both sizes. Sleep stages agreed with an EEG headband about 80% of the time for deep sleep, 77% for light and 70% for REM.

That's one person, two runs and four nights per watch. But Android Authority and DC Rainmaker also found heart rate close to a strap, so I trust the pattern.

GPS is another story. His tracks were cleaner than the Pixel Watch 3's and noisier than a Garmin's or an Apple Watch Ultra 3's, and Android Authority saw drift off the trail on hikes. For a Saturday 5K, that's fine. For a cyclist who wants exact lines, it isn't.

Feature On the Pixel Watch 4? What it needs
Tracking, Wallet, Maps, Gemini with Raise to Talk Yes Android 11 or newer, a Google Account and the Pixel Watch app
ECG and SpO2 Yes, free Select countries only
Blood pressure, insulin resistance and sleep breathing trends Yes, free since September 24, 2026 Nothing extra listed
Daily Readiness Score Yes The paid health tier; free on the Watch 5
Deeper health insights Yes The paid health tier
Offline Gemini, cloud GPS correction, rep tracking, Smart Wake No A Pixel Watch 5
Breathing Emergency Detection Depends on region EU only so far
Satellite SOS LTE models only US only when checked; no carrier plan needed
Pairing a chest strap No It can only broadcast its own heart rate
iPhone No Not supported

What the table tells you: no health feature needs a Pixel phone, but region and the paid tier gate a few. That tier was called Fitbit Premium when the watch launched. If tracking is your main reason to buy, compare it with the best smartwatches for health tracking first.

Is it still fast, and how long will Google keep updating it?

Speed isn't what you give up with the older model. 9to5Google's long-term video describes three months with no crash, and slowdowns only below about 10% battery. Droid Life puts the Watch 5's chip at about 20% faster, and I couldn't find a benchmark that sets the two side by side.

The software is current too. Wear OS 7 reached the Watch 4 in June 2026, as 9to5Google reported, with a retrained Raise to Talk gesture, Emergency Sharing tied into fall and crash detection, and reworked media controls. The AI watch face generator followed in October 2026.

Now the fine print. Google guarantees updates until at least October 2028. Its page promises security updates and says feature drops may be included, with no count of Wear OS versions. So a buyer today gets a little under two years of certainty, against nearly three on a Watch 5. Android Authority reports five OS upgrades for the Galaxy Watch 9, if a long run matters most.

And the unknowns? Whether the workout builder reaches the Watch 4 isn't confirmed, and satellite texting has no date. Gemini has limits as well: it couldn't answer DC Rainmaker's questions about his own training data and opened the Fitbit app instead.

My call: if offline Gemini is the reason you want a Pixel Watch, buy the 5. If it isn't, the 4 runs the same software today.

What do owners report, and what has been fixed?

One complaint matters most right now, and it's recent. From late October 2026, owners on r/PixelWatch reported sudden battery drain, as relayed by 9to5Google. One 45mm Watch 4 owner went from up to 2.5 days to under a day, while many commenters saw no change at all. Google acknowledged the issue for a small number of users, and Android Authority's follow-up says a fix began rolling out on November 3, 2026. No build number came with it.

Does buying the newer watch dodge it? No. The reports cover the Pixel Watch 2 through the Pixel Watch 5.

Reported issue Status
Sudden battery drain, late October 2026 Fix rolling out, says Google. Not yet confirmed by owners
GPS tracks broken in cycling and walking modes, seen in Europe by DC Rainmaker Google was investigating. No fix confirmed
Raise to Talk failing about one time in ten, and triggering by accident Gesture retrained in Wear OS 7. No check of the result published
Notifications stopping with a Galaxy Z Fold 7, per 9to5Google No fix confirmed
Switching Google accounts on the phone signs Gemini out on the watch No fix confirmed
Google Home doorbell alerts arriving without an image No fix confirmed
Automatic workout detection missing activities at launch Walk detection improved by February 2026. Fixed for walks only

Most of that list is a single outlet's experience, not a pattern across owners, and I'd weigh it that way. The GPS bug is the one I'd take seriously if you ride in Europe, because nothing published says it was fixed.

Heads-upIf a new watch drains fast in its first week, don't write it off as normal 41mm behavior. Install every update, give it a few days, and keep an eye on your return window. A factory reset without restoring a backup helped most affected owners, per Android Authority.

That warning costs you ten minutes of attention in week one. After that, the durability reports are calm: three months on a dock with no failed charge in the long-term video.

41mm or 45mm, and is LTE worth paying for?

If the battery figures made you nervous, this choice fixes most of it. Pick the 45mm unless your wrist is small.

41mm 45mm
Weight, no band 31.0 g 36.7 g
Battery 325 mAh 455 mAh
Claimed life, always-on Up to 30 h Up to 40 h
Claimed full charge About 45 min About 60 min
Wrist range 130 to 210 mm 150 to 215 mm
Independent battery result About 36 h, one review About two days, 9to5Google and DC Rainmaker
Running heart rate vs chest strap 0.99 0.81, with one locked run

The table says the bigger watch buys you 40% more battery for under 6 g. Google told The Quantified Scientist both sizes share the same sensors, so accuracy isn't the tiebreaker. He found the 41mm small on an average male wrist, and its small band is shorter than the 45mm's. Typing on the 41mm keyboard is harder too, per 9to5Google.

So the 41mm vs 45mm size advice comes down to one rule: go small only if the big one won't sit flat on your wrist. Buying for a slim wrist that sleeps in a watch? Then the 41mm is right, and a daily dock is the trade.

LTE is a separate question. It's the only route to Satellite SOS, which works without a carrier plan but was US only when checked, and handles emergency messages only. Google includes it free for two years after launch, and that clock started in October 2025. What it costs afterward isn't known.

Calls and data on LTE do need a plan. If you never leave the house without your phone, I'd take Wi-Fi and stop there.

Final verdict: is the Pixel Watch 4 still the smarter buy?

It comes down to one figure you'll only see on the day: the gap between the two watches. At Google's store, the Watch 4 costs less than the Watch 5. If that saving is real money to you, the older watch is the smarter buy, because you give up very little you can see or feel.

What you do give up is easy to list. One year of guaranteed updates. Offline Gemini. The cloud GPS correction. A free readiness score. If none of those made you wince, you have your answer. If the gap is small, though, I'd put it toward the Watch 5 and take the extra year.

And if a Watch 4 is already on your wrist? Keep it. the5krunner puts it in one line: "If you own a Pixel Watch 4, keep it." I agree, and it matches what I concluded about the newer watch.

Whichever way you go, buy the 45mm if it fits, and plan on short daily top-ups in place of a night on the charger. Think of a Sunday evening before a work trip: ten minutes on the dock while you pack, and you're covered until you land.

Still not sold on a Pixel? The Pixel Watch 5 alternatives lay out the other routes. The Garmin Venu 4 is the pick for days between charges, and Galaxy phone owners should start with the Galaxy Watch 9.

Pixel Watch 4 (41mm / 45mm) specs

Compatibility
Most Android 11+ phones; needs the Pixel Watch app
Display
41mm or 45mm domed AMOLED LTPO, up to 3000 nits
Battery
Up to 30h (41mm) or 40h (45mm) with always-on display
GPS
Built-in dual-frequency GPS
Water Rating
5 ATM and IP68

What the experts found

Android AuthorityNo numeric score; Editor's Choice badge

The best Wear OS watch for Android users, most of all Pixel owners: refined design, top-tier heart rate accuracy, better battery and charging and repairable parts, held back by middling GPS, no sapphire glass and Fitbit Premium paywalls.

A stunning display, charging fast enough to end battery anxiety and Raise to Talk as the reason to buy; older Pixel Watch owners should consider it, Pixel Watch 3 owners should not upgrade.

The strongest overall device on Android for raw health data: heart rate among the best and sleep staging on par with Apple and Oura; GPS is better than the Pixel Watch 3 but still noisier than Garmin, Coros, Suunto or the Apple Watch Ultra 3.

Also consider

Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)
Best if the price gap is small

Google Pixel Watch 5 (41mm, Wi-Fi)

The same case, screen and dock with a faster chip, 64 GB of storage, offline Gemini and guaranteed updates to October 2029. The 41mm is still a daily-charge watch, and coaching needs Google Health Premium.

$299.99$399.99Save 25%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

View on Amazon
Garmin Venu 4 (45mm)
Best for days between charges

Garmin Venu 4 (45mm)

Garmin lists up to 12 days in smartwatch mode, or 4 with the always-on display, plus multi-band GPS, and it works with iPhone and Android. The metal case is heavy for sleep, and it has no full onboard maps.

$449.99$549.99Save 18%

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

Early Black Friday Deal

View on Amazon
Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)
Best for Galaxy phone owners

Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 (44mm Bluetooth)

Thinner at 8.6 mm on the 44mm, with a sapphire screen and ECG and sleep apnea checks that need a Galaxy phone. Plan on a nightly charge, since full charges run from about 1.5 hours to nearly 3.

$408.99

as of Nov 16, 2026, 00:00 UTC

View on Amazon

Pixel Watch 4 (41mm / 45mm): frequently asked questions

Is the Pixel Watch 4 still worth buying now that the Pixel Watch 5 is out?

Yes, if it costs clearly less on the day you buy. The case, screen, heart rate sensor, dock and battery claims match the Pixel Watch 5, and it already runs Wear OS 7. You give up offline Gemini, cloud GPS correction and one year of guaranteed updates. If the gap is small, I'd buy the Watch 5.

Should I upgrade from a Pixel Watch 4 to a Pixel Watch 5?

No, and I'd say that plainly. You'd be paying for a faster chip, more storage and offline Gemini inside the same watch. The free health trends and Wear OS 7 already reached the Watch 4. Keep it until the battery fades, and remember that battery can be replaced.

How long will the Pixel Watch 4 get updates?

Google's update schedule guarantees software updates until at least October 2028, three years from launch. That is a little under two years for someone buying today. The Pixel Watch 5 is listed to October 2029. Google promises security updates and says feature drops may be included.

Does the Pixel Watch 4 work with an iPhone or a Samsung phone?

It doesn't work with an iPhone. It pairs with most phones on Android 11 or newer through the Pixel Watch app, Samsung phones included, and no health feature is tied to a Pixel phone. One 9to5Google reviewer did see notifications stop at times with a Galaxy Z Fold 7.

How long does the Pixel Watch 4 battery last?

About two days on the 45mm with the always-on display on, going by 9to5Google and DC Rainmaker. The 41mm reached about 36 hours in its only published run, so I'd plan on a daily charge. Google's own claims are up to 40 hours and 30 hours.

Do you need a subscription for the Pixel Watch 4?

Not for the basics. Tracking, ECG and the blood pressure, insulin resistance and sleep breathing trends are free. The Daily Readiness Score and the deeper insights sit behind Google's paid health tier on the Watch 4. LTE models also need a carrier plan for calls and data.

Will the Pixel Watch 4 get offline Gemini?

It isn't expected to. the5krunner lists offline Gemini, cloud GPS correction, strength rep tracking and Smart Wake as Pixel Watch 5 only. The Watch 4 does have Gemini with Raise to Talk when it's connected, and Wear OS 7 retrained that gesture.

Does the Pixel Watch 4 come with a charger?

It comes with the Quick Charge Dock, whose cable is fixed to it, but no power adapter. Google's charging times assume a 30W adapter sold separately. Chargers from older Pixel Watches don't fit, so don't count on reusing one.

Keep reading

Google Pixel Watch 4 (41mm / 45mm)View on Amazon